What does it mean to claim insolvency?

Bankrate.com

George Saenz

George Saenz

Dear Tax Talk,
We are in the process of being foreclosed upon on my primary home and our one and only rental house. Our tax adviser said that we may be able to claim insolvency. Otherwise we will probably owe taxes on the rental house.

Can you explain what insolvency is? Is our 401(k) balance included in our assets? Thank you.
-- Beverly

Dear Beverly,
While your creditors may not have access to your retirement accounts, the IRS does. The general rule is that if you have a debt that is forgiven, you recognize income. Exceptions exist for primary home debt forgiven as well as debts forgiven in bankruptcy proceedings and when a taxpayer is insolvent.

The cancellation of your primary home debt is not considered income provided that the debt was used to purchase the home and was not increased by a cash-out refinance.

Ideally you, just like everyone else in your situation, would like to avoid filing bankruptcy to avoid further embarrassment and credit damage. If you could avail yourself of the insolvency exception to avoid recognizing income from the rental property's debt discharge, you would be able to avoid bankruptcy.

It is a long-established principle of taxation that a discharge of debt results in a gain to the debtor. The reasoning is that when the loan originated, you didn't recognize income because you're obligated to repay it. If you don't repay it, you have somehow gained. Many people in foreclosure don't feel like they've gained anything. However, the bank's loss was caused by your mistake in investment and when the bank isn't repaid, you're being held accountable for its loss.

For many years, the tax law has given bankrupt and insolvent taxpayers a break when it comes to forgiven debt. The reasoning is that the tax law shouldn't take a bad situation and make it worse. It's pretty well established that if you enter into bankruptcy, certain assets, depending on your state of residency, are exempt from creditor claims. Generally, these assets are homestead property, insurance products and retirement accounts. What had not been clear is how these assets were treated in the case of insolvency; neither the law, IRS regulations, announcements or rulings explained it.

A taxpayer in bankruptcy proceedings can exclude forgiven debt from income. A taxpayer that is insolvent can also exclude forgiven debt from income to the extent insolvent. Insolvency means that a person's liabilities exceed their assets. Hence, the definition of assets is extremely important in determining the extent to which a person is insolvent.

Prior to the real estate crisis, the IRS took a taxpayer's claim of insolvency to tax court. The taxpayers sought to exclude assets exempt from creditor's claims when measuring insolvency. The theory being that if the assets are exempt in bankruptcy proceedings, the taxpayer shouldn't be forced into bankruptcy just for the favorable tax consequences. The IRS and the U.S. Tax Court couldn't have disagreed more.

Hence, in determining the extent of your insolvency, you will have to count your 401(k) as an asset. I recommend you have your tax adviser work out the consequences more concisely so that you can measure the benefit of declaring bankruptcy.

Ask the adviser

To ask a question on Tax Talk, go to the "Ask the Experts" page and select "Taxes" as the topic. Read more Tax Talk columns.

To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein. Taxpayers should seek professional advice based on their particular circumstances.

Bankrate's content, including the guidance of its advice-and-expert columns and this website, is intended only to assist you with financial decisions. The content is broad in scope and does not consider your personal financial situation. Bankrate recommends that you seek the advice of advisers who are fully aware of your individual circumstances before making any final decisions or implementing any financial strategy. Please remember that your use of this website is governed by Bankrate's Terms of Use.



More From Bankrate.com
View Comments

Recommended for You

  • CELLPHONE SNOOP DISCOVERS HER BOYFRIEND IS CHEATING

    DEAR ABBY: I have been in a long-distance relationship with "Victor" for several years. Recently I began to suspect he was cheating. What raised my suspicion was that I suddenly couldn't reach him on the weekends. Usually we would Skype -- Sunday night for me, Monday morning for him. Last February…

    Dear Abby
  • Flight Attendant's Hilarious Safety Instruction Video Goes Viral

    Fasten your seat belts, stow your belongings under your seat and put your electronics in airplane mode. Southwest Airlines' Martha Cobb has a few safety announcements, and a couple of jokes to share as well. The Houston-based flight attendant known as Marty is gaining national attention thanks to a…

    Trending Now
  • Take Professional Looking Photos With Your Phone

    The Nokia Pro Camera setting is just like a digital SLR. Adjust features like white balance, shutter speed & flash. Shoot like a pro with your phone.

    AdChoices NokiaSponsored
  • Woman leads police on chase after she forgets $50 on gas station counter

    A deputy intended to do a good deed by following the woman, but after running her tags, learned she was driving with a suspended license.

    Odd News
  • N. Korea officials 'target London salon over Kim haircut ad'

    British police said Tuesday they had intervened after North Korean embassy officials reportedly told a London hairdresser to take down a discount haircuts advert featuring leader Kim Jong-Un. Mo Nabbach said two officials identifying themselves as being from the Stalinist state's mission took…

    AFP
  • Walker's brothers to help finish 'Fast & Furious'

    NEW YORK (AP) — Paul Walker's brothers are stepping to help finish filming on "Fast & Furious 7," the film Walker was in the midst of making when he died in November.

