Some Republicans are having doubts as Romney's campaign hits a rough patch, with a few wondering whether another candidate might have had a better shot
All through the Republican primaries, Mitt Romney was considered the most electable candidate the GOP had to offer. Recently, however, the former Massachusetts governor's campaign has been rattled by infighting and gaffes. Romney has struggled over the last week to get back on track after being caught on tape disparaging the 47 percent of Americans who don't pay federal income taxes. Meanwhile, President Obama has surged in the swing states that are expected to decide the November election. Political odds-makers say Romney's path to victory is narrowing, and some GOP insiders are openly second-guessing the party's choice of a nominee. Could somebody else have offered the GOP a stronger shot?
Republicans had better options — but those people didn't run: Romney was "head and shoulders above candidates like Michele Bachmann and Herman Cain," says Doug Mataconis at Outside the Beltway. Former Utah governor Jon Huntsman, might have been more electable, but primary voters weren't interested. If Romney was the best the GOP had, though, it was because the rivals who "might have posed a challenge" to him — "Jeb Bush, Chris Christie, Mitch Daniels, and Marco Rubio come to mind" — didn't run.
"Was Mitt Romney the best candidate the GOP had this year?"
SEE MORE: Is Mitt Romney against a two-state solution in Israel?
No. The GOP picked the best candidate: Romney just "needs a strong performance to cut into Obama's (narrow) lead," says Pete Spiliakos at First Things. There's reason to believe he can deliver one, too. After all, Romney "always got the job done" in the primaries — he "totally destroyed" Rick Perry, "beat down [Newt] Gingrich good" in Florida, and "ran rings around" Rick Santorum. Obama is a "tough" rival with a "weak record," and Romney has the best chance of anyone in the GOP crop to beat him.
"Romney in debate"
The GOP primaries damage even strong candidates: Romney is "robotic" and "severely out of touch," says Richard Cohen at The Washington Post, but the GOP's "real problem" is its "incredibly damaging" primary system. It forces everyone to pander to the right so much "that it all but dooms the winner." The resultant "brain drain" is why, in 1980, Ronald Reagan had to beat a future president and two future Senate leaders, but Romney just had to outshine "a bunch of nobodies" who weren't "remotely qualified."
"The Republican brain drain"
SEE MORE: Mitt Romney releases his 2011 tax return: 4 takeaways
Any Republican should be good enough: "Given the awful state of the economy," says Dennis Prager at National Review, the "unprecedented tensions" between us and our closest Mideast ally, Israel, and Obama's drive to build the welfare state, "a Republican candidate should not merely win," but win in a landslide. Romney can be that candidate. He just has to stop focusing on specifics, like jobs, and "run on the big issue" of whether we want to let the government and its debt take over our lives.
"It's not just the economy, stupid!"
Read more political coverage at The Week's 2012 Election Center.
SEE MORE: Advice for Mitt Romney: 'Go rogue' and 4 other strategies
View this article on TheWeek.com Get 4 Free Issues of The Week
Other stories from this topic:
- The List: Advice for Mitt Romney: 'Go rogue' and 4 other strategies
- Forecast: 3 paths to electoral victory for Mitt Romney
- Analysis: Mitt Romney releases his 2011 tax return: 4 takeaways