Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    The Week

    Planned Parenthood and the pink Bibles controversy

    A Christian publisher pulled its Breast Cancer Awareness Bible after anti-abortion bloggers complained about where the money raised by the project was going

    Americans can promote breast cancer awareness with everything from ribbons to coffee mugs to women's designer boots. But one pinkified book is drumming up a wave of controversy. It's a special Breast Cancer Awareness edition of the Holman Christian Standard Bible, which has been yanked from store shelves by its publisher after customers complained about who was getting the money raised from sales. Here, a brief guide:

    So what happened?
    Nashville-based LifeWay Christian Resources recalled its special edition "Here's Hope Breast Cancer Awareness Bible" from Walmart and other retailers after receiving complaints that the book's proceeds — $1 per copy — went to the Susan G. Komen for the Cure Foundation, which has ties to Planned Parenthood. "Though we have assurances that Komen's funds are used only for breast cancer screening and awareness," said Thomas Rainer, president of LifeWay, "it is not in keeping with LifeWay's core values to have even an indirect relationship with Planned Parenthood." He called the project a "mistake."

    Has the Susan G. Komen Foundation always been controversial?
    No, the 25-year old foundation is the global leader for the breast cancer movement, responsible for events like Race for the Cure. When LifeWay's Bibles hit store shelves two months ago, they appeared to be just another in a long line of pink products put out to let people show support for the cause. But then anti-abortion websites and some customers started complaining about the Komen foundation's ties to Planned Parenthood, an organization that offers a host of sexual health services, including birth control and abortions. "The sign might as well read, 'Buy a Bible and support abortion!'" wrote Susan Tyrrell at Life News

    And what does the Komen Foundation say?
    The cancer awareness group was "disappointed" by LifeWay's decision, and said that all of the money raised "since the Bible's debut in October has gone directly to breast-cancer related services, and none to abortion services." That's why this is so unfortunate, says Meredith Melnick at TIME. Now, the "only losers in the controversy are women who need breast cancer screening." 

    Sources: CBS NewsLife News, TIMEUSA Today

    View this article on TheWeek.com Get 4 Free Issues of The Week

    Other stories from this topic:

    Like on Facebook - Follow on Twitter - Sign-up for Daily Newsletter

     

    47 comments

    • Zena  •  La Conner, United States  •  5 mths ago
      Are you kidding me? 2% of Planned Parenthood's services are even abortion-related. They do freaking screenings for breast cancer, which I should think would be pretty darn important to an organization that promotes breast cancer awareness.

