Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Parents Reveal 5-Year-Old’s Gender: Good Excuse or a Form of Abuse?

    This story comes from the Yahoo! Contributor Network, where individuals publish their unique perspectives on some of the world’s most popular websites.
    Do you have a story to tell? Become a Yahoo! contributor

    COMMENTARY | A U.K. couple recently revealed their child's gender after keeping it a secret for five years, but it has some people questioning their parenting methods.

    While Beck Laxton and Kieran Cooper concealed the gender because they wanted to avoid stereotyping, the jig was up when it was time for Sasha to start school. It was then that school administrators wanted to know: Is it a boy or a girl? (It's a boy.)

    In an interview with Cambridge News, Laxton explained why she decided to raise her son "gender- neutral" and said even she didn't check the baby's sex until a half hour after he was born. (After nine months of wondering, what's another 30 minutes?)

    The couple kept the child's sex under wraps, bought him gender-neutral toys and refused to let him dress in masculine clothes with skulls or camo prints.

    But pink, sparkly clothes weren't on the banned list and neither were dolls.

    Some are comparing the family's controversial decision to a lab experiment.

    While every parent can raise their child as they see fit, critics think this child's best interests weren't always at heart. Indeed, it almost seems as though Mama Laxton was encouraging the girl play.

    A family Christmas card featured a picture of a picture of Sasha dressed as a fairy. "Children like sparkly things," his mom said. Sure they do, but why does Sasha look so unhappy in the picture?

    Of course, up until now this method seems to have worked for the family. Sasha sounds to be a happy child who is open to a variety of experiences. But one has to wonder how Sasha will thrive once he gets out from under his mama's wings and into the real world.

    Kids are known to tease, and Sasha still sports the "girls" blouse from his school's uniform.

    "I don't think I'd do it if I thought it was going to make him unhappy, but at the moment he's not really bothered either way," his mother claims.

    As for five years ago when the couple broke the news of their baby's birth to family and close friends -- but neglected to mention the gender-- Laxton said, "There were a couple of people who assumed it was a boy, because that's the default: something's male unless you say it isn't."

    Apparently so.

    Victoria Leigh Miller is a freelance writer. She has been writing about parenting topics since 2001.

     

    22 comments

    • Yahoo user  •  1 mth 4 days ago
      Sounds like mama wanted a girl and daddy was too much of a wimp to put his foot down. They are both idiots.
    • justme  •  Hilo, Hawaii  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      Hmm that does not sound gender neutral if you dressed him in girl clothes..more bias Mommie dearest Practice what you spout if you don't dress him in "Male" clothing then Why in the World would you dress him up as a GIRL Really ..sounds more like YOU need to grow up not the CHILD!
    • T.A.M.I.A.  •  1 mth 4 days ago
      The whole thing is creepy. Where is CPS?
    • darlenes  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      was this boys mother dropped on her head as a child ? this might explain why she did this to her child .
    • Bobbi T  •  San Francisco, California  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      These are just stupid parents who are selfishly raising their boy to be a girl because that is what they wanted. They gave him a predominantly female name. Now he has to go to school and not know how to really act with other kids who have had a more normal stable family life. I feel bad for the kid because he is going to have a hard road ahead of him.
    • Rugged Rod  •  Portland, Oregon  •  1 mth 4 days ago
      How arrogant to believe that your lives are so important. If you keep your kid's gender a secret, keep it to yourselves, don't call the media.
    • doctaj  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      I wonder what Sasha is going to think of his parents' decision to treat him like some kind of experiment when he's older? So many kids are being raised today in ways that do nothing but create statistics out of them as they get older. Shameful!
    • Elizabeth Warren  •  Silver Spring, Maryland  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      This is such a strange story to me. I always believed that part of a child's healthy development was gender identity. I wonder if the parents did a disservice to their son's development.
    • faiman  •  1 mth 4 days ago
      i really don't get these crazy parents!! seriously. At the time of his fertilization his chromosomal sex was determined, all the testosterone that acted on this kids brain made his BRAIN sex male too. this kid was born with so much genders-specificities! the baby is not a clean slate! doing all these crazy psycho experiments with their kids did they bother improving their basic knowledge about how nature works, did they bother talking to people who are expert in embryology,peadiatrics,psychologist etc how this could adversely affect this kids developement. !the kid will be gender-neutral i don'g think so he'll be GENDER-CONFUSED!
    • Concerned American  •  Pasadena, Texas  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      what the f***????
    • Deborah  •  Killeen, Texas  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      Such a poor excuse to skullf**k a child--intellectual curiosity. I am curious to know if these freak-of-nature parents have considered sterilization? Sick perverts. This family will be buying some therapist's summer home in the near future. Poor Sasha Fierce.
    • J  •  Forest Lake, Minnesota  •  1 mth 2 days ago
      These people are sick. Sorry, but children do need to be identified as a boy or girl. Dont refer to him as the youngest or the infant, give the f*%#ing kid a real name for a boy and dress him in boy clothes because HES A BOY!!!! They are screwing up this kid more then they think, he will get teased for wearing a girls shirt and having a girls name.
    • Lawrence L  •  Arcadia, California  •  1 mth 4 days ago
      Two moms......what do you expect!
    • Tyler  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      Why are there so many stupid parents?
    • Mike  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      Morons. "masculine clothes" banned but "pink, sparkly clothes" were ok ? Definitely sounds like momma wanted her son to be a girl.

