Big League Stew

Masahiro Tanaka has partially torn UCL, but no surgery yet

Big League Stew
New York Yankees v Cleveland Indians

View photo

CLEVELAND, OH - JULY 8: Starting pitcher Masahiro Tanaka #19 of the New York Yankees pitches during the first inning against the Cleveland Indians at Progressive Field on July 8, 2014 in Cleveland, Ohio. (Photo by Jason Miller/Getty Images)

It's not the worst possible news for the New York Yankees, but it isn't good news, either: After getting an MRI and seeing the team doctor Thursday, right-hander Masahiro Tanaka was diagnosed with a partial tear of the UCL in his right elbow.

Yankees general manager Brian Cashman says Tanaka won't get surgery yet; instead, he'll rehab for six weeks and see if he can pitch. The injury could be similar to that sustained by Matt Harvey of the New York Mets, who considered rehab before deciding to undergo Tommy John elbow ligament replacement surgery. If Tanaka, 25, decides later on surgery, he'll miss the rest of this season and a good chunk of 2015 because of the 12-15 month rehab time expected.

Here's a glimpse into Harvey's thinking, via the beat writer for the Bergen (N.J.) County Record:


However, if the tear in Tanaka's elbow isn't as bad as Harvey's, if it's more like the one that Adam Wainwright of the St. Louis Cardinals sustained in 2011, a non-surgical course might work out for a while. Eventually, though, the ligament usually tears fully and surgery is required. At least 60 players, in the majors and minors, have gotten Tommy John surgery since Jan. 1 — a rate that leading physicians call an epidemic.

The New York Post reported first Wednesday that Tanaka was getting MRI on his elbow. An All-Star in his first season after coming from Japan as a free agent and signing for $155 million, Tanaka has performed better than most other pitchers in the majors. He dominated from April through June, but his past two starts yielded disappointing results — he allowed a combined nine runs and 19 hits — which also set off alarms.

Tanaka's numbers overall this season — 2.51 ERA with with 135 strikeouts in 129 1/3 innings — made him a leading candidate for AL Rookie of the Year and Cy Young. He's pitched a league-leading three complete games with one shutout. The Yankees have a 13-5 record in his starts.

New York already has lost CC Sabathia, Ivan Nova and Michael Pineda from their season-opening rotation. Nova also had Tommy John, and Sabathia might not pitch again this season because of a balky knee. Pineda's shoulder problems persist, though he might return in August.

Keeping Tanaka healthy probably is the only way the Yankees will continue to contend for the playoffs. Their record is 46-44 coming into Thursday. They're within three games of first place in the AL East, and in similar shape for the wild card.

More MLB coverage at Yahoo Sports:

- - - - - - -

David Brown is an editor for Big League Stew on Yahoo Sports. Have a tip? Email him at and follow him on Twitter!

Follow @AnswerDave

View Comments (107)

Recommended for You

  • Hiroshima bombing order offers glimpse into fateful day

    BOSTON (AP) — It's just a few cryptic notations on a badly yellowed sheet of paper, but it changed the course of world history.

    Associated Press
  • Florida triple murder may have been ritualistic killing: police

    The victims, identified as Voncile Smith, 77, John William Smith, 49, and Richard Thomas Smith, 47, were found dead on Friday, three days after police believe someone the family knew entered the home and killed them as part of a witchcraft ritual. "The elements of this case are odd, at best,"…

  • New York City's new drug threat: 'weaponized marijuana'

    It gives users super human strength, makes them impervious to pain and can be bought for as little as $2 across New York. Illegal synthetic marijuana, or "weaponized" marijuana as police are calling it, is spreading across New York, particularly the city's homeless population in search of a cheap…

  • Why 1 Small Nation Plays a Major Role in Peacekeeping

    For poor nations, standing up for world peace can be a profitable business.

  • ON SALE NOW: Chris Brown - One Hell of a Nite Tour

    Don’t miss Chris Brown performing with Kid Ink, Omarion, Fetty Wap, and Teyana Taylor this summer.

