Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    The Upshot

    NYC organization struggles to preserve ‘Tribute in Light’ memorial

    The 'Tribute in Light' illuminates the sky over the Brooklyn Bridge and lower Manhattan. (AP Photo/Mark Lennih …Six months after the World Trade Center attacks, as shell-shocked New Yorkers struggled to redefine the city and accept the new skyline, something beautiful appeared in the night sky.

    Two identical ghostly blue lights shot straight up from Ground Zero, right where the mammoth illuminated towers had once stood. It was chilling, it was touching, and, for some, it might have been difficult to look at night after night. But it was tasteful, and meaningful to so many.

    On Sept. 11 of every year since, the Municipal Arts Society has brought that giant public artwork, called the "Tribute in Light," back to the night sky.

    Luminous and visible from any point around the city, the twin lights fill the footprints of the towers. On a clear night, their brilliance extends far higher than even the real towers reached. On a cloudy night, they stretch straight into the heavens.

    This year, according to the New York Observer, may be their last.  The installation costs hundreds of thousands of dollars to stage each year, and the Municipal Arts Society, a nonprofit arts group, may retire it after the 10th-anniversary display.

    "It takes more than a week to produce 'Tribute in Light,'" the Municipal Arts Society told the paper. "The process starts Friday, Sept. 2, and continues through dusk on Sept. 11, when a switch is flipped and the powerful beams shoot four miles across the sky, visible for 60 miles around. Everything is done by hand by the crew of 30 electricians, lighting technicians, stagehands and production assistants."

    The Sept. 11, 2001, memorial lights shine in New York, Friday, Sept. 11, 2009. (AP Photo/Stephen Chernin)

    The lights project from the top of the Battery Parking Garage on Greenwich Street in Lower Manhattan, and the technicians spend the week arranging and testing "88 refrigerator-sized, 7,000-watt xenon searchlight bulbs so powerful that everyone handling them must wear eye protectors and special gloves."

    The Municipal Arts Society has only enough grant money to show the tribute one last time, according to news site DNAinfo.com.

    This week, the organization launched a fundraising drive to make the tribute, which started as a temporary memorial, truly permanent. They hope to raise an endowment of $15 million over the next couple of years.

    "It's become a symbol of that day," Municipal Arts Society vice president Christine Krische told DNAinfo.com of the blue beams. "It's the one thing everyone in New York and miles away can participate in. It's a communal thing."

     

