David vs. David

Party loyalty: Too many voices and no loyalty translates to gridlock in the U.S.

David vs. David
U.S. President Barack Obama delivers the State of the Union address to a joint session of Congress on Capitol Hill in Washington

View photo

U.S. President Barack Obama delivers the State of the Union address to a joint session of Congress on …

There is an existential difference between our governments: the U.S. federal system and the Canadian parliamentary system have little philosophical compatibility.

These are design structure differences, and those that whinge about the “failures and shortcomings” of their respective systems need to understand root causes — and then perhaps shut up.

The United States is a republic, and its legislative structure is designed for gridlock. U.S. founding fathers were more fearful of dictatorship than of governing paralysis. Indeed, if a proposal doesn’t have very substantial support, it will invariably fail. Consequently, this reality is reflected in our intricate assortment of checks and balances with essentially co-equal Legislative/Congressional bodies (the House of Representatives and Senate), each elected and completely independent of the other. Consequently, either can defeat legislation passed by the other, regardless of the consequences. The Executive branch (President and cabinet) stands entirely separately with the president able to veto any legislation passed by Congress, action reversible only by a two-thirds majority of both houses of Congress.

Underpinning this schema for deadlock is the electoral reality that presidents are elected independently of Congress — and vice versa. Thus neither owes any loyalty to the other. Indeed, regardless of party label, individual members of Congress are de facto free agents. Loyalty to the president is a personal commitment, not institutional let alone obligatory. For example, in contrast to Canada, the president cannot appoint “his” candidate in a district, cannot expel someone selected by a primary election from nomination, and cannot jettison that individual from caucus. Thus if an individual wins the party nomination, regardless of whether he or she is personally odious, that individual can run as a member of the party and be elected.

Moreover, there is no party platform worthy of the name. To be sure, at every-four-year presidential conventions, a “platform” is devised but it is forgotten before its last nail is driven, and it would be risible for someone to complain that an individual isn’t acting in accord with the platform.

The upshot is that each member of Congress is a freelance/independent agent. Gathering a consensus for any issue is akin to herding chickens. Each individual “rooster” must be persuaded that such a position is in their interest and their feathers unruffled. Egos are made for stroking. To be sure, there are substantial numbers of representatives and senators who will axiomatically support/oppose a proposal depending on their party label. But such agreement reflects individual choice rather than compulsion, and even ostensible party loyalists can offer a “Trudeau salute” if they believe a proposal conflicts their personal interests. Hence, the need for deal cutting and arguments sweetened by bribes.

A Canadian power structure would be to die for so far as a U.S. president is concerned. One might imagine presidential willingness to sell his soul (little as it might be worth on current theological markets) and/or sacrifice a first born to secure control akin to that enjoyed by any Canadian prime minister, even in a minority government. Friendly dictator? We see “dictator” as the key word in that pairing with the powers exercised by the Canadian prime minister mind-boggling in dimension. In contrast, one could say that every U.S. government is a minority government so far as attempting to construct a coalition to pass legislation — with the exception that the president can be defeated on any/every issue without having to call an election.

Any student of Canadian politics knows Pierre Trudeau’s maxim that 100 yards from Parliament Hill, MPs are nobodies. They exist as physical projections of the party label and elected primarily as a reflection of such; an Independent is a pitiful creature in the Canadian system. Regardless of how personally popular, if forced out of the party (remember John Nunziata?), they usually are defeated in the next election.

Thus while a U.S. congressman is independent by definition, party support is hardly a given and each must devote substantial effort to raising funds not just to campaign against opposing party candidates, but to beat back challengers from their own party.

So a Canadian wanting to introduce a “forlorn hope” (private member) bill should immigrate to the United States where countless bills on every topic are introduced — and never move beyond the congressional letter to constituents announcing it. And if you don’t want to be a trained seal, don’t get in the water.

David T. Jones is a retired State Department Senior Foreign Service Career Officer and a frequent contributor to American Diplomacy. During a career that spanned over 30 years, he concentrated on politico-military issues, serving for the Army Chief of Staff. He is co-author of Uneasy Neighbor(u)rs, a study of American-Canadian bilateral concerns and has published several hundred articles, columns, and reviews on U.S. - Canadian bilateral issues and general foreign policy.

View Comments

Recommended for You

  • The Poop on Pooping: 5 Misconceptions Explained

    Here is the truth behind five common misconceptions about defecating. Misconception No. 1: Daily pooping is normal, and optimal.

  • Children's corpses reveal desperate attempts to escape Korean ferry

    By Jungmin Jang and Ju-min Park MOKPO/SEOUL (Reuters) - South Korean divers swam though dark, cold waters into a sunken ferry on Wednesday, feeling for children's bodies with their hands in a maze of cabins, corridors and upturned decks as they searched for hundreds of missing. Writing by Nick…

  • Reverse Mortgage: How it Works (Age 62 Plus)

    Educate yourself! Understand how a reverse mortgage works. Learn more now!

    AdChoices LendingTreeSponsored
  • Search for MH370 reveals a military vulnerability for China

    By Greg Torode and Michael Martina HONG KONG/BEIJING (Reuters) - When Chinese naval supply vessel Qiandaohu entered Australia's Albany Port this month to replenish Chinese warships helping search for a missing Malaysian airliner, it highlighted a strategic headache for Beijing - its lack of…

  • James Buchanan: Why is he considered America’s worst president?

