Military Wants 'Minority Report' for Suicide Prevention

LiveScience.com
Military Wants 'Minority Report' for Suicide Prevention
.

View gallery

The U.S. military wants to invest in ways to predict and prevent suicide among its troops.

Suicides among U.S. troops have outpaced combat deaths in Afghanistan throughout much of this year. The alarming trend has spurred the U.S. military to envision a "Minority Report" future where it has better predictions of when a person is likely to commit suicide — or perhaps even murder.

The idea of predicting people's likelihood of using violence comes from the U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA). The agency plans to hold a suicide prevention workshop on Oct. 19 to figure out the best methods and technological tools for identifying troubled states of mind, according to a special notice issued on Sept. 26.

"It seems to me that this is in response to the high incidence of suicidal behavior in veterans upon return from active duty," said Kent Kiehl, an associate professor of psychology and neuroscience at the University of New Mexico. "Or [it comes from] recent homicidal incidents where people go in and shoot everybody and then kill themselves."

That most recent special notice makes no mention of predicting murder. But an earlier special notice issued on Sept. 20 and later archived on Sept. 24 suggested grander ambitions for a "Predicting Suicide Intent" (PSI) program that would identify changes in a person's state of mind and predict future mental states related to both suicide and murder.

"The overall goal of PSI is to develop and evaluate predictive models for suicide assessment as a proof of concept, and extend it to the development of models that can predict other neurocognitive states of extreme order including homicidal intent," according to the Sept. 20 special notice.

Breaking down the problem

Experts already use psychological screening and neurocognitive tests to come up with risk assessments for whether imprisoned criminals are at low, medium or high risk of falling back on old behaviors, Kiehl said. But predicting an individual's likelihood of committing suicide or murder still represents a huge challenge.

"Predicting something like murder is extremely difficult to do because the base rate is so small," Kiehl told TechNewsDaily. "If you study 100,000 people, three might go out and kill someone else. There's really not a good way to predict that single individual."

Similarly, suicides represent relatively rare events that make prediction tough, said Douglas Mossman, an M.D. and forensic psychologist at the University of Cincinnati. Much of Mossman's past work has highlighted the huge challenges of anticipating and preventing violence based on risk factors that are imperfect indicators of future violence. [Facebook Launches Suicide Prevention Tool for Military Families]

"Even in a high-risk population like a military population where they're concerned about the number of suicides and fatalities, it's still a statistically unusual event," Mossman explained.

Kiehl, an expert on psychopaths, pointed out that DARPA's futuristic model would have to account for the fact that suicide and homicide have very different risk factors. For instance, depression is a risk factor for suicide, but psychopaths who kill in cold blood rarely show signs of depression. Murders get even more complicated by themselves because of the many different motives of killers.

Besides "classical" suicide and murder, Kiehl also identified a third behavior related to spree killings where the murderers end the rampage by killing themselves. Different risk factors would likely apply to those three scenarios.

Costs of prediction

The roadblocks for predicting suicide and murder look huge. But psychologists do have plenty of tools that could help boost risk assessments based on the right deployment, Kiehl said. He suggested that he and his colleagues might end up getting involved with DARPA's plan, if the military agency shows interest in their work.

Kiehl envisions using a combination of tools to screen people and sort out those at high risk for suicidal or homicidal behavior. The U.S. Army might take a first step by applying a questionnaire or interview for all soldiers at several stages: boot camp, deployment and return from deployment.

The initial screening could sort out potential high-risk individuals for a second screening step that used neurocognitive computer tests or games to examine each person's state of mind. A third step for screening the highest-risk individuals could use electroencephalography (EEG) to measure electrical brain waves, or use brain imaging such as functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) scanners. [Quiz: Sci-Fi vs. Real Technology]

Such psychological screening might ideally apply to everyone all the time for the best chance of noticing and preventing suicides or murders, Kiehl said. But he added that both the financial cost and the intrusion on personal privacy or freedom make it so that the U.S. military must find a balanced middle ground.

