3 level-headed takeaways from the Tesla-New York Times kerfuffle

The Week
Despite a brutal New York Times review, people will probably still buy electric cars.
.

View photo

Despite a brutal New York Times review, people will probably still buy electric cars.

The back-and-forth has been emotional and bizarre. But reasonable people can still learn lessons from this strange affair

One of the weeks' biggest internet brouhahas centered on New York Times reporter John M. Broder, who test-drove a new electric Tesla Model S that ran out of power on a rather chilly trip from Washington, D.C. to Boston. Elon Musk, the forward-thinking billionaire behind the car company, alleges that The Times report was an outright lie, and released the car's data logs. Musk says the data demonstrates that the reviewer sabotaged his trip by failing to charge the Model S properly, neglecting to drive at correct cruising speeds, and intentionally draining the car's battery by driving around in aimlessly in a parking lot.

The Times fired back, this time with Broder dissecting Musk's assertions line-by-line. (If you really must, you can read all the nitty-gritty details here.)

SEE ALSO: How credit report errors are hurting millions of Americans

The back-and-forth has been bizarre, to say the least. So what can a reasonable person learn from this whole kerfuffle? Here are three lessons:

1. The New York Times probably doesn't have an anti-Tesla agenda
Musk, as the guy behind PayPal, SpaceX, and Tesla, is something of a hero in the tech world. And because Tesla is a glitzy electric car company with aspirations to lower carbon emissions and usher in a new era of clean, functional energy, some of Musk's supporters are accusing The Times (or Broder, at least) of being in the pocket of Big Oil, an assertion that is totally unfounded. The allegations don't really pass the smell test, either. Will Oremus at Slate sums it up best: "Perhaps the most convincing statistic in Broder's rebuttal is the number of times he called Tesla personnel throughout the trip to ask for help getting the car to its destination: 'About a dozen,' he says. That's hardly what you'd expect from a man 'determined' to get the car to die so he could embarrass Musk and Co. in his review."

SEE ALSO: What the American Airlines-US Airways merger means for customers

2. Driving an electric car requires careful planning
"Like many such controversies, common ground turns out to be easier to find than you might think," says John Voelcker at Green Car Reports. "It's a fact that electric-car range falls in colder temperatures." Broder chose to drive from DC to Boston during one of the coldest months of the year, and Tesla should have considered the implications of such a test a little more thoroughly beforehand. Broder, for his part, surely could have spent more time researching exactly how the car's elaborate charging system worked before setting off on his trip. And keep in mind: A reviewer from CNN was able to replicate the same trip — albeit in different weather conditions — without any problems. The big takeaway: Driving electric cars, especially in cold weather and with charging stations few and far between, takes some advance planning.

3. Tesla will probably end up the big winner, in spite of it all
Yes, Broder's initial review was brutal. And despite Musk's claims, Broder's report does seem to be an honest account of a reasonable driver running into a real set of problems. Nonetheless, the controversy is drumming up all sorts of buzz for Tesla's Model S, and getting the electric car in the minds of people who had otherwise never heard of it. And inevitably, it will get easier to drive the Model S. More Supercharger stations will be built, battery technology will undoubtedly get better, and early adopters will still open their pocketbooks to get their hands on a shiny new Tesla. Here, at least, the old adage holds true: Any publicity is good publicity.

SEE ALSO: Apple's hedge-fund problem: Can the company remain independent?

View this article on TheWeek.com Get 4 Free Issues of The Week

Other stories from this section:

Like on Facebook - Follow on Twitter - Sign-up for Daily Newsletter
View Comments (13)

Recommended for You

  • US billionaire says WWII Japanese ship found in Philippines

    Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen said Wednesday he had found one of Japan's biggest and most famous battleships on a Philippine seabed, some 70 years after American forces sank it during World War II. Excited historians likened the discovery, if verified, to finding the Titanic, as they hailed the…

    AFP
  • Central Florida man killed by police serving search warrant

    By Barbara Liston ORLANDO, Fla. (Reuters) - A 26-year-old Central Florida man died after being shot in the face early on Wednesday morning by a sheriff’s deputy attempting to serve a search warrant in a narcotics investigation, authorities said. The Volusia County Sheriff’s Office reported in a…

    Reuters
  • 175-Pound Pit Bull Hulk Shatters Misconceptions About the Breed

    This dog just may be the world's largest Pit Bull. Only 18-months-old, Hulk weighs a hefty 175 pounds. He's also best friends with a 3-year-old boy.

