News Corp. board is far from independent

Associated Press
FILE - In this Nov. 9, 2010 file photo, outgoing Chancellor of New York City Public Schools Joel Klein listens during a news conference at City Hall in New York. Klein serves on the News Corporation's board of directors.(AP Photo/Seth Wenig, file)

View gallery

FILE - In this Nov. 9, 2010 file photo, outgoing Chancellor of New York City Public Schools Joel Klein …

NEW YORK (AP) — A corporate board is supposed to answer to shareholders. At News Corp., it answers only to the Murdoch family.

The 16-member board that governs one of the world's most powerful media companies is dominated by Rupert Murdoch's relatives, confidants and hand-picked executives — a group that has sometimes let him make questionable business moves.

The phone-hacking scandal at a British newspaper owned by Murdoch has focused new attention on the News Corp. board, which is so cozy with the Murdoch family that one corporate watchdog group gives it an "F'' for governance.

"This isn't just a dysfunctional board. It's a nonfunctional board," says Paul Hodgson, a spokesman for GovernanceMetrics International, an independent research firm that rates corporate boards and has given News Corp. a failing grade since 2003.

News Corp., which owns the Fox television network, the 20th Century Fox movie studio, The Wall Street Journal and the New York Post, among other media properties around the world, is a public company.

That would usually mean it's controlled by the investors who hold its common stock. But almost none of the shareholders of News Corp. have a say. Decisions about who sits on the board and other corporate matters fall almost exclusively to the Murdochs.

The company is one of just 44 in the Standard & Poor's 500 that divide stock into two classes. One is for select investors who have sole voting power. The other is for individual stockholders and institutional investors, who have no voting power.

In the case of News Corp., Murdoch controls almost 40 percent of the voting stock, most of it through a family trust. Others own so little that they have no influence. The second-largest owner of voting stock, the investment firm of Saudi Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, has just 7 percent and no representation on the board.

Some of the biggest shareholders of the other type of News Corp. stock are money management companies, including BlackRock and Vanguard. But they have no say in who's on the board or what the board does.

"If you are buying shares in this company, it's buyer beware," says Sydney Finkelstein, a professor at Dartmouth's Tuck School of Business and author of the book "Why Smart Executives Fail." ''There is no management or leadership reason to have two classes of stock except to retain control."

The News Corp. board's charter says a majority of the company's directors must be considered independent, with the board conducting a review once a year to make sure they qualify.

Today, the board has seven insiders, including Murdoch, 80, his two sons, three News Corp. executives and one adviser to Murdoch.

The other nine are considered independent. On Tuesday, for example, the company put out a statement on behalf of the "independent directors," saying they were "shocked and outraged" by the allegations against Murdoch's News of the World newspaper.

But the group of independent directors includes two former company executives and three people with whom Murdoch or his family has done significant business. One, for instance, used to be the chairman of an Australian airline where Murdoch had a stake. That leaves only four of 16 board members with no clear link to Murdoch or the company.

Some investors say a lack of board oversight has contributed to poor decisions.

Murdoch has remained at the helm even though News Corp.'s stock returns haven't been stellar. Over the last decade, its return with dividends has been about 10 percent, compared with a 32 percent rise in the S&P over the same period, according to data provider FactSet.

There have been a few bad deals, too. Last month, News Corp. offloaded social networking site MySpace for $35 million. The company paid $580 million for it in 2005. It had lost more than $1 billion total over about three years.

In 2009, News Corp. was forced to write down $2.8 billion of the value of Dow Jones & Co. Inc., which it bought two years earlier for $5.7 billion. The deal allowed Murdoch to seize the U.S. newspaper he prized, The Wall Street Journal, and came after an expensive courtship of the Bancroft family.

"I think there's a lax ethical culture," says Julie Tanner, assistant director of socially responsible investing at Christian Brothers Investment Services, which invests on behalf of Catholic institutions like dioceses and hospitals and owns 30,755, or less than one hundredth of 1 percent, of voting shares of News Corp. "It appears to be a severe lack of effective review and oversight."

