FILE- This April 18, 2012 , file photo shows the Carnival Fantasy at dock in Charleston, S.C. Local environmental and neighborhood groups have sued over the city's year-round cruises. A state judge is... more 
FILE- This April 18, 2012 , file photo shows the Carnival Fantasy at dock in Charleston, S.C. Local environmental and neighborhood groups have sued over the city's year-round cruises. A state judge is recommending their claims that the cruises violate city zoning and state pollution laws be dismissed, but has suggested the state Supreme Court allow their complaint that the cruises are a public nuisance proceed in court. (AP Photo/Bruce Smith, file) less 
1 / 24
Associated Press | Photo By Bruce Smith, file
Mon, Jan 7, 2013 2:13 PM EST