    ABC News
  • Chad president tells Boko Haram leader to surrender or face death

    By Madjiasra Nako N'DJAMENA (Reuters) - President Idriss Deby of Chad said on Wednesday he knew the whereabouts of Abubakar Shekau, the leader of the Nigerian militant group Boko Haram, and called on him to surrender or risk being killed. Chad's army has waged a series of battles against Boko Haram…

    Reuters
  • Passengers use emergency slides after landing in Denver

    DENVER (AP) — Passengers on an American Airlines flight from Charlotte, North Carolina, were forced to slide off the plane on emergency chutes soon after landing in Denver on Wednesday.

    Associated Press
  • Australians on Indonesia death row arrive on execution island

    Two Australian drug smugglers were taken Wednesday to an Indonesian island where they will be executed despite frantic diplomatic efforts to save them, as Prime Minister Tony Abbott said Australia was "revolted" by their looming deaths. Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran, the ringleaders of the…

    AFP
  • France, Cameroon wouldn't take foreigner later shot by LAPD

    LOS ANGELES (AP) — A homeless foreigner shot to death by Los Angeles police was in the country illegally after serving time for a bank robbery but couldn't be deported because no country would take him, U.S. immigration authorities said Wednesday.

    Associated Press
  • U.S. may review 1959 airplane crash that killed Buddy Holly

    (Reuters) - U.S. transportation safety investigators said on Wednesday they are reviewing a request to reopen a probe into the 1959 airplane crash that killed musicians Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens, J.P. Richardson, better known as "The Big Bopper," and their pilot. The original investigation 56…

    Reuters
  • View

    Turkish jetliner skids off on runway (9 photos)

    A Turkish Airlines jet landing in dense fog in the Nepalese capital Wednesday skidded off a slippery runway but there were no serious injuries, officials said. Officials at Kathmandu's Tribhuwan International Airport said the plane with 238 people on board was coming from Istanbul when the…

    Yahoo News
  • 'Thousands' of Russian troops in east Ukraine: US envoy

    The United States' senior envoy to Europe alleged Wednesday that Russia had deployed "thousands and thousands" of troops to neighboring Ukraine. Speaking to a congressional foreign affairs committee, Assistant Secretary of State Victoria Nuland also told US lawmakers that Russia was flooding…

    AFP58 mins ago
  • Former marine reported killed in Syria

    A former Royal Marine has become the first Briton to be killed while fighting with Kurdish forces battling Islamic State jihadists in Syria, leaving his family "devastated" Wednesday. Konstandinos Erik Scurfield, 25, died on Monday in a battle with IS militants, a source in the Kurdish People's…

    AFP
  • Senate fails to override Obama's veto of Keystone XL approval

    By Susan Cornwell WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Senate failed on Wednesday to override President Barack Obama's veto of legislation approving the Keystone XL oil pipeline, leaving the controversial project to await an administration decision on whether to permit or deny it. The Senate mustered…

    Reuters
  • Killers sought in deaths of 300,000 chickens in South Carolina

    By Harriet McLeod CHARLESTON, S.C. (Reuters) - Revenge may be the motive for the killings in South Carolina of more than 300,000 commercial chickens worth about $1.7 million over the past two weeks, authorities said on Monday. Birds have been found dead of unnatural causes in 16 chicken houses at…

    Reuters
  • View

    Hello kitty and kitty and lots more kitties on Japanese island where cats rule (17 photos)

    An army of feral cats rules a remote island in southern Japan, curling up in abandoned houses or strutting about in a fishing village that is overrun with felines outnumbering humans six to one. Originally introduced to the mile-long island of Aoshima to deal with mice that plagued fishermen's…

    Yahoo News
  • Survivor testifies about 2 friends stabbed, bound, drowned

    PHILADELPHIA (AP) — A man who survived being beaten, bound, stabbed in the neck and kicked into the Schuylkill River took the stand in a hearing Tuesday and described the night his two friends lost their lives.

    Associated Press
  • Americans Love K-Cups, but Their Creator Regrets Inventing Them

    Now it seems that John Sylvan, the inventor of the tiny containers, is firmly on Team #KillTheKCup too. “No matter what they say about recycling, those things will never be recyclable,” said Sylvan.

    Takepart.com
  • Paris Hilton brother Conrad to plead guilty to plane assault

    LOS ANGELES (AP) — Paris Hilton's youngest brother, Conrad, agreed to plead guilty to assaulting flight attendants on a trip from London to Los Angeles last year when authorities say he called other passengers "peasants" and threatened to kill crew members.

    Associated Press
  • Father says no proof his son is 'Jihadi John'

    The father of "Jihadi John" said in an interview published Wednesday that there was no proof that his son was the Islamic State executioner, adding there were a number of "false rumours" circulating. "There is nothing that proves what is being circulated in the media, especially through video clips…

    AFP