    Associated Press
  • Here are all the passwords you need to change right now because of Heartbleed

    By now, we all know what a huge deal Heartbleed is. The massive vulnerability in OpenSSL protocol impacted 66% of all sites on the Internet at the time of its discovery, and now companies are scrambling to fix the issue. Most big companies seem to have done a pretty good job of acting quickly, but…

    BGR News
  • Teacher who ‘ordered a hit’ on 7th grader gets fired

    Florida’s St. Lucie County School Board officially fired veteran teacher Dru Dehart after their investigation found that she encouraged six 8th grade students to beat up 7th grader Radravious Williams, WPTV NewsChannel 5 reports.

    Odd News
  • Crimeans find their new lives in Russia harder than expected

    A month on from their referendum to join Russia, Crimeans ought to be looking north to the mainland with some satisfaction. Kiev is mobilizing troops to oust them, raising the possibility that Russia will respond with military intervention. But for Crimeans, now safely ensconced in Russia's…

    Christian Science Monitor
  • 12 Best  Family Cars of 2014

    Forget "family car" stereotypes- it's not just minivans anymore! We narrow down the best SUVs, hybrids, sedans, and yes, minivans for your family!

    AdChoices Kelley Blue Book®Sponsored
  • View

    Utah woman arrested after dead babies found (16 photos)

    A judge set a $6 million bail for a Utah woman accused of killing six babies that she gave birth to over 10 years. State Judge Steven Hansen in Provo set bail at $1 million for each child when Megan Huntsman appeared via video in a Utah courtroom Monday morning. Huntsman, 39, was arrested Sunday on…

    Yahoo News
  • Study finds signs of brain changes in pot smokers

    NEW YORK (AP) — A small study of casual marijuana smokers has turned up evidence of changes in the brain, a possible sign of trouble ahead, researchers say.

    Associated Press
  • William, Kate and baby George kick off Australia tour

    Prince William and his wife Kate flew into Sydney on Wednesday with their baby son George to kick off the Australian leg of their tour Down Under. The royals disembarked from an Australian air force 737 under sunny skies after arriving from New Zealand, an AFP photographer said. Eight-month-old…

    AFP59 mins ago
  • What I learned as a liberal talking head on Fox News

    In the fall of 2013, I gave a TED talk on what I learned as a progressive, on-air talking head at Fox News, where I worked for two years before leaving and joining my current home, CNN. After all, one of the most frequent questions I was asked during my time at Fox was how I did it, how I was a fox…

    Christian Science Monitor
  • South Dakota mystery solved: Teen girls died in 1971 car crash

    By Brendan O'Brien (Reuters) - The remains recovered from a car found overturned in a South Dakota creek last fall have been identified as those of two teenage girls who disappeared in 1971, and no foul play is suspected, authorities said on Tuesday. The girls, Cheryl Miller and Pamela Jackson,…

    Reuters
  • View

    Frazier Glenn Cross (7 photos)

    Kansas prosecutors filed state-level murder charges Tuesday against the white supremacist accused in shootings that left three people dead at two Jewish community sites in suburban Kansas City. Frazier Glenn Cross has been charged with one count of capital murder for the deaths of 14-year-old boy…

    Yahoo News
  • View Special Offers on Our Most Popular Cards

    Become a cardmember today. Find a card, compare rewards and apply for an American Express® card.

    AdChoices American Express®Sponsored
  • Geologic Wonder: See the Grand Canyon from Space

    Helicopter tours of the Grand Canyon can provide a bird's-eye view of the iconic landmark. But that's nothing compared to what astronauts see as they zip over northern Arizona in the International Space Station. In a new image taken from orbit, the Grand Canyon is visible slicing through the Kaibab…

    LiveScience.com
  • 'DWTS': How Derek Hough Got Between NeNe Leakes and Tony Dovolani

    In one of the first dramatic moments of this season's "Dancing with the Stars," NeNe Leakes stormed out of a dance rehearsal during the week after she noticed her partner Tony Dovolani was getting a bit jealous. Leakes had danced with Derek Hough the week before during switch-up week and had come…

    ABC News
  • 'Syria rebels get US-made missiles'

    Syrian rebels fighting to topple President Bashar al-Assad for the first time received at least 20 US-made TOW anti-tank missiles from a "Western source," a rebel official told AFP Tuesday. "Moderate, well-organised fighters from the Hazm movement have for the first time received more than 20 TOW…

    AFP
  • Chief: Suspects wore GPS devices during killings

    ANAHEIM, Calif. (AP) — Two parolees raped and killed at least four women while wearing GPS trackers, and there may be more victims, a California police chief alleged Monday.

    Associated Press
  • A look at the NBA playoff picture

    A look at where things stand in the NBA playoff picture, with two days remaining in the regular season and all 16 teams that will head to the postseason this weekend now having clinched their spots:

    Associated Press
  • Play

    Caught on Tape: Intruder on Surveillance Over Baby's Crib

    Sheriff has released unnerving video of a family home with an intruder and a lesson to all.

    ABC News Videos
  • SONY PlayStation® Games

    Visit the PlayStation® Store today to discover and download games, add-ons and demos for your PS4™, PS3™, and PSVita. Shop now!

    AdChoices SonyEntertainmentNetworkSponsored