The board has kept mostly quiet since the phone-hacking scandal broke, even during the closure of News of the World, the resignation of two top News Corp. executives and an appearance before Parliament this week by Rupert and son James.

When they have spoken out, directors haven't wavered in supporting Murdoch.

Thomas Perkins, who has been on the board since 1996 and is a partner at a venture-capital firm, told The Associated Press on Monday that Murdoch has the full support of the board as CEO.

The statement on behalf of the "independent directors," issued Tuesday by board member Viet Dinh, said they were shocked and outraged about the hacking but "united in support of the senior management team to address these issues."

That Perkins and Dinh are speaking for the board and have fully backed Murdoch caught the eye of Yale management professor Jeffrey Sonnenfeld. Five years ago, he says, both had a very different view on phone hacking.

In 2006, Perkins quit the board of Hewlett-Packard over the company's attempts to obtain phone records from journalists and directors. The company was trying to find out who on the board was leaking corporate information to reporters.

The controversial method used was called "pretexting," which meant the company pretended to be someone else in order to get confidential records.

Perkins discovered his personal information had been accessed. The lawyer who represented him against H-P was Dinh, whom Perkins knew from the News Corp. board.

Neither Dinh nor Perkins immediately responded to messages seeking comment on Wednesday. On Monday, Perkins said the H-P case was different.

"This is the opposite of the Hewlett-Packard scandal, which I was involved in, where the bad stuff was occurring at the chairman of the board level. This is the opposite of that," Perkins said.

When the board has taken action, its efforts haven't been as independent as they may initially seem. The company this week named attorney Lord Grabiner as the new independent chairman of the company's management and standards committee.

Instead of reporting to an independent director, the committee will report to Joel Klein, a former chancellor of New York City schools and assistant U.S. attorney general, who now works for News Corp. Klein will report to Dinh, an independent director.

Independent directors have hired corporate law firm Debevoise & Plimpton LLP to advise them on how to oversee the internal committee set up to investigate the hacking and allegations of police bribery.

If board members didn't support Murdoch, the family could always replace them. A more independent board might still demand his resignation.

Some News Corp. investors, including some with voting shares, think the board should at least start to loosen Murdoch's grip by separating the roles of chairman and CEO. That could add an independent voice to the board room.

Christian Brothers on Friday filed a shareholder resolution, to be voted on at the annual meeting, calling on News Corp. to separate the roles.

Murdoch could also step down, as a way to draw attention back to the business and away from himself.

"To the extent that the legacy of this company means something to him, this could be a necessary step," Finkelstein says.


Associated Press writer Chip Cutter contributed to this story from New York and Ryan Nakashima from Los Angeles.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Inside the Alleged Abduction of California Mom Sherri Papini

      Keith Papini details what happened before his wife was found alive.

      ABC News q
    • Donald Trump Mocks ABC News Reporter for 'Crying' on Election Night

      The president-elect also named his defense secretary.

      Inside Edition
    • Colombia Plane Crash Survivor Cried Out for Crew

      He says he survived by curling up in the fetal position.

      ABC News q
    • NASA photo reveals a startling 300-foot-wide rift in Antarctic Ice Shelf

