COMMENTARY | According to TIME, the U.S. Navy is concerned that its SEALs, the vaunted special forces teams made famous many times over, are too white. Minorities make up a much smaller fraction of SEAL officers than their respective proportions of the national population.
The Navy wants to rectify this. And it's not just for feel-good purposes: Non-white SEALs are more likely to be able to successfully blend into the local populace during operations in regions like Africa, the Middle East, and Asia and the Pacific.
My problem? In today's cash-strapped, budget-cut economy the Navy plans to spend money to do this. And, judging from the article, it will be some real money:
"The SEALs want a contractor who will work through 'athletic, peer group, academic and administrative entities' to inform minority youth about SEAL opportunities...generate SEAL-related contacts with at least 'a thousand (1000) minority males aged 16-24 per metropolitan region' over a 12-month period... The contractor is expected to mentor 15 'high potential minority candidates' per region."
Given the prestigious and elite nature of the Navy SEALs, as well as their dangerous mission that leaves no room for error, I doubt it is wise to allow outside contractors to have influence in the process of SEAL selection. Due to the money involved and sensitive nature of the contractor's mission, it is reasonable to assume that there could be pressure on the Navy to accept the contractor's chosen applicants. As a result, the legendary SEAL selection process could be compromised, creating controversy and resentment. Critics could even go so far as to claim that the military's special forces were using affirmative action.
Additionally, why is an external contractor needed? Couldn't the Navy save money and time by attempting to recruit minority SEAL applicants internally from among current officers and enlisted personnel?
An external contractor could, accurately or inaccurately, be accused of tainting the SEAL selection process through a myriad of factors, while internal recruitment done by the Navy itself is likely to only bolster the Navy's reputation.




26 comments