      Honestly, our healthcare system should be modeled after Planned Parenthood: Pay what you can, when you can, give what you can to help who you can, and receive the care you need at an affordable price with respect from the doctors!
      • Mike68 5 mths ago
        Over 300,000 abortions were performed by Planned Parenthood in 2009. It may by 2%, or more rationally like 10%. When a woman has an abortion performed she is the recipient of more than one service provided, and that skews the numbers.
      • Jack 5 mths ago
        The truth is, Planned Parenthood does NO SCREENING for breast cancer - NONE. What they do is refer their clients to ANOTHER FACILITY, unrelated to Planned Parenthood. Planned Parenthood has no ability to do Mamograms - NONE. It is EXTREMELY UNFORTUNATE that the Susan Komen Foundation participates in one of the leading causes of breast cancer - ABORTION. Follow the money - If breast cancer were cured the foundation would be out of business. If abortion were stopped, there would be so few breast cancer victims, they would go out of business. EVIL! Over 4000 innocent defenseless children slaughter EVERY DAY and all you think about is the well being of a satanic organization?!
      • faith 4 mths ago
        Mike and Jack, thanks for exposing the lies. Zena, respect starts with the most vulnerable human beings in the womb.
    • ny_weather  •  5 mths ago
      Where can I buy these books? I'm not even Christian and I want to buy one...or three... or 50
      • faith 4 mths ago
        They're not for sale but PP sells fetal body parts for profit. Why would you support them?
    • Alastar  •  Denver, United States  •  5 mths ago
      If these organizations are going to interfer in our lives stop any tax dollars from going to them and let them start paying taxes.
    • Ruth  •  Mishawaka, United States  •  5 mths ago
      Before Roe v Wade, back in the day when abortions were performed in back alleys with dirty coat hangers promoted by the girls' menfolk whether father, husband or boyfriend, the ministers sure did NOT woof and fuss like they do today. Apparently the 'Christian' form of honor killing was okay by them or maybe they all had laryngitis? I took care of two girls in the hospital one 18 one 19 years old, I was 18 at the time. Took those girls three days to die from infection which the antibiotics obviously did not touch. I don't remember reading about how tragic their deaths were and etcetera... You all fill in the blanks, none of today's rhetoric do I remember. And I am absolutely sure neither one of those girls really really wanted her private parts reamed out with a dirty coat hanger; we all knew the dangers of a back alley abortion. Somehow abortion is wrong with the so called Christian folk when the woman decides for a clean abortion rather than her menfolk decide to risk her life with a dirty abortion. So much for the value and equality of women in America...so much for Christian compassion.
      • Nephilim 5 mths ago
        Which Christian group are you referring to that forced women to have unprotected sex and then forced abortions via dirty hanger in the specific location of back alley-ways?
      • Stephen 5 mths ago
        Which group? - All the Christian groups who did (and still do) consider sex to be "dirty" - but only for the unwed girl/woman who must sneak off into some back alley if she isn't ready to be a mother. This same mentality does nothing to punish or hold accountable the man who impregnated the woman. Like the church in New Hampshire that, when the young girl was raped and impregnated by the pastor, made her "apologize" to the congregation for getting pregnant. Ignorant mean people....
      • Nephilim 5 mths ago
        So some random church in New Hampshire and "churches that consider sex to be dirty". Thanks for the specifics.
    • Susan  •  Richardson, United States  •  5 mths ago
      this is your typical right wing crazy talk----------------they have proven over and over again that they despise women and for that matter babies--------------these pink BIBLES provided funds for breast cancer showing they hate women------------------they scream about abortion but then after the baby arrives then it is to hell with them and the mother, again they hate women and their children----------------------
      • Kay 5 mths ago
        You are so right, and would it not be interesting to know how many of their families have had abortions.
      • faith 4 mths ago
        Churches shelter and feed the needy, PP kills them off. Wake up people.
    • sidartha  •  Makati City, Philippines  •  5 mths ago
      Planned Parenthood gives all women who come to them sex education and contraceptive services. They have prevented more abortions by doing this then all the anti-choice groups put together. Planned Parenthood is the true anti-abortion oganization.
      • faith 4 mths ago
        Promoting immoral sex increases abortion and STD's. PP is anti-women since it kills most of them before birth.
    • Jeff VC  •  5 mths ago
      It is a shame that some brilliant Christians will never be born because their mothers died of curable breast cancer?
    • DavidB  •  Tucson, United States  •  5 mths ago
      These ignorant bible thumpers have no problem allowing living women to die of cancer in order to protect unborn embryos. A bunch of brainwashed fools.
    • SFSympa  •  5 mths ago
      Typical right-wing attack on women and their health care.
    • Erin  •  State College, United States  •  5 mths ago
      Only these nutjobs would turn something as important as saving women from breast cancer into another argument about abortion. Talk about screwed-up priorities.
    • Horus was plagiarized  •  5 mths ago
      This reminds me of the smaller governement that Kansas republicans promissed, then they created special building codes for PP (there are 2 in the entire state) that first had to approved by the legal team, then voted on by the legislature, then adpoted in to law, then had to be implemented by triaining the building inspectors, then they shut one of the two down. So how much money, time and effort went into the smaller goverment? Hypocrites and idiots following sharia laws (ancient tribal laws, that is all the bibble is) and suppressing the religious freedom of everyone in the state!! Gotta love the gop, smalller govt unless it involves your marriage, bed, children, other religions, sexual partners, sexual prefernces, ect...
    • A Yahoo! User  •  Coram, United States  •  5 mths ago
      Right wing Christian fundamentalists proving yet again that they are no less oppressive than their Sharia Law counterparts.
    • Alastar  •  Denver, United States  •  5 mths ago
      Nothing christ-like about these control freaks that are unwilling to mind their own business.
    • Stephen  •  5 mths ago
      These self-righteous so-called "Christians". They object to any effort to provide care to people who do not have insurance. They rally against "Obamacare" but offer NO solutions. Not ONE republican candidate has expressed ANY concern about the plight of American citizens who have no health insurance, although they all delight in badgering Romney over the Massachusetts mandates. Any REAL Christian would back a national health program to make sure that no American citizen is denied needed health care. The pseudo-Christians only spout verses from the Bible that don't threaten their greed and riches. They forget the entire chapter of Mark, and they certainly don't tell about Lazarus, the beggar at the gate of the rich man (who ignored his needs). "That was me, said Jesus".
    • opinomine  •  Waco, United States  •  5 mths ago
      Oh, how they #$%$ anything to do with right to choose, but then refuse to have the safety nets and programs avialable for the children they demand must be born. They are lunatics--unable to think of the best solutions for the time we live in.
    • Golden Crust  •  Indianapolis, United States  •  5 mths ago
      What a shame for so-called "pro-lifers" to take funding away from cancer screening. How do they live with their hypocrisy and bullyish behavior?
    • Fifi  •  New York, United States  •  5 mths ago
      Put the Bibles on the shelves and I will buy ten so that I can help with the cancer victim! What about them, doesn't life as a person mean anything. Why should the publisher be dictated to when we are trying to save lives??? Don't understand the double standard of those people who complain. Don't they have cancer victims in their family and if not well what goes around comes around!!! Unbelievable!!!!
    • cocheta  •  5 mths ago
      If we really started looking deeply, we'd find 'links' between any organization and any other organization...particularly if they are in the same field...ie: healthcare. I can see the publisher's dilemma but wonder if they have thought out the consequences. They have given into blackmail. If you do it once, it's so much easier to do it a second...or third....or twentieth time. What will be the next objection?