      The breakup of the massive Larsen C Ice Shelf in Antarctica is getting closer and will eventually produce an iceberg the size of Delaware prowling the Southern Ocean, according to new NASA data.  On Friday, NASA released an astonishing new image taken by researchers flying above the ice shelf on Nov. 10 showing the crack is getting longer, deeper and wider. Scientists think it will eventually cause a large section of the shelf to break off. The scientists associated with a NASA field campaign known as Operation IceBridge measured the Larsen C fracture to be about 70 miles long, more than 300 feet wide and about a third of a mile deep.  SEE ALSO: With a collapsing West Antarctica, sea level rise may be twice as high as we thought "The crack completely cuts through the Ice Shelf but it does not go all the way across it – once it does, it will produce an iceberg roughly the size of the state of Delaware," NASA said in a press release.  View is of a rift in the Antarctic Peninsula's Larsen C ice shelf from our airborne survey of polar ice: @NASA_ICE — NASA (@NASA) December 3, 2016 When this iceberg calving event happens,  likely within the next decade, it will be the largest calving event in Antarctica since 2000, the third biggest such event ever recorded and the largest from this particular ice shelf, scientists say.  Larsen C lies next to a smaller ice shelf that disintegrated in 2002 after developing a crack similar to the one now growing in Larsen C. Map of Antarctica showing the amount of melting of ice shelves from below. Blue shades represent melt rates of greater than 5 meters (16.4 feet) per year. Arrow points to Larsen C Ice Shelf. Image: NASA/JPL-Caltech/UC Irvine/Columbia University Ice shelves breaking off into icebergs don't directly increase sea levels, since their ice is already resting in the ocean like an ice cube in a glass.  However, because they act like doorstops to the land-based ice behind them, when the shelves give way, the glaciers can begin moving into the sea. This adds new water to the ocean and therefore increases sea levels.  The rift is likely to lead to an iceberg breaking off, which will remove about 10% of the ice shelf’s area — Project MIDAS (@MIDASOnIce) August 18, 2016 In the case of Larsen C, once the rift extends all the way across the shelf and breaks off the section of ice, a larger area of ice that is about the size of Scotland will destabilize and be at greater risk for melting, according to other research. In August, a British research team monitoring the Larsen C Ice Shelf found that the rift had expanded by 14 miles between March and August of 2016. This was the fastest rate of expansion the researchers had observed. Larsen B Ice Shelf before its breakup in 2002. Image: nasa Larsen B Ice Shelf after its breakup in 2002. Image: nasa The Larsen C Ice Shelf is the most northerly of the remaining major Antarctic Peninsula ice shelves. This part of Antarctica has been warming rapidly in recent years due to a combination of increasing air and sea temperatures.  The nearby Larsen B Ice Shelf made worldwide headlines in 2002 when it broke up after a similar process of rift-induced iceberg calving. The Larsen B event was featured in the opening scenes of the sci-fi climate change-related disaster film, The Day After Tomorrow . BONUS: New Zealand's earthquake literally cracked the Earth open

    • Fatal warehouse fire in Oakland (25 photos)

      Up to 40 people were feared dead in a huge fire that tore through a rave party held in a warehouse near San Francisco, authorities said, warning that the initial death toll of nine would likely rise once crews swept the stricken building. Oakland Fire Chief Teresa Deloach Reed said most of those who perished in the blaze that started about 11:30 pm (0730 GMT) Friday were thought to have died on the upper floor of the two-story warehouse known as Oakland Ghostship. “It must have been a very fast-moving fire,” she told reporters. It was not immediately known what sparked the inferno at the electronic dance music party attended by an estimated 50 to 100 people. By mid-day Saturday, fire crews had not yet been able to fully sweep the scene and officials braced for more casualties once rescuers entered the building. (AFP) See more news-related photo galleries and follow us on Yahoo News Photo Tumblr.

      Yahoo News Photo Staff
    • Inside Edition
    • Police use 'fake news' in sting aimed at California gang

      Police investigating a notorious gang in a city on California's central coast issued a fake press release that the chief credited with saving two men by deceiving gang members who wanted to kill them, ...

      Associated Press
    • GameStop Accused Of Overcharging Customer

      A disgruntled customer has revealed online how GameStop allegedly overcharged him after ordering an “Uncharted 4” PS4 500GB bundle on Cyber Monday.

      International Business Times
    • Students: Slain USC prof was caring; arrested student quiet

      LOS ANGELES (AP) — A graduate student arrested on suspicion of killing the professor who oversaw his work at the University of California was described by some of his fellow classmates as a quiet but seemingly normal young man while others say he was troubled and pegged as most likely to quit the group's rigorous doctoral program.