    April 23 marks the birthday of James Buchanan, the man regarded by many historians as one of the worst—if not the worst—presidents of all time. So what did Buchanan do to earn the disrespect of so many people?

    National Constitution Center
  • Play

    DUI Hit-and-Run Driver Who Killed Cyclist Sentenced

    At an emotional hearing where cyclists demanded justice, Wendy Villegas was sentenced Tuesday to three years, eight months in prison for fatally striking 22-year-old cyclist Luis "Andy" Garcia in September 2013. Sara Welch reports from downtown Los Angeles for the KTLA 5 News at 1 on April 22, 2014.

    KTLA - Los Angeles
  • 9 indicted in kidnapping of NC prosecutor's father

    CHARLOTTE, N.C. (AP) — As the kidnappers pulled into a quiet, upscale golf course community, they thought they were about to abduct an assistant district attorney who sent a high-ranking gang member to prison for life, authorities said.

    Associated Press
  • Minnesota Man Accused of Murdering Teens Who Entered His Home

    Retiree Byron Smith Allegedly Told Police, 'I Wanted Him Dead'

    Good Morning America
  • Dead teen's mother claims negligence in deadly California crash: report

    (Reuters) - The mother of a 17-year-old student who was among 10 people killed in a highway crash in northern California earlier this month has sued FedEx Corp for negligence, California-based City News Service reported. More than 30 others were injured when a FedEx tractor-trailer crossed a…

  • Discover Your Dream Vacation on Carnival.com!

    Looking to get away somewhere warm like the Caribbean or the Bahamas? Discover your perfect cruise getaway with Carnival. Book now for great rates!

    AdChoices Carnival.comSponsored

    DEAR ABBY: I manage a group of 15 employees. A few months ago, I hired the wife of an old friend. Until now she has been a great employee, but recently she and a male co-worker have been taking lunches and breaks together in a way that leads me to believe they are flirting or have already crossed…

    Dear Abby
  • 'Piles and piles' of bodies in S. Sudan slaughter

    NAIROBI, Kenya (AP) — The townsfolk believed the mosque was safe. They crammed inside as rebel forces in South Sudan took control of the town from government troops. But it wasn't safe. Robbers grabbed their cash and mobile phones. Then gunmen came and opened fire on everyone, young and old.

    Associated Press
  • Pentagon scientists show off life-size robot

    US Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel got a first-hand look at a life-size robot that resembles Hollywood's "Terminator," the latest experiment by the Pentagon's hi-tech researchers. But unlike the cinematic version, the hulking Atlas robot is designed not as a warrior but as a humanitarian machine that…

  • 'Main Line' drug ring in Pennsylvania nets two prep school grads

    (Reuters) - Two graduates of an exclusive Pennsylvania prep school were charged with operating an extensive drug ring that dealt cocaine and marijuana to students at high schools and colleges in an affluent part of Philadelphia, authorities said on Tuesday. Neil Scott, 25, and Timothy Brooks, 18,…

  • Bus driver accused of bullying a special needs student and urging others to bully her as well

    An Olympia School District (OSD) bus driver in Washington state has been placed on leave after surveillance video caught him bullying a special needs student.

    Odd News
  • Former Iron Curtain still barrier for deer

    PRAGUE (AP) — The Iron Curtain was traced by an electrified barbed-wire fence that isolated the communist world from the West.

    Associated Press
  • All New 2014 Transit Connect

    If youre looking for a work van, you can get advice from your brother or from an economist. The numbers dont lie. Come see what we mean by that.

    AdChoices Ford Motor CompanySponsored
  • U.S. says will act 'in days' if no Russian action in Ukraine

    By Doina Chiacu and Patricia Zengerle WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The United States' government said on Monday it will decide "in days" on additional sanctions if Russia does not take steps to implement an agreement to ease tensions in Ukraine reached in Geneva last week. The steps include publicly…

  • Play

    Cops Break Down Teen`s Door After Video Game Revenge Prank

    Cops in New York and a teenager were the victims of a video game prank Tuesday afternoon. A SWAT team was called to a teenager`s home after beating another person in an online video game. Police say it was an act of revenge.

  • Ancelotti in frame for Man Utd job - reports

    Manchester United began their search for a new manager on Wednesday, with newspaper reports claiming that Real Madrid coach Carlo Ancelotti has emerged as a candidate to succeed David Moyes. Several British newspapers said that Ancelotti was being considered for the vacancy, along with Netherlands…

  • Repo man takes car with a sleeping 4-year-old in backseat

    A 4-year-old child is now home safe after being taken on a ride while he slept in the backseat of a car as it was repossessed.

    Odd News
  • Teen who stowed away on flight to Hawaii remains hospitalized

    A teenage boy who stowed away on a flight from California to Hawaii in the frozen, oxygen-deprived wheel well of a passenger jet remained hospitalized on Tuesday, two days after his death-defying jaunt over the Pacific Ocean, a Hawaii official said. The teenager, whose name has not been released,…

  • Letterman gets visit from his successor, Colbert

    NEW YORK (AP) — Stephen Colbert, who will take over for a retiring David Letterman on CBS' "Late Show" next year, revealed Tuesday that he almost worked for Letterman — twice.

    Associated Press
  • 360 Checking: The checking account that pays you.

    Say bye to paying fees and minimums and hello to earning interest with 360 Checking from Capital One 360. Open today and earn a $50 bonus.

    AdChoices Capital One 360Sponsored