      Planned Parenthood offers more than abortions....it offers essential healthcare to thousands of women every year. That means that child-bearing age women are healthier so that complications in pregnancy are reduced which reduces the cost of healthcare....that women have healthier babies who do not end up spending months in the hospital. Healthier babies grow up to be more productive adults. And yes, there are those who for whatever reason do have abortions, sometimes for financial reasons. Perhaps if there were more viable alternatives the number of abortions would go down but until we have a social support structure that ensures that no child grows up malnourished, abused, or abandoned, we are stuck with what we've got.

      Adoption is inadequate. There are thousands of children being shuffled around foster care and institutions with physical/emotional/psychological problems that require treatment. People often want to adopt a perfect little baby, not a toddler with FAS. All too frequently those children wind up in abusive situations where they are warehoused for the money they bring in.

      As for personal responsibility....there are two parts to that, the man and the woman. Too many men seem to think that because they donate the sperm that makes them a 'father', but they contribute nothing to the upbringing and well-being of the child. Too many women chose immature males to have a relationship. Birth control is not 100% effective and even those who love and want children may not be prepared financially or emotionally for the strain even a healthy child can bring into a situation. Too many women have been abandoned by the men who promised to care for them and their children, yet there are men who whine about how much child support they have to pay...too many girls who think that a baby will bind the father to her or give her someone to love and to love her or justify her existence, perhaps out of her own uncaring unloved childhood, but the support she needs...the education she needs....aren't out there. I don't approve of abortion as birth control but until we start passing out birth control on every street corner, I don't see an alternative.

      There are times when the destructive behavior so overwhelms me that I think people should be required to get a permit to have children. There are too many broken homes, unstable relationships, immature selfish people making stupid decisions not to pay attention. This isn't limited to any particular race or religion or social class...it is endemic in our society.

      I find the whole 'pro-life/pro-choice' argument more than a little specious. The reality is that abortion is too often a necessary healthcare choice. My mother had to have what was (at the time) an illegal abortion...fortunately done by a doctor in his clinic. The only options available to her were the abortion or dying along with the fetus. Since she had 4 children, she felt she didn't have a choice. I give thanks every day of my life for the doctor who had the compassion and the courage to help her live. I hope every woman who finds herself in an equally heartbreaking situation will have the love, support and medical care she requires...not quasi-governmental or societal condemnation for something that is beyond her control.

      When all children have loving, supportive homes then we will have achieved something.
    • Alexander V  •  Oxnard, California  •  5 mths ago
      Imagine if these inbred giblet heads actually devoted the same amount of time, money and resources to help children that are already BORN instead of wasting effort on zygotes...they only care about life as long as it's a fetus, but the moment you're born their plan for you is "please die quickly, you freeloading #$%$
    • anonymous  •  5 mths ago
      What a bunch of narrow minded fools...They all think they are going to Heaven...but, I doubt God would take them...they aren't his kind of people...