Apple's Cheap iPhone Denial Is Under Official Review

The Atlantic
Apple's Cheap iPhone Denial Is Under Official Review
.

View photo

Apple's Cheap iPhone Denial Is Under Official Review

About those cheap iPhones that weren't, it turns out Apple's Phil Schiller might not have said the exact words that "they will never be the future." Reuters has withdrawn a report, which quoted an interview with the Apple executive in the Shanghai Evening News, that seemed to debunk multiple reports this week that the company was developing a phone built with cheaper parts that could be available for as little as $99 by the end of the year.

RELATED: Looks Like Apple Lost Another Prototype iPhone in a Bar

Since wide coverage of the company's apparent dismissal of the rumor, the Chinese paper's story "was subsequently updated with substantial changes to its content," Reuters said in explaining why it took down its own story. What exactly those changes entail, remains unclear. A Chinese-language article dated January 9 is still hosted hereSome blogs suggest that this is the original article, with nothing changed. Based on Google's rudimentary Translate feature, it's hard to tell.

RELATED: Confirmed: Apple Is Showing Us Some New Stuff Next Week

Apple had confirmed that Schiller's interview with the Shanghai Evening News was "official," a spokesperson told The Next Web. But that doesn't necessarily mean the paper got the quotes right, or that something wasn't literally lost in translation. The Next Web, which had some help translating, has not yet updated their post. 

RELATED: Everyone Overreacted About the New iPhone Adapter (and Everything Else)

Schiller's on-the-record remarks came as a surprise in the first place. Apple doesn't often address rumors. Plus, the tech community seemed to be in the midst of convincing itself that a cheap iPhone made sense. People like Daring Fireball's Jonathan Gruber, who has close ties to all those mysterious sources we hear about, said things like "this doesn't mean Apple isn’t going to produce a cheaper iPhone" — even though a quote like the one Schiller gave the Chinese paper means exactly that. 

RELATED: iPhone 5 Is a Hot Item for Thieves

The Reuters report suggests that Schiller's remarks may have been taken out of context, or simply that their reporter may have mistranslated the Shanghai Evening News We've reached out to Reuters for clarification on what kind of updates led to the story's removal and will update once we hear back. 

View Comments (19)