    79 comments

    • Anonymous  •  8 mths ago
      cool
    • Jimbo  •  9 mths ago
      Want to really give a tribute to the fallen of 9/11 [ including fallen military of 2 wars] go to almost any place that rents movies [its on Netflix] and get the movie LOOSE CHANGE 9/11
      An American Coup . Watch and wonder are a couple of lights shining upward at the sky really a proper Tribute to the fallen.
    • The Irish Pirate ;p  •  9 mths ago
      Will and Jada Always! When it's good you know it.
    • Daniel  •  9 mths ago
      The lights are a memorial tribute, much better then a building, a park or a reflecting pond. The lights say, I'm still here with you and you need only to look to the night sky to know I'm there.
      We will Never Forget.
    • AJ Bigs  •  9 mths ago
      Excuse me, did everyone forget or perhaps temporarily overlooked the billions (you read it correctly BILLIONS) of dollars Americans and countries around the world donated to the victims of 9/11 and provided assistance to restore the states devastated by this disaster? Some of you don't even realize that had it not been for your fellow Americans and the generosity of other countries we may not be where we are today! Lets not forget that 9/11 set the USA on its path to a recession. Lets see ENRON (October 2011) costed the USA trillions of dollars and many hardworking folks lost their retirement benefits. Those unlawful transactions probably contributed 80% to the reason why we faced a recession. Three years following 9/11 this country was headed for a depression, ENRON brought G.W. Bush's term in like a lion and Bernie Madoff ended it with a lion's roar...why is it that whenever my party is in office we move closer to a recession and/or depression? I'll need to ponder that after I finish this comment...LOL. By the time G.W. Bush left office we were well into the beginning phase of a "great Depression (the signs were visible, our markets were down, folks began losing their job (especially if you worked on a government contract), Americans weren't spending because of market fears, the housing boom had ended. We were involved in two wars, we had the Enron scandal then the Madoff scandal which eliminated billions of folks retirement money. Not to mention we lost a few key allies because of false statements or vicious lies to get support. By 2007, the housing bubble was in full swing, but as usual we didn't pay any attention until it was too late. By then, we were faced with the "subprime mortage which I consider a banking scheme" that to present day has caused the most significant risk to our economy. Ripple effect is the number of families that lost their home to foreclosure, homelessness communities on the rise (including those in the so called "tent communities,") and more lay-offs! In 2011, we need to be more responsible in monitoring where are contributions for causes actually end up. Since Rumsfield announced on September 10, 2001 that $2.3 TRILLION dollars in funds had gone "MISSING" he should find those missing funds and provide these services on behalf of the American people. How ironic is that...Rumsfield announces $2.3 TRILLION missing dollars on the eve of 9/11?????
    • AKewl  •  9 mths ago
      Rick Perry will most likely let more high-rise buildings hit some jets all the while he's polishing his boots!
    • AKewl  •  9 mths ago
      Is George Dubya Dumya Bush going to read a children's book at the 9/11 Memorial? Ask him why Building #7 imploded and collapsed all by itself!
    • Glenn  •  9 mths ago
      our government should stop paying afganistan,iraq,and pakistan for not helpin fight the war
    • Duke of Earl  •  9 mths ago
      well the mayor of NY what his name Blownutts want to built a mosque on the site, to remember the people killed there ?
      • Rick 9 mths ago
        its actually not right on the site, its a few blocks away, and they do have freedom of religion just like Christians and Jews.....but it doesn't exactly mean i support it, it is no doubt morally wrong
      • Luis 9 mths ago
        @Rick Morally Wrong? Its not a training camp for Al Qaida operatives we're talking about, it's a mosque. Is building a church in Iraq "morally wrong" as well? Or is it only when it comes to Islam that morals come into play. Evil things are done in the name of religion AND science, we cannot blame an entire group of people by the actions of the most extreme.
    • Mary  •  9 mths ago
      Come on New Yorkers rough times are here for along time but if eveveryone gives just the price of that extra cup of morrning coffee This can go on for years Hy Maxwell House how about starting off This is New York I no longer live in the great state (wish Inever left) These people faced the fight of a life time GIVE ALREADY
    • steve1957  •  9 mths ago
      Keep these light's!
    • -YODE-  •  9 mths ago
      I think the lights should be on every night. Not just one day out of the year and how does cost hundreds of thousands dollars to setup lights for one night....
    • George  •  9 mths ago
      Pay tribute by stopping all aid to any Muslim country and just let them kill each other like they been doing for centuries..with the money we save lets drill for our own oil build more refineries that create jobs and get these disgusting subhumans out of our lives once and for all
    • Dread Pirate Roberts  •  9 mths ago
      If America really wanted a fitting tribute to the 9/11 victims... put Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld and Powell in prison.
      • remember the alamo 9 mths ago
        You are a whack job perv freak sicko. Losers like you should keep their pie holes shut. 3000 Americans are murdered by islamist terrorists and you resort to the same old tired unoriginall boring pile of rubbish.
    • Sadness  •  9 mths ago
      I am Sadness .I wish capture and who idea 9/11. Go to jail.
    • Valkyrie  •  9 mths ago
      The usual ninnies are online today with the usual asinine suggestions, including the always-popular demand that we eliminate foreign aid, because that way we can pay for EVERYTHING.