For instance, predictions might improve if psychologists could track incidents in people's lives related to divorces, financial problems or unstable homes. Whether or not the U.S. military and society at large are willing to pay that price remains to be seen.

"If you give up a bit of individual freedom, you can prevent many mental health problems," Kiehl said.

Making it real

The technology already exists to improve risk assessments for suicide or murder, but it could get better. Kiehl envisioned an EEG system embedded in soldiers' helmets that could collect mental data by measuring brain wave patterns, or perhaps a wearable EEG cap for sleeping soldiers to identify troubled sleep patterns that could tip off psychologists as related warning signs.

"If DARPA is interested in a tricorder that zaps you and tells you whether you'll commit suicide, then, no — we're not there yet," Kiehl said.

Mental health professionals have largely moved away from "yes or no" visions of predicting violence and instead favor risk assessment of a person's broader health issues and risk factors, Mossman said. Successful treatment of risk factors such as psychosis or substance abuse may have the side benefit of reducing an individual's likelihood to use violence.

But even if DARPA's prediction goal doesn't get realized, Mossman said that the research could still improve understanding of events that put people at higher risk of suicide. A focus on broader mental health could also prove more beneficial to everyone, regardless of whether or not he or she would ever commit suicide.

"When we have that information, we can go ahead and do clinical interventions that may be beneficial to people who may harm themselves, but also to people who wouldn't have harmed themselves but are suffering in other ways," Mossman said.

This story was provided by TechNewsDaily, a sister site to LiveScience. You can follow TechNewsDaily Senior Writer Jeremy Hsu on Twitter @jeremyhsu. Follow TechNewsDaily on Twitter @TechNewsDaily, or on Facebook.

Copyright 2012 LiveScience, a TechMediaNetwork company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Executive actions ready to go as Trump prepares to take office

      By Ayesha Rascoe and Julia Edwards Ainsley WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Donald Trump is preparing to sign executive actions on his first day in the White House on Friday to take the opening steps to crack down on immigration, build a wall on the U.S.-Mexican border and roll back outgoing President Barack Obama's policies. Trump, a Republican elected on Nov. 8 to succeed Democrat Obama, arrived in Washington on a military plane with his family a day before he will be sworn in during a ceremony at the U.S. Capitol. Aides said Trump would not wait to wield one of the most powerful tools of his office, the presidential pen, to sign several executive actions that can be implemented without the input of Congress.

      Reuters
    • Animal Shelter Offers $11,200 Reward After Rottweiler Is Found With Ears, Nose and Tail Cut Off

      "Baron is doing remarkably well considering his injuries," a veterinarian reported.

      Inside Edition
    • Cancer Patient Who Did 'Juju on That Beat' During Chemo in Viral Video Dies

      Ana-Alecia Ayala, who made headlines in October for dancing up a storm during chemotherapy treatments, has died after a year-long battle against cancer.

      Inside Edition
    • Everything We Think We Know About the Upcoming Ford Bronco and Ranger

      Ford promises a new small pickup truck and a return of the legendary Bronco name. Here's what to expect.

      Road & Track
    • Foreclosed mall once valued at $190M is auctioned for $100

      TARENTUM, Pa. (AP) — A Pennsylvania mall that was foreclosed on after its owners failed to repay $143 million has been auctioned off for $100.

      Associated Press
    • Documents: Woman knew for months she'd been stolen at birth

      An 18-year-old who was kidnapped as an infant discovered months ago that she had been raised by her abductor under an assumed name, court documents show.

      Associated Press
    • Giant Florida Gator Is Not For Tourists, Nature Preserve Staff Warn

      Officials for the county's natural resources division said, although, they appreciate the attention the nature reserve has been getting, they are also worried about the safety of visitors and wildlife.

      International Business Times
    • Ex-president George H.W. Bush moved to intensive care; wife hospitalized

      Bush, who at 92 is the nation's oldest living ex-president, has been at Houston Methodist Hospital since Saturday after experiencing shortness of breath, family spokesman Jim McGrath said on Wednesday. Since then, Bush experienced an "acute respiratory problem stemming from pneumonia" and was sedated for the unspecified procedure, his office said.

