RFK: What we lost, what we learned

Jeff Greenfield Yahoo News

ABC News Videos

Robert Kennedy's Daughter Involved in Car Accident

Robert Kennedy's Daughter Involved in Car Accident

Robert Kennedy's Daughter Involved in Car Accident

Now watching

Next video starts in : 7 Play

Robert Kennedy's Daughter Involved in Car Accident

Robert Kennedy's Daughter Involved in Car Accident
Replay video
Up next

U.S. reaffirms 'One China' policy following Trump’s phone call with Taiwan

U.S. reaffirms 'One China' policy following Trump’s phone call with Taiwan Up next

U.S. reaffirms 'One China' policy following Trump’s phone call with Taiwan

By Jeff Greenfield

He has been gone longer than he was alive. When he was killed 45 years ago on June 6, just after winning the California presidential primary, Robert Kennedy was 42 years old.

Because I worked on that campaign, I’ve been asked the same questions over and over: Could he have been nominated? Could he have been elected? Could he have made a real difference had he won?

After four decades of brushing the questions aside—“Who knows?”—I tried to answer them in a detailed narrative. If you want one version of how Kennedy might have won in Chicago, how he might have beaten Nixon and what he might have tried to do, you can find it in my “what-if?” book, “Then Everything Changed.”
   
Of course, it’s just as possible to imagine Kennedy losing the nomination—Hubert Humphrey had most of the big nonprimary states—or losing to Nixon in November. (Maybe in a decade or so, Robert Caro will tell us what LBJ would have tried to do to Bobby.)

For me, the real loss does not lie in the realm of speculation. We know what we lost: The voice and vision of a still-young man with an extraordinary—perhaps unique—understanding of the possibilities and limits of public action.
   
By the time he ran for president, Kennedy had spent almost three years at the very center of power, as attorney general and (much more important) as President John F. Kennedy’s closest confidant. He had learned lessons that few aspirants to the White House ever get to learn: the way “experts” may be ignorant; the way certainties offered to a president may be dead wrong; and the way untested assumptions can lead to disaster.

Some of these lessons came at the cost of humility. John and Robert Kennedy brought no small measure of arrogance to the presidency. The efforts to subvert Castro’s regime in Cuba (possibly including assassination), the embrace of counter-insurgency in Vietnam and the failure to understand how to deal with Congress cost the Kennedy administration heavily.

The crucial point here is that Robert Kennedy had learned from these mistakes. (One of his favorite quotes, from Aeschylus, says, “God calls men to a heavy reckoning for overweening pride.”) At the point when most powerful people are setting out to write their memoirs, he found himself suddenly, violently thrown from power with the death of his brother—which meant that he found himself outside the corridors of power, with full knowledge of what went on inside. It meant, for instance, that he knew that passing a bill and spending money did not necessarily make things better. It meant he understood how structural, institutional weaknesses could undermine good intentions. (My first day on his Senate staff, I went to a hearing on the then-new federal aid to education law. “What is happening with the money?” he wanted to know. Why is it then, he asked, “whenever I go into a ghetto, the two things people hate most are the public welfare system and the public education system?”)

He was, in other words, a public figure challenging orthodox liberalism at the very moment of its postwar peak and raising radical questions about what we were doing for the least of us. Decades before Newt Gingrich suggested that school kids could work (as janitors, of course, since Gingrich was pandering to a very conservative base), Kennedy was suggesting that high school kids might be let out of school a few hours a week to work: to earn money, learn a trade, maybe find an appetite for a profession. That’s why in my alternate history, I imagined him in a major fight with the teachers’ unions.

That’s what we lost: Not necessarily a president, but a 42-year-old man who should have decades more to use what he had learned in helping shape the public policy of his time.

Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.

