Should Apple make a bigger, bolder 'iPhone Plus'?

The Week
The bigger the better? The oversized Samsung Galaxy Note II has been a massive success.
.

View photo

The bigger the better? The oversized Samsung Galaxy Note II has been a massive success.

The iPhone 5 might be getting a big sibling, with new rumors swirling of a larger phone with a 4.8-inch screen

Big phones are a hit. Samsung, despite the prognostications of some tech bloggers, is on track to sell 10 million of its Galaxy Note II globally since it launched last fall, leaving little doubt that a market for 5-inch phone-tablet hybrids is out there. 

Now Apple wants in on the big-phone* action, according to a recent report from the China Times, and could be plotting a larger iPhone to compliment its existing line of iOS products. Insiders say that a new "iPhone Math" — which Instapaper inventor and technology writer Marco Arment has re-christened the "iPhone Plus" (more on that in a bit) — will launch alongside the iPhone 5S sometime in June. The new, larger handset is said to feature a 4.8-inch screen and an 8-megapixel camera. As with all Apple rumors, take this all with a grain of salt. [*Consider this a motion to strike the marketer term "phablet" from everyone's vocabulary.]

SEE MORE: Is Apple already testing the iPhone 6?

Some think it will actually happen. Writing at his blog, Arment says he thinks Apple will surprise everyone with an iPhone Plus, and points out that it's possible to keep "the pixel dimensions the same as the iPhone 5," meaning "no app changes would be necessary" for app-makers. Images on the larger phone, instead of stretching and distorting, would scale correctly. Apple has already shown a new willingness to cater to market demand with the iPad Mini and the 4-inch screen of the iPhone 5. Arment even created a nifty mock-up demonstrating how an iPhone Plus would fit cleanly into the company's current product lineup of phones and tablets. 

Others big-phone advocates are even more brazenly pushing for Apple to release an iPhone Plus. Business Insider's new resident air travel expert Henry Blodget, who hasn't exactly kept his family's love for Apple products a secret, is also jumping onboard the big-screen bandwagon. He argues that Apple "absolutely has to make an iPhone with a bigger screen" to regain its mojo:

A couple of weeks ago, I was riding down an elevator when the person in front of me fired up a Galaxy, and I thought to myself, "wow."

Last week, I watched a friend reviewing some videos he had taken of an event on a Galaxy, and I again thought to myself, "wow." […]

And as much as I wanted to reassure myself that I had made the right choice, my eyes were telling me otherwise:

That bigger screen is awesome. [Business Insider]

Then there's Wall Street. Apple is down 35 percent from its record-setting peak five months ago. While $453 per share is still nothing to sneeze at, investors are still worried that the company may be losing its touch. 

SEE MORE: Is Apple working on a cheap iPhone?

Bottom line: We have no way of knowing what Apple is going to do. But here's how the evidence stacks up:

• A new market for large phones exists.
• Changing the screen size wouldn't pose a problem for app-makers.
• Apple has shown its willingness to offer a variety of products in different sizes.

SEE MORE: Google Maps returns to the iPhone: 'Free, fast, and fantastic'

So, yes, a bigger, bolder iPhone Plus will inevitably find the right set of hands — when or if it's ever released. If the Tim Cook-era has demonstrated anything, it's that Apple is less stodgy than it has ever been, and the company doesn't mind entering new product categories even if it is a step or two behind the competition.

View this article on TheWeek.com Get 4 Free Issues of The Week

Other stories from this topic:

Like on Facebook - Follow on Twitter - Sign-up for Daily Newsletter
View Comments