      "Hey, you LIBTARDS! quit spending all our money on other countries, and use that money here at home--although only use it for big, patriotic light shows--we don't want to see one PENNY of that money going to jobless benefits or infant nutrition or Head Start or teachers' salaries or anything communistic like that."

      Gah. The stupidity is lethal.

      In fact, US foreign aid in all forms adds up to a hair under 1% of our national budget. It pays for itself in goodwill, the exchange of vital information, and--when it is used to help victims of famine and warfare--as a minimal expression of our national humanity (it is only appropriate that the expression is minimal, since our national humanity is pretty minimal, too, as you can see by the strident demands that we stop helping starving and dying people in other countries, RIGHT THIS MINUTE).

      If you want to cut a bloated, ugly, pointless budget, why not start with the US military? By the most conservative estimates, it gobbles up 17-20% of the national budget; but that's misleading. Once you start counting the indirect subsidies--the portion of other areas of the national budget, like the Department of Energy, that in fact benefit the military--it consumes between 45 and 54%.

      In short, the military-industrial complex that Ike warned us about nearly 60 years ago is destroying us economically as well as culturally and politically, with a cost to US taxpayers that roughly equals the military spending of all the other countries on the earth put together.

      So if you want your patriotic light show, forget about grabbing that money back from starving Somalian children, and ask the Pentagon. They can spare it.
    • John  •  9 mths ago
      Why so expensive to operate? Aren't they using FREE solar power, and why aren't they using CFL's or LEDs?
      • GO 9 mths ago
        solar panels are not free and an array producing .6 MEGAwatts would not be small by any stretch of the imagination. Also, the CFLs and LEDs probably do not have the distance or would require major refocusing
      • John 9 mths ago
        Oh but I thought all this green technology was FREE and BETTER? [Said with a LOT of SARCASM.]
    • Vladi313  •  9 mths ago
      If you REALLY want a fitting tribute to the 9/11 victims, put Bush and Cheney in prison.
      • patrick 9 mths ago
        why?
      • Ray 9 mths ago
        -just dumb...
      • Vladi313 9 mths ago
        Why?

        1. Criminal negligence. The ignored repeated warnings about impending Al Qaeda attack using planes, resulting in the worst attack on our nation's soil since Pearl Harbor.

        2. Torture. Changing the name to "enhanced interrogation" doesn't make it legal.

        3. Outing a CIA agent who's status was classified.

        4. Destruction of evidence, contempt of congress, and obstruction of justice through the misuse and abuse of executive privilege and instructing their own people to ignore subpoenas.

        Is that enough for you?
    • Ray  •  9 mths ago
      These light run up a big electric bill that helps the Saudis profit from fuel sales - it was 19 Saudis on the 911 planes & this is how we punish them.
      • AJ Bigs 9 mths ago
        Huh??? Did you know 70% of our electricity is generated using fossil fuels, especially coal??? Really, you think fuel from the Middle East has something to do with electricity in the USA? ? Really???? Gee wiz, when will Americans better educate the children.
    • Ray  •  9 mths ago
      After 911 the Bushstapo created the biggest government in history , the most laws, & the biggest bureacracry in history & squandered ONE TRILLION DOLLAR$ & more in Iraq & broght down the middle class.

    ABOUT THE UPSHOT

    The Upshot is the Yahoo! News blog assembling choice material from The Ticket (politics), The Lookout (national affairs), The Cutline (media) and The Envoy (foreign affairs).

    Subscribe

    [X]

    How to subscribe

    Roll over each section to subscribe using Add to My Yahoo! or RSS Feed feeds.

    Yahoo! News offers dozens of RSS feeds you can read in My Yahoo! or using third-party RSS news reader software. Click here to find out more about RSS and how you can use it with Yahoo! News.

    Meet The Upshot Team

    Loading...

    The Upshot Network

    Edited by Dylan Stableford
    Edited by Eric Pfeiffer
    Edited by Olivier Knox