    Recommended for You

    • Woman delivers epic Twitter takedown after Trump attacks ‘SNL’

      “Just tried watching Saturday Night Live — unwatchable!” Trump tweeted, perhaps proving the sketch’s point. “Totally biased, not funny and the Baldwin impersonation just can’t get any worse. Just tried watching Saturday Night Live – unwatchable! Totally biased, not funny and the Baldwin impersonation just can't get any worse.

      Yahoo News
    • Republican success opens door to amending US Constitution

      The November election put Republicans in full control of a record number of state legislatures around the country, a level of power that gives the party an unprecedented opportunity: change the U.S. Constitution. ...

      Associated Press
    • Sherri Papini Shows Some Signs Of Psychological Trauma

      An investigation into the California mother's mysterious disappearance continues days after she was found "heavily battered."

      International Business Times
    • Oakland warehouse operator sparks outrage for mourning loss of venue — not victims

      The operator of the converted warehouse in Oakland, Calif., where a fire broke out during a dance party on Friday night, killing at least 33 people, has been widely criticized over his initial response to the tragedy. “Everything I worked so hard for is gone,” Derick Ion Almena wrote in a Facebook post early Saturday morning. Almena’s post was met with immediate backlash from Facebook users for omitting any mention of the victims.

      Yahoo News
    • BMW remotely locks car thief in stolen vehicle until cops arrive

      Modern luxury cars are packed with all sorts of advanced security features, but not even a company like BMW can protect against someone leaving their keys inside their brand new sedan. But one would-be car thief found that even such colossal absentmindedness doesn't mean a sure-fire score. Seattle police released a report detailing the recent car theft. Apparently a BMW 550i owner borrowed the vehicle to a friend, who proceeded to leave the car unlocked in a parking garage with a set of keys right inside. A group of miscreants were browsing for possible scores when they stumbled upon the gift-wrapped BMW and one of the men decided to make it his own. DON'T MISS:  Amazon just announced Amazon Go, a grocery store with no checkout Once the friend — who was undoubtedly sweating bullets after realizing that they handed their friend's pricey ride over to some thieves — contacted police, things started to get interesting. The cops proceeded to call BMW, which was able to track the vehicle and pinpoint its location, which they relayed to the officers. Seattle police were also lucky that the stolen BMW also had remote door locks that could be activated from afar, which the company was happy to put to work. A short while later, the police found the BMW still running with the thief sleeping inside. The man then attempted to make an escape, but failed, and was quickly brought into custody by the officers. He was discovered to have a bit of meth on him as well, which, along with a heavy auto theft charge, will likely keep him busy for the foreseeable future.

      BGR News
    • 'Last Tango in Paris' rape scene revelation sparks outrage

      LOS ANGELES (AP) — "Last Tango in Paris" is making headlines again 44 years after the controversial film came out. A recently unearthed video interview with Italian director Bernardo Bertolucci from 2013 has renewed interest, and outrage, over what happened to actress Maria Schneider on set during the infamous butter rape scene.

      Associated Press
    • A Gunman Has Been Detained At A DC Pizza Restaurant That Was At The Center Of A Fake Clinton Conspiracy

      On Sunday afternoon, a lone gunman entered the Comet Ping Pong restaurant, a popular pizza and family establishment in Washington D.C., and fired several shots. According to the Washington Post, Police Chief Peter Newsham stated his belief that the incident was not terror related, although the gunman’s motive remains unclear. Newsham was also quick to note that this restaurant was tied to fake news and conspiracy theories, which circulated earlier this year, about the Clinton campaign.

      UPROXX
    • Kim Jong Un’s Wife Makes First Public Appearance In Months

      Ri Sol Ju was last seen in public on March 28 this year and her absence had sparked rumors of pregnancy while some said she may have had a serious falling out with the North Korean leader.