      Reuters
    • Deadly snow avalanche hits hotel in earthquake-stricken central Italy (15 photos)

      Rescue workers were met with an eerie silence Thursday when they reached a four-star spa hotel struck by an avalanche in a mountainous earthquake-stricken region of central Italy. At least 30 people were missing, including at least two children, authorities said. Guests at the three-story Hotel Rigopiano in the central Abruzzo region alerted emergency workers of the disaster on Wednesday, following a series of quakes in the region. “Help, we’re dying of cold,” one couple wrote rescuers, according to the ANSA news agency. Another man, identified by news reports as Fabio Salzetta, sent a SMS message saying he had escaped with a maintenance worker, but that others were trapped inside. Corriere della Sera quoted the text message as saying: “Some walls were knocked down.” And: “I’m outside with a maintenance worker but you can’t see anything of the hotel, there’s only a wall of snow in front of me.” When rescuers on skis arrived in the early morning hours of Thursday, they found just two people alive, according to news reports. Civil protection authorities said that 30 people were missing. The ANSA news agency quoted a rescuer as saying that there were fatalities, but details weren’t immediately available. Just one body was reported removed from the hotel by late morning Thursday. (AP) See more news-related photo galleries and follow us on Yahoo News Photo Tumblr .

      Yahoo News Photo Staff
    • The internet roasts a photo of Donald Trump writing his inauguration speech

      When times get tough, at least you can still meme. President-elect Donald Trump is slated to deliver his inauguration address on Friday, so he teased his Twitter followers with a little behind-the-scenes photo of himself writing a speech at his Mar-a-Lago estate in Florida. SEE ALSO: Don's Johns: Port-a-potties get censored for Trump’s inauguration Writing my inaugural address at the Winter White House, Mar-a-Lago, three weeks ago. Looking forward to Friday. #Inauguration pic.twitter.com/S701FdTCQu — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) January 18, 2017 The staged photo and Trump's cold, dead gaze sent the internet straight into "meme mode alpha," where it was pointed out that Trump was actually holding Sharpie marker, which may or may not actually be closed. @realDonaldTrump that is a blank piece of paper and you're holding a closed sharpie pic.twitter.com/ekCcH8eTXe — Jules Suzdaltsev (@jules_su) January 18, 2017 @cajunmonkey439 @realDonaldTrump It is *obviously* a sharpie. pic.twitter.com/gdD2AUhBKX — Jules Suzdaltsev (@jules_su) January 18, 2017 .@realDonaldTrump pic.twitter.com/8CSroNshBR — XpeK (@peKofX) January 18, 2017 Surprised that you didn't just use this photo as your epic, bigly speech pic.twitter.com/SezwzToFg4 — Roland Scahill (@rolandscahill) January 18, 2017 good job @realDonaldTrump pic.twitter.com/Ioj869Tfy3 — uhhh (@_uhhhhhhh) January 18, 2017 pic.twitter.com/pAKcXAEAkD — Sam Grittner (@SamGrittner) January 18, 2017 @realDonaldTrump #NotMyPresident #TheResistance #conflict #Putin #Inauguration In house security cam Mar a Lago pic.twitter.com/diwnpjAS3F — Beo Bachter (@kaysintBB) January 18, 2017 Early draft of Donald Trump’s inauguration speech. #TrumpSpeech #MyFirstWordsAsPresident #MAGA pic.twitter.com/qgo1glv5cG — Tom ❄️ (@TommieWho) January 18, 2017 Exclusive sneak peek at Trump's inauguration speech! pic.twitter.com/6W6ex0Ks3z — Kara Calavera (@KaraCalavera) January 18, 2017 Trump's Inaugural address leaked... pic.twitter.com/J8soJQ4Ira — Jordan Uhl (@JordanUhl) January 18, 2017 Exclusive: #Trump's Inauguration speech leaked! #TrumpInaugural #trumpgrammar pic.twitter.com/XzrXXpnjxD — Gerry Stergiopoulos (@GerryGreek) January 18, 2017 According to CNN, Trump did write his inauguration speech himself. BONUS: NBD, just a massive alligator out for a stroll

      Mashable
    • When presidential inaugurations go very, very wrong

      As Constitution Daily counts down to Inauguration Day, we look back at three presidential ceremonies from the 1800s that ended very badly.