      Associated Press
    • Inside Edition
    • Trump targets another company, draws Sanders' criticism

      By Doina Chiacu WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President-elect Donald Trump drew a rebuke from former Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders on Saturday, after turning his attention to another Indiana company planning a move to Mexico. "Rexnord of Indiana is moving to Mexico and rather viciously firing all of its 300 workers. Rexnord Corp , an industrial supplier based in Milwaukee, announced plans in October to move a bearing plant, and its 300 jobs, from Indianapolis to Mexico, employees told the Indianapolis Star at the time.

    • Russian security service says killed North Caucasus Islamic State 'emir'

      Russia's FSB security service said Sunday it had killed an "emir" of the Islamic State group in a raid in the volatile North Caucasus. The FSB said that 35-year-old Aselderov was involved in blasts in the southern Russian city of Volgograd which killed 34 in 2013. It also linked him to twin car blasts in Dagestan in 2012 that killed 14 and injured at least 120.

    • In photos: Nat Geo Traveller UK destinations 2017 (10 photos)

      Experts at National Geographic Traveller UK have compiled their list of the best destinations to visit in 2017, a selection meant to represent places that are timely and relevant for savvy globetrotters next year."From Ireland's forgotten county to the high temple of US hipsterism, from South America's hottest foodie city to Germany's art scene, we've selected the world's best places to see and be seen in the coming year," said editor Pat Riddell in a statement. Here are the top 10 destinations on Nat Geo Traveller UK's ‘Cool List' 2017.

      AFP Relax News
    • S. Korea crisis proves perils of cheating at school

      When South Korea's Park Geun-Hye looks back on the scandal-fuelled implosion of her presidency, she may reflect ruefully on what lit the first fuse -- a parent pulling strings over a child's education. Park's downfall was the result of her friendship with Choi Soon-Sil -- a secretive, long-time confidante who stands accused of meddling in state affairs, squeezing tens of millions of dollars from local companies and amassing a fortune by leveraging her ties to the president. It's a damning list of charges, but one that may never have come to light but for a fatal misstep by Choi two years ago in using her influence to secure her daughter's admission to an elite university.

    • Officials: Bodies of Missing Mother, Daughter Found in Well

      North Carolina authorities say bodies of mother, teen-age daughter found in a well, three days after they were reported missing

      ABC News q
    • Chains and branded skin: California kidnap case baffles cops

      SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Three weeks after Sherri Papini disappeared, the question of whether she was dead or alive was answered when the young mother and wife was spotted waving frantically for help along a California freeway early on Thanksgiving morning. But the mystery over what happened to her during those 22 days just seemed to grow stranger.

      Associated Press
    • What Did Mila Kunis Name Baby No. 2?

      “It’s a private name…You don’t want everyone else’s opinion on the name,” Kutcher said in October.

      International Business Times
    • U.S. Navy aims to buy more Boeing F/A-18E/F Super Hornets: source

      The U.S. Navy plans to divest its older model Boeing Co F/A-18 Hornet fighter jets in coming years and hopes to buy dozens of F/A-18E/F Super Hornets to deal with a shortfall of strike fighters aboard its carriers, a Navy official said. "To decrease the strike fighter shortfall and to best prepare future air wings for likely threats we will soon divest from legacy Hornets, look to buy several squadrons worth of Super Hornets and continue with efforts to bring on the F-35 carrier variant," said the official. Sources familiar with Navy plans say delays in the fielding of the carrier variant of the Lockheed Martin Corp F-35 fighter jet, longer-than-expected maintenance times for older model Hornets, and higher usage rates have left the Navy facing a shortfall of about 70 fighter jets in coming years.

    • Chef credited with inventing General Tso's Chicken has died

      NEW YORK (AP) — The chef credited with inventing General Tso's Chicken, a world-famous Chinese dish smothered in a sweet sauce that was never a staple in China, has died in Taiwan at 98.

      Associated Press
    • The Latest: Trump takes on another Indiana manufacturer

      WASHINGTON (AP) — The Latest on President-elect Donald Trump (all times EST):

      Associated Press