      International Business Times
    • Jill Stein Emboldened By Michigan Recount

      Green Party candidate Jill Stein says 75,000 blank votes in Michigan are at the center on the recount effort she is trying to expand to three states. (Dec. 5)

      Associated Press Videos
    • Alec Baldwin has perfect response after Trump disses his 'SNL' impersonation

      It's Sunday, which means the internet is coming to terms with the future president of the United States in yet another feud with Saturday Night Live . Alec Baldwin performed another spot-on impression of Trump on the show Saturday evening, mocking the president-elect for his recent actions on Twitter, Trump's preferred form of communication.  After the show bashed Trump for tweeting, Trump then hate-tweeted about the show, proving the exact point the skit was trying to make.  Just tried watching Saturday Night Live - unwatchable! Totally biased, not funny and the Baldwin impersonation just can't get any worse. Sad — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) December 4, 2016 But Baldwin isn't the type to just let some bully talk smack without dishing it back, so he tweeted that he would gladly stop his Trump impersonation if Trump simply releases his tax returns.  ...@realDonaldTrump Release your tax returns and I'll stop.Ha — ABFoundation (@ABFalecbaldwin) December 4, 2016 Here's the bit that Trump is referring to: During the election Trump refused to release his tax returns despite pressure from both Republicans and Democrats, citing an ongoing audit by the IRS. In October the New York Times released records from Trump's tax returns in 1995, which show that he may have avoided paying taxes for up to 18 years after reporting a $916 million loss.  Of course this isn't the first time Baldwin and Trump exchanged words on Twitter over SNL ; just last month Baldwin called out Trump for a similar tweet where Trump complained about "equal time" even though he already had won the election. ...@realDonaldTrump Equal time?Election is over. There is no more equal time. Now u try 2 b Pres + ppl respond. That's pretty much it. — ABFoundation (@ABFalecbaldwin) November 20, 2016 Meanwhile Alec's brother Stephen decided to how his support for Trump on Twitter on Sunday. Stephen previously stated during the election that his brother's portrayal of Trump isn't funny. Mr President @realDonaldTrump God is with you ! Thanks so much for your willingness to serve our Nation.Blessing 2U & VP @mike_pence — Stephen Baldwin (@StephenBaldwin7) December 4, 2016 BONUS: Did Trump orchestrate the 'Hamilton' debacle to distract us or is life just a distraction?

      Mashable
    • Second Russian jet crashes in failed carrier landing near Syria

      Russia's defence ministry said Monday a Sukhoi jet fell into the sea after a malfunction as it tried to land on the Admiral Kuznetsov aircraft carrier following a bombing raid in Syria. It was the second such crash involving Russia's lone carrier in a month, since it arrived in the eastern Mediterranean to bolster Moscow's airpower in Syria. "After carrying out its military assignment in Syrian airspace, a Su-33 fighter rolled beyond the deck of the Admiral Kuznetsov aircraft carrier during landing due to breakage of the arresting cable," said a defence ministry statement quoted by Russian news agencies.

      AFP
    • Video: Growing Outrage Over Road Rage Death of Former NFL Player

      The admitted shooter of Joe McKnight was released without charges while authorities investigate the case.

      ABC News q
    • Afghan's murder-rape arrest reignites Germany refugee debate

      The German government pleaded for calm Monday after the arrest of a teenage Afghan asylum seeker for the alleged rape and murder of a German student triggered fresh criticism of the country's liberal refugee policy. The anti-migrant AfD party blamed the crime on the "uncontrolled" influx of foreigners, while the head of a police union warned of the "dangers that always go along with massive immigration". "Such horrible murders already happened before the first Afghan or Syrian refugee arrived here," Gabriel told the Bild newspaper.

      AFP
    • See Pics Of ‘Duck Dynasty’ Rebecca Lo Robertson’s Wedding To Fiancé John Reed Loflin

      “Duck Dynasty” Rebecca Lo Robertson just got married to her fiancé John Reed Loflin. See wedding photos here.