      National Constitution Center
    • A Family's Fight: Mom and Her 1-Year-Old Daughter Battling Cancer Together

      She wasn't expecting her own diagnosis, much less her daughter's.

      Inside Edition
    • Durant dazzles against former Oklahoma City team once more

      OAKLAND, Calif. (AP) — Russell Westbrook promised to pay back Zaza Pachulia for a hard foul.

      Associated Press
    • North Korea's Kim Jong Un Is So Fat He Might Have Hurt His Ankle Again

      Kim's leg injuries have been linked to obesity in the past and recent pictures show the Korean leader appears to have put on extra weight. 

      International Business Times
    • Virginia man convicted of 2006 slaying of family is executed

      JARRATT, Va. (AP) — A man convicted of killing a family of four, slashing their throats and setting their home ablaze after they left their front door open while preparing for a New Year's Day party in 2006, was executed Wednesday.

      Associated Press
    • Fatal Autopilot crash wasn’t Tesla’s fault, investigators decide

      The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has closed its six-month-old investigation into the fatal crash of a Tesla Model S , which was being driven by the Autopilot system when it collided with a truck last May. The NHTSA will not seek a recall of Tesla's vehicles, and the report said that the agency's examination "did not identify any defects in the design or performance of the Automatic Emergency Braking or Autopilot systems." The crash occurred on a highway in Florida on May 7th last year. The Tesla was being driven a few miles per hour over the speed limit in the left lane of a two-way highway, when a truck with a trailer turned across both lanes towards an exit. The Tesla's radar and cameras failed to pick up the trailer, and the Tesla drove directly into the side of it, killing the driver. Since the accident, Tesla has updated its semi-autonomous Autopilot feature to force drivers to be more hands-on, and treat it like a driving aid rather than an actual Autopilot. Despite the name, Tesla says that Autopilot is still a beta feature that requires drivers to monitor the road just like normal.New Tesla cars also have an updated version of the Autopilot with more sensors, which should prevent a similar accident from happening again. Despite the one fatal crash, Autopilot is statistically safer than human drivers. According to Tesla, Autopiloted vehicles have driven over 200 million miles by this point, with just one fatality. The average for human-driven vehicles is one fatality every 94 million miles, although the numbers are probably skewed a little, as a Tesla is safer than the average car in a crash, and the majority of Autopiloted miles will be driven on divided highways, which are safer than regular roads.

      BGR News
    • Julian Assange Says He Will Return to U.S. After Manning Decision

      WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange said Thursday he will stand by his offer to travel to the United States if Chelsea Manning is released from prison.

      Tribune
    • Virginia inmate executed despite arguments against drug 'cocktail'

      A Virginia inmate was executed on Wednesday for murdering two young sisters during a 2006 killing spree, after the Supreme Court denied a stay request where he argued the use of compounded lethal drugs violated his constitutional rights.     Ricky Gray, 39, died by lethal injection at 9:42 p.m. at the Greensville Correctional Center, Virginia Department of Corrections spokeswoman Lisa Kinney said in an emailed statement. Gray's lawyers filed an emergency petition with the Supreme Court on Tuesday, saying that the three-drug combination could cause Gray unnecessary suffering and thereby violate constitutional guarantees against cruel and unusual punishment.

      Reuters
    • Trump asks some 50 senior Obama appointees to stay on

      WASHINGTON (AP) — President-elect Donald Trump has asked roughly 50 senior Obama administration appointees to remain in their posts after his inauguration to ensure continuity in government, his incoming White House press secretary said Thursday.

      Associated Press
    • Iran Shocked by Deadly Fire, Collapse of Tehran High-Rise

      A historic high-rise building in the heart of Iran's capital caught fire and later collapsed, killing at least 30 firefighters and leaving their stunned colleagues and bystanders weeping in the streets

      ABC News q