The Lookout

Rejected Boy Scout receives outpouring of support

View gallery


Ryan Andresen, who turned 18 on Monday, was denied his Eagle Scout award. (Andresen family)

[Updated at 2:20 p.m. ET]

Ryan Andresen may have been shunned by the Boy Scouts, but not by scores of strangers who've stepped up to pledge their support over his plight.

The California teen made headlines around the world last week after his scoutmaster refused to approve his Eagle Scout award because Ryan is gay.

Since then, more than 350,000 people have signed an online petition urging the leaders of Troop 212 to ignore the Scouts' anti-gay policy and award Ryan the organization's highest honor.

"I'm just totally and completely blown away and amazed," said Ryan, who will appear on the "Ellen" TV talk show this Thursday. "I can't believe it. I really want to thank everyone for showing their support. It means so much to me."

His supporters include many former Scouts who say they plan to pledge their own coveted Eagle pins to Ryan.

"In my mind he's earned it simply by refusing to be anything other than who he is," Andrew Lanham wrote in an email to Yahoo News. "As an Eagle Scout, I'm appalled by the BSA's continuing bigotry. It sounds to me like Ryan is already one of my fellow Eagles, even if the organization won't recognize it."

Eric Andresen had to set up a post office box over the weekend to accommodate the number of people wanting to give his son their pins.

"We've been overwhelmed, especially with the overwhelming amount of positive support and the Eagles that have volunteered to turn in their medals, either back to [Boy Scouts of America] or to Ryan," he wrote in an email.

An alumnus of Ryan's hometown troop set up a Facebook page to invite others to pledge their pins and plan a gathering to honor the disavowed Scout.

"One's Eagle Ceremony is the crowning affirmation of all those great experiences, lessons, values, and friendships," Matthew Kimball wrote on the Facebook page. "It haunts me that my friends, people I've loved, admired, and respected, people that have been my greatest mentors, would deny Ryan this affirming experience."

Kimball, a third-generation Eagle, wrote that he meant no disrespect toward the Scouts and isn't trying to challenge the private organization's right to determine its criteria for membership and awards.

"But I do feel that it does its own self both harm and disrespect when it puts its principles, even were they to be unquestionably sound, before actual people, actual human beings—in this case, a young man who has undoubtedly endured an incredible amount of difficulty in reconciling who he is with a group of friends and mentors whom he admires and for whom he has striven for over a decade to emulate and make proud," he posted on Facebook.

View gallery


Ryan Andresen has been a Scout for 12 years. (Andresen family)

Under Scout rules, Eagle candidates must meet the requirements by their 18th birthday. Ryan, a Scout since he was 6, recently finished an extensive service project and the needed paperwork but hasn't been able to get his troop leader's approval. He turned 18 on Monday. The rules do provide for a 90-day window after a Scout's 18th birthday, but Ryan's father said the family has not heard from the troop leader.

"It hurts a lot," Eric Andresen wrote. "Ryan should have received an apology from the scoutmaster by now."

Ryan's scoutmaster has not returned messages from Yahoo News.

In addition to not meeting the group's membership standard on sexual orientation, a national spokesman for the Scouts said, Ryan also disagreed with the BSA's religious principles.

Eric Andresen objected to that portrayal.

"Ryan has never said anything about being atheist to anyone, because he's not," his father wrote. "Ryan has labeled himself as agnostic and continues to believe in a supreme being—he just hasn't figured out what form that is or how he wants to recognize it."

Officials with, an Internet social change platform, said the rapid response to Ryan's petition is one of the biggest they've seen in the site's four years.

"It's clear from this petition that many people around the country see the Boy Scouts' anti-gay policy as widely out of touch and this denial of Ryan's Eagle award particularly troubling," said's Mark Anthony Dingbaum.

View Comments (4843)

Recommended for You

  • Man with 'Islamic extremist leanings' attacks NY police

    The man who attacked New York City police officers with a hatchet before being shot dead was reported to have Islamic "extremist leanings" police and a monitoring group said. The man, identified in the US media as Zale Thompson, had posted an array of statements on YouTube and Facebook that…

  • Six bodies identified after decades in Oklahoma lake

    By Heide Brandes OKLAHOMA CITY (Reuters) - Oklahoma authorities have formally identified six people whose bodies were found in a western Oklahoma lake in 2013, bringing a resolution to missing persons mysteries that spanned decades, a spokeswoman for the state medical examiner said Thursday. The…

  • World War II airmen fly again in storied B-29

    BATON ROUGE, La. (AP) — The bomber best known for dropping the atomic bombs on Japan also flew countless other raids. Karnig Thomasian's final mission on a B-29 Superfortress ended in flames when bombs collided and exploded in the air over Burma in 1945.