  • Two elite U.S. airmen die after parachute training accident

    Its cause has not been determined and an ongoing investigation could take up to a year to complete, the Air Force said in a statement. It identified the men as Sergeant Timothy Officer, 32, and Sergeant Marty Bettelyoun, 35. Both had served several tours of duty abroad and were part of a special…

  • Drone delivers bundle of drugs to prison yard, causes serious hoopla

    When a package containing heroin, marijuana and tobacco lands in a prison yard, things go pretty much the way you'd expect.

  • Calm Down, Internet: This Female Engineer Isn't False Advertising

    In cities around the world, ads in subway stations have become a flash point for social critique. In New York, two comedians filed a lawsuit when the Metropolitan Transit Authority refused to install their posters poking fun at Muslim stereotypes. Everyone is smart, creative, and hilarious," stated…
  • Play

    Newborn baby found in stroller in South Los Angeles

    A newborn baby, with his umbilical cord still attached, was found in a stroller near a church in South Los Angeles Tuesday.

    KABC – Los Angeles
  • Evidence mounts in trial of police officer in man's death

    CHARLOTTE, N.C. (AP) — In the trial of a white Charlotte police officer charged with killing a black man who was seeking help after a car crash, attorneys focused Tuesday on the immediate aftermath of the brief, violent encounter between the two men.

    Associated Press
  • Maryland boy beaten over cake died from head injuries: coroner

    A coroner has concluded that a 9-year-old Maryland boy who was fatally beaten over a missing piece of birthday cake died from head injuries, a spokeswoman for the agency said on Tuesday. The death of the boy, Jack Garcia, was a homicide, the spokeswoman for the District of Columbia's Office of the…

  • Use of batboys and girls suspended after 9-year-old's death

    KANSAS CITY, Mo. (AP) — The National Baseball Congress suspended using batboys and girls during its World Series games in Kansas following the death of a 9-year-old boy who was accidentally hit in the head with a bat during a game.

    Associated Press
  • Grandma Feels Disrespected When Her Advice Is Ignored

    DEAR ABBY: Whatever happened to respecting one's elders and recognizing grandparents as head of the family? I recently returned from visiting my son, his wife and my new grandchild. My son's wife and I had many disagreements on how to care for my grandchild. Instead of respecting my years of…

    Dear Abby
  • View

    70th Anniversary of Hiroshima bombing (39 photos)

    On two days in August 1945, U.S. planes dropped two atomic bombs, one on Hiroshima on August 6, one on Nagasaki on August 9, the first and only time nuclear weapons have been used. Their destructive power was unprecedented, incinerating buildings and people, and leaving lifelong scars on survivors,…

    Yahoo News
  • Obama warns of dangers to Israel if Iran deal blocked: U.S. Jewish leader

    By Jeffrey Heller JERUSALEM (Reuters) - President Barack Obama told U.S. Jewish leaders it was likely rockets would fall on Tel Aviv if a nuclear deal with Iran was blocked and military action ensued, one of them said on Wednesday. In a separate appeal to American Jews, Israeli Prime Minister…

  • AP Exclusive: Deaths of Yosemite jumpers remain a mystery

    FRESNO, Calif. (AP) — World-famous wingsuit flier Dean Potter had strapped his iPhone to the back of his head and hit record before jumping from a cliff in Yosemite National Park in what was to be an exhilarating flight through a V-shaped rocky formation — a route that left little margin for error.

    Associated Press
  • Nigeria names new head of state-run oil company

    Nigerian President Muhammadu Buhari has appointed a new head of the country's corruption-hit state oil company, weeks after after sacking the entire board, his spokesman said on Tuesday. Buhari took office on May 29 and axed Nigerian National Petroleum Company (NNPC) chief Joseph Thlama Dawha and…

  • London to New York in 1 hour? Airbus might be working on a plane faster than the Concorde

    Travelers who regularly fly from the U.S. to Europe and back should be thrilled to hear that Airbus might be developing a brand new superfast jet that would make the journey from London to New York in just one hour. That’s much faster than the Concorde jet that needed three and a half hours to…

    BGR News