      International Business Times
    • Philippines third quarter nickel ore output drops 16 percent as Duterte's green clampdown bites

      By Manolo Serapio Jr MANILA (Reuters) - The Philippines' output of nickel ore fell 16 percent in the third quarter from a year earlier, government data showed on Monday, after the world's top supplier of the metal suspended some mines in a clampdown on environmental violations. The Southeast Asian nation has already stopped work at 10 of its 41 mines in a campaign, backed by President Rodrigo Duterte, against what the government says is irresponsible mining. Output of nickel ore for direct shipping fell to 9.34 million tonnes in July-September from 11.09 million tonnes in the same period last year, data from the Mines and Geosciences Bureau showed.

      Reuters
    • Police use 'fake news' in sting aimed at California gang

      Police investigating a notorious gang in a city on California's central coast issued a fake press release that the chief credited with saving two men by deceiving gang members who wanted to kill them, ...

      Associated Press
    • Muslim NYPD officer to speak out following threats in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn

      Police are investigating a possible bias incident in which an off-duty New York City police officer who is Muslim says she and her 16-year-old son were harassed.

      WABC – NY
    • Amazon just announced Amazon Go, a grocery store with no checkout

      Amazon is the web's largest retailer, but the company has long been planning a move into the brick-and-mortar retail scene as well. Now, the reports  that Amazon was hard at work on a revolutionary corner store concept have finally achieved fruition. It's called Amazon Go, and it looks like the future. Amazon Go is a system that marries physical stores with advanced algorithms and sensors to eliminate the need for a typical store checkout. Instead of packing all the things you need into a basket or cart and then dragged it through a tedious checkout process, you just grab whatever you need and walk out of the store. MUST SEE:  Watch the new SNL sketch that had Donald Trump fuming on Twitter It sounds like a shaky concept at first, but only until you see just how advanced the technology really is. When you first walk into the store, you use your smartphone to open you virtual shopping cart. As you make your way around the store, a vast system of sensor tracks where you are, what you pick up, and what you take with you. The system even knows if you pick something up and then put it back, and will only charge you for things you actually intended to buy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NrmMk1Myrxc Once you've gotten when you came for, walking out of the store prompts the system to charge you for the products you've taken, and the receipt for your trip pops up automatically on the app. Amazon calls the system "Just Walk Out." The store, which is currently only open to Amazon employees but is poised to welcome all Amazon shoppers soon, is located in the company's home town of Seattle. At present, only one store has been announced, but it's clear that with a four-year development and considerable investment being made, the company has ambitions beyond Seattle.

      BGR News
    • The Latest: Michigan Republicans appealing recount order

      MADISON, Wis. (AP) — The Latest on the presidential recount efforts in Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin (all times local):

      Associated Press 4 min ago
    • Fatal warehouse fire in Oakland (49 photos)

      The death toll from the Oakland, California, warehouse fire has now climbed to 36 as authorities continue to discover bodies — some of them of teens possibly younger than 17 — after a blaze broke out during a dance party in a building that housed artist studios. The Oakland Fire Department has searched 70 percent of the charred building so far but had to stop this morning because of unsafe conditions, Fire Chief Teresa Deloach Reed told " Good Morning America " today. It planned to resume the search for victims later today. "The unfortunate reality of this somber Monday morning is that we're anticipating additional bodies being recovered within the structure," she said. "We're at approximately 70 percent of coverage in terms of the area that we're able to search, and the 30 percent that's left is 12 to 15 feet high with debris." At total of 33 bodies had been found at that point, but the number has since risen by three. Of the 36 victims, 11 have been positively identified, authorities said this morning. The Oakland Fire Department first responded to reports of a structure fire at the warehouse known as the Ghost Ship around 11:32 p.m. Friday night. Reed told reporters the facility appeared to function as a residential building that hosted a makeshift artists' studio as well as parties like the one that took place Friday night. (GMA) See more news-related photo galleries and follow us on Yahoo News Photo Tumblr.

      Yahoo News Photo Staff