      We had 2 girls and we made conscious decisions in the '80s NOT to push gender-specific clothes, toys or behaviors. But as most parents discover --- girls are girls and boys are boys. My girls liked dolls and my nephews liked trucks.
    • Dre  •  1 mth 2 days ago
      Sasha is not a gender neutral name. Sasha is a girls name and they have done him a disservice by giving their son a girls name.
    • MaryH  •  Philadelphia, Pennsylvania  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      Sounds very Victorian.
    • Post-Partum Postum Poster  •  1 mth 4 days ago
      Fairy cross the Mersey
    • Gee Bee  •  1 mth 4 days ago
      Why do SO many parents try to screw up their kids? 'The road to hell is paved with good intentions' is still a relevant proverb. Now, this may take a little getting used to for some so please approach it with an open mind: IT IS OKAY TO BE A MALE. I know, that thought is a radical one, but after being blamed for the way my father's generation acted I just had to point it out for those not familiar with the concept. When my daughter was going to have a baby someone asked if I wanted a grandson or granddaughter. I say a granddaughter. She asked why and I said that besides the whole being a candidate for cannon fodder, a boy born today has so many things slanted against him it is no advantage being male, we are the throw away sex now. I now have 5 granddaughters and only two grandsons, I got my wish it seems.
    • Nia  •  1 mth 3 days ago
      While I don't understand their decision I see the basic reasoning behind it, stereotyping is super annoying. My son (3) loves pink, fairies and sparkly stuff yet society tells me I cannot let him have that stuff because that would be girly or make him gay. Such #$%$ Pink is just another color. Glitter is pretty for all genders. It's this stuff that made them do it.
    [ [ [['Dekraai', 10]], 'http://news.yahoo.com/photos/mourners-remember-seal-beach-shooting-victims-1318620627-slideshow/', 'Click image to see more photos', 'http://l.yimg.com/a/p/us/news/editorial/3/2c/32c8e92d889f42edb719cb5257afdf4e.jpeg', '461', ' ', 'Reuters/Lori Shepler', ], [ [['iPhone 4SXXXXXXX', 11]], 'http://news.yahoo.com/photos/thousands-line-up-for-apple-s-iphone-4s-1318602841-slideshow/', 'Click image to see more photos', 'http://l.yimg.com/a/p/us/news/editorial/f/4f/f4f15e8f6f323f5386dc9fdf9e15dca8.jpeg', '500', ' ', 'AP/Kirsty Wigglesworth', ] ]
    [ [ [['basic norm that death is private', 6]], '28413590', '0' ], [ [['songwriter also saw a surge in sales for her debut album', 6]], '28413590', '1', 'Watch music videos from Whitney Houston ', 'on Yahoo! Music', 'http://music.yahoo.com' ], [ [['keyword', 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999]], 'videoID', '1', 'overwrite-pre-description', 'overwrite-link-string', 'overwrite-link-url' ] ]
    Loading...
    • Rutgers suspect 'stupid', not criminal, lawyer says MICHAEL KOENIGS, IAN T. SHEARN and COLLEEN CURRY
      Rutgers Students Say Tyler Clementi Webcam Peeking Was 'No Big Deal'

      Prosecution: Dahrun Ravi Spied on Tyler Clementi, Deprived Him of Privacy and Dignity.

    • Police hold back crowds near The Florida Mall in Orlando, Fla. late Thursday, Feb. 23, 2012 after more than 100 sheriff's deputies in riot gear broke up an out-of-control crowd waiting to buy a new Nike basketball shoe at one of the stores. Authorities say there were no injuries or arrests outside the Florida Mall late Thursday. The crowd began getting unruly as hundreds packed the parking lot, waiting to buy the $220, limited-edition shoe that was timed to be released during the NBA All-Star Game in Orlando. (AP Photo/Reinhold Matay)

      Not again. In a situation reminiscent of the craziness that broke out in December when Nike released its retro version of a popular Air Jordan basketball shoe, police were called in late Thursday to break up a crowd that had gathered at the Florida Mall near Orlando in anticipation of the release of a new [...]

    • Man Bites Car, Bath Salts to Blame?

      Police Photos Show Apparent Teeth Marks in Metal Hood

    • Michael Jackson's Doctor Conrad Murray Denied Bail

      Murray Was Convicted of Involuntary Manslaughter in Jackson's Death

    • In this undated photo made available by the Spain's Culture Ministry, a member of the Ministry technical crew displays two of the 594,000 coins and other artifacts found in the Nuestra Senora de las Mercedes, a Spanish galleon sunk by British warships in the Atlantic while sailing back from South America in 1804, in a warehouse in Tampa, Fla. A 17-ton trove of silver coins recovered from the Spanish galleon was set to be flown Friday Feb. 24, 2012 from the United States to Spain, concluding a nearly five-year legal struggle with Odyssey Marine Exploration, the Florida deep-sea explorers who found and recovered it.  (AP Photo/Spain's Culture Ministry, HO)

      A 17-ton trove of silver coins recovered from a Spanish galleon sunk by British warships on a voyage home from South America in 1804 was set to be flown Friday from the U.S. to Spain, concluding a nearly five-year legal struggle with the Florida deep-sea explorers who found and recovered it.