COMMENTARY | According to The Daily Caller, college professors don't think as highly of our 40th president, Ronald Reagan, as they should. Out of 284 professors, only 16 percent identified themselves as politically conservative and only 40 percent included Reagan among their list of the top 10 presidents. By contrast, a 2011 Gallup poll found Americans are most likely to say that Reagan was the greatest president, with almost 20 percent of respondents naming him number one.
I like Ronald Reagan but find this witch-hunt against "uber-liberal" college profs to be insulting, and misguided.
First of all, how were these 284 college professors selected? If one wants to skew data to demonize professors as liberals, they could poll 284 professors at liberal arts, fine arts and performing arts colleges in liberal areas such as New York and San Francisco to guarantee a higher percentage of nonconservative academics. Were any of the colleges and universities in conservative areas such as west Texas?
Second, there have been a lot of presidents. Forty-four so far. Who is to say there are not 10 former presidents likely to be ranked superior to Reagan? Reagan, after all, was not without scandal nor controversy such as the notorious Iran-Contra affair. Perhaps America's first several presidents got high marks as being Founding Fathers and all, then others like Andrew Jackson, Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson, Franklin Roosevelt and John Kennedy rounded out the rest.
Simply put, if you know all your presidents it's not hard to find 10 good ones from before the 1980s.
Finally, contrasting the opinion of professors, many of whom are likely to be far savvier in terms of historical knowledge than the general public, with that of a mass poll of laymen is misleading. The public might name Reagan as the best president because he is one of the few names they know.
As a world history teacher I can count on one hand how many presidents most of my students can name. Maybe the general public names Reagan as best commander-in-chief because they always show '80s Cold War flicks like Red Dawn and Top Gun on TV and '80s-retro is a popular genre.
I like Reagan, but the poll is too misleading.




170 comments