    Associated Press
  • Prosecutors: Michigan girl meant to kill family

    PLYMOUTH TOWNSHIP, Mich. (AP) — A 15-year-old suburban Detroit girl accused of stabbing her younger brother as part of a plot to kill her family so that she could run off with a 23-year-old man was ordered held on $1 million bond Thursday.

    Associated Press
  • Pistorius shoves race, crime and punishment in South Africa's face

    By Ed Cropley PRETORIA (Reuters) - As Oscar Pistorius spent his first day behind bars this week, a suspected child rapist and murderer went on trial at the same Pretoria court in a case that has also provoked fierce debate about crime and punishment in post-apartheid South Africa. Although the two…

  • After 1st Ebola case in NYC, 3 others quarantined

    NEW YORK (AP) — A doctor who became New York City's first Ebola patient was praised for getting treatment immediately upon showing symptoms, and health officials stressed that the nation's most populous city need not fear his wide-ranging travel in the days before his illness began.

    Associated Press
  • Driver attacked after ice cream truck kills boy

    LOS ANGELES (AP) — Neighborhood residents attacked the driver of an ice cream truck after it struck and killed a 7-year-old boy riding a motorized bike in South Los Angeles, authorities said.

    Associated Press
  • Heads roll in Russia as more details emerge of Total crash

    Top Russian airport officials quit on Thursday as more employees were detained over the Moscow plane crash that killed the CEO of French oil giant Total. The driver of the snowplough that collided with Total boss Christophe de Margerie's plane as it was taking off from Moscow's Vnukovo airport late…

  • Ebola cases could spur lawsuits _ with big hurdles

    DALLAS (AP) — In a land of lawsuits, this case seems made for litigation: A doctor appears to miss a red flag, an Ebola diagnosis is delayed, and a patient dies. But this is Texas.

    Associated Press
  • Japan warns of increased activity at volcano near nuclear plant

    TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan warned on Friday that a volcano in southern Japan located roughly 64 km (40 miles) from a nuclear plant was showing signs of increased activity that could possibly lead to a small-scale eruption and warned people to stay away from the summit. The warning comes nearly a month…

  • Two dead in murder-suicide at Houston hospital: police say

    HOUSTON (Reuters) - Two health workers died on Wednesday in an apparent murder-suicide at the out-patient pharmacy of a major Houston hospital, police said. A woman who worked at Ben Taub Hospital was shot dead by a male co-worker, who then killed himself. The names of the two have not been…

  • Dancing priests become Internet sensation

    ROME (AP) — A video of a pair of dueling, dancing American priests studying in Rome has gone viral, following in the footsteps of a now-famous Italian nun whose Alicia Keys-esque voice won her a singing contest and a record contract.

    Associated Press
  • Lebanon army nabs beheading suspect in 'terror cell' raid

    Lebanese troops arrested a recruiter for the Islamic State group wanted for the beheading of a captured soldier, in a raid Thursday that netted more suspects and killed three gunmen, the army said. "A military intelligence unit carried out a security operation at dawn in the Dinniyeh area" of…

  • Marine murder case reveals US-Philippine sore spot

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — American forces are guarding Marine Pfc. Joseph Scott Pemberton, yet a ring of Filipino troops surrounds them. The seemingly redundant security effort around the suspect in a Philippine murder case reflects Manila's uneasy ties with Washington, its former colonial master.

    Associated Press
  • Mexico mayor accused of ordering attack on missing students

    Mexico on Wednesday ordered the arrest of the mayor of the city of Iguala, his wife and an aide, charging they masterminded last month's attack that left six students dead and 43 missing. Carrying torches and candles, tens of thousands of people marched through Mexico City and other cities to…

  • Paintings in national parks spark probe, furor

    SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — A series of colorful, eerie faces painted on rocks in some of the West's most famously picturesque landscapes has sparked an investigation by the National Park Service and a furor online.

    Associated Press
  • Six in quarantine in Connecticut as U.S. steps up Ebola checks

    By Richard Weizel WEST HAVEN, Conn. (Reuters) - Connecticut placed six West Africans who recently arrived in the United States under quarantine for possible Ebola exposure, a move that comes as the United States starts new restrictions on those coming from the countries hardest hit by the deadly…