How a few dozen conservatives can thwart the rest of the GOP

The Week
Speaker John Boehner has had to strike a delicate balance with his caucus. 
.

View photo

Speaker John Boehner has had to strike a delicate balance with his caucus. 

To end the government shutdown, all Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) has to do is bring a clean continuing resolution up for a vote that makes no mention of ObamaCare. And according to reports, most Republicans in the House would be game for such a plan, not to mention the chamber's Democrats.

So what gives?

SEE ALSO: The 6 worst things to say to an unemployed friend

Boehner has had to strike a delicate balance in his caucus since January, when diehard conservatives tried to oust him from the speakership. The uprising "crippled" him, says National Review's Robert Costa, leaving him unwilling to cut off that vocal wing for fear of losing his post. As a result, "he knows a clean [continuing resolution] has never been an option for him."

The leadership vacuum has allowed Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) to wield more clout than Boehner himself in guiding the party's budget strategy. With powerful Tea Party groups behind him, Cruz pushed the defund-ObamaCare tactic in the first place, and has since kept it alive.

SEE ALSO: The U.S. military basically wants to build Iron Man

Further, while the numbers for a clean continuing resolution may appear to be there, they are fluid. GOPers who may privately want to drop the party's demands are, under pressure from the right, unwilling to do so in public.

The Republican majority is relatively small. The party holds 233 seats, and need 217 votes to pass a bill. But there are an estimated 30 to 40 hardline conservatives who refuse to budge, no matter what. And there's another few dozen who are on the fence, and who have, to this point, been pulled into Cruz's camp come vote time.

SEE ALSO: Will the government shutdown cost the GOP the House?

Therefore, even if Boehner in theory has the support to pass a bill, he would need a significant swath of Democratic votes to do so — something he'd prefer to avoid. The right is already deeply mistrustful of Boehner, and would openly revolt if he helped pass a plan backed by more Dems than Republicans.

Plus, Democrats are unified in their opposition to Republican demands, leaving Boehner with no choice but to deal only with his caucus.

SEE ALSO: Peak soil: Why nutrition is disappearing from our food

"The combination of those two factors — a close Republican majority and united Democratic opposition — gives those 30 Republicans their power," explains the Washington Examiner's Byron York. "In a situation where Democrats nearly unanimously oppose a bill, the 30 can make the difference between success or failure for Boehner. If they stick together, Boehner can't win."

Boehner could cut out the Tea Party and bring up a clean bill that would pass with full Democratic support. Yet he would risk losing much of his caucus — not only the hardliners — in the process, further fracturing the party and endangering his job.

SEE ALSO: Watch The Daily Show ask a real hostage negotiator how to handle the GOP

View this article on TheWeek.com Get 4 Free Issues of The Week

More from The Week:

Like The Week on Facebook - Follow The Week on Twitter - Sign-up for The Week's Daily Newsletter

View Comments (105)