Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    The Week

    The school that banned mirrors to teach girls a lesson

    In a controversial effort to curb teen vanity, a school in England prohibits makeup and removes mirrors from the girls' bathrooms

    Talk about plain dealing. The 14- to 16-year-old girls at Shelley College in West Yorkshire, England have been banned from wearing makeup, and are checked daily for offending eyeliner and rouge. (Teachers are reportedly armed with "makeup removal kits.") Going even further, the school has removed the mirrors in the girls' bathrooms to curb what's perceived as an obsession with vanity. "There comes a point when you need to stop teachers spending half an hour in the day talking to girls about their makeup," says head teacher John McNally. "It is more sensible to say it's not allowed." Is this a good way to help kids focus on learning over looks?

    Girls could benefit from restraints: This could be "a good time for girls to learn that they look fine even when their faces aren't coated in makeup," says Judy M. at Care2. I've taught high school classes where appearances were a huge distraction. The girls were "constantly trying to sneak a look at mirrors and fix their makeup" when they should have been learning.
    "British school bans makeup and mirrors"

    Hmmm, I'm not so sure: "Teenagers have enough trouble accepting their looks," says Margaret Hartmann at Jezebel. "It seems a bit cruel to take away something that could make them feel a bit more comfortable." Wearing a uniform is one thing, but being told what you can and cannot put on your face is a very personal matter. Still, it could work: Reportedly, in the post-makeup era, one Shelley student said, "Nobody is no prettier or uglier, we all just look normal."
    "School removes mirrors, bans teen girls from wearing makeup"

    This solution doesn't get at the root of the problem: "Instead of prescriptively banning makeup and mirror-gazing, it'd be awesome if the school put those resources into teaching strong self-esteem for all its students," says Sierra at Babble. Girls are obsessed with their appearance because of "social pressure, media pressure, and a natural fascination with [their] radically changing bod[ies]." Removing mirrors is unlikely to change that. "It's just going to make it harder for [a girl] to check her hair in the middle of the day."
    "Will a school's ban on mirrors help teen girls focus?"

    View this article on TheWeek.com Get 4 Free Issues of The Week

    Other stories from this topic:

    Like on Facebook - Follow on Twitter - Sign-up for Daily Newsletter

     

    145 comments

    • Pooky  •  8 mths ago
      Instead of ignoring how they look, they should be taught to embrace the way they look - and love themselves, no matter how they look.
      • DeDe 8 mths ago
        What a crock. Like that ever works. What planet do you live on. Girls learn early on that no one is going to embrace the way they look if they are not attractive.
      • Pooky 8 mths ago
        You must be one of those girls then..
      • Pooky 8 mths ago
        Only you, DeDe, that have such low self-esteem that you have to HATE others.
    • o  •  8 mths ago
      Great! Women have years to waste their money on makeup, these girls will save thousands of dollers by the time they are adults LOL. Uniforms are a good idea too, a way to equalize people. School is for learning.
    • William  •  8 mths ago
      girls need to realize that they will never be more beautiful than they are right now. they are victimized by the glamor industry.
    • k  •  8 mths ago
      I think that moderation and education should be the lesson here. There is plenty of time for the girls to wear makeup outside of school hours. School is for learning not dating. Maybe this is a good thing. I wonder though, what are the boys learning? What was taken away from them?
    • Pilgrim  •  8 mths ago
      Denying these young women this rite of passage is the crime here. It has nothing to do with distractions or learning or how they look with or without makeup; it's part of being a teen-aged girl and everything that comes with it. It's like saying 'you don't need salt and pepper, the food is just as nourishing without it'.
      • Kimber 8 mths ago
        Technically, you don't need it and ,just like adding salt to your food, can be harmful in the long run.
      • Pilgrim 8 mths ago
        The fad that sold us the idea that salt was harmful ended quite some time ago. Salt is now seen as an essential nutrient in balance with potassium.

        My point is that the quality of life enjoyed by these girls in their teen years is being robbed from them by a gaggle of feminazis and prigs.

        Leave the girls the dignity of choosing who they want to be. Taking away that choice is a form of servitude. Liberty itself is at issue here.
    • Vet 60-64  •  8 mths ago
      We need this thinking in the USA. Thes self centered kids are our future? God help us all when these idiots grow up...
    • Orlando Olivera  •  8 mths ago
      Ugly girls are the best. They are grateful , very accomodating and very agreeable.
      • Snake 8 mths ago
        yep dad said to marry an ugly women, you won`t care if they run away!
    • Steve  •  8 mths ago
      I suspect those behind this are fat ugly women for who a truckload of make up would do no good....attractive women rarely complain about vanity..its the fat ugly ones who would like to be vain but have nothing to base it on.
    • Rudy G  •  8 mths ago
      Is there a ban on pocket mirrors as well? Or on a bit larger ones that can fit into a book bag? What are the girls to do if it is a bit windy on their way to school and they arrive with their hair blown severely out of place? Or when it has rained and they got wet? And does anyone want to be that there will be no girls who will try to sneak into the boy's bathroom for a quick look in the mirror? Or arrive late to class after running down to the gym locker room? Once again, officious martinets put in charge of children take a meat ax to a problem that best could be resolved with effective teaching and mentoring.
    • Holy Crap  •  8 mths ago
      Reality their tired being sued from perverted bus drivers.
    • MadMark  •  8 mths ago
      Women have been brainwashed into thinking that they need makeup and perfume - its as if women have been told they're ugly and stink ...
    • Morticia  •  8 mths ago
      What a**holes.
    • DeDe  •  8 mths ago
      I certainly hope the female teachers are banned from wearing makeup. Not much of a lesson if they are all foofed up and the girls have to go au natural.
    • R@nd0mly  •  8 mths ago
      Things that should be banned. Make Up, the genie bra, and any other breast enhancing products that when removed they just return to normal.. and sag.. what a lie.. great way to disappoint a guy
    • Laff  •  8 mths ago
      Make-up should be banned across the world. All it does is render attractive chicks stupid with no sense of humor because they spend 9 hours a day humping a mirror. And no amount of make-up can save an ugly/fat chick, so basically the mere existance of make-up is a lose-lose situation.
    • Snake  •  8 mths ago
      what about the gays! more of them in England then girls! just unfair they have mirrors!!!!
    • Lance  •  8 mths ago
      i never did get the makeup thing.if you need to paint your face to look good,something is very wrong indeed,i always wonder what the female reaction would be if it were men that needed paint to look presentable,at least with men what you see is what you get
    • Vet 60-64  •  8 mths ago
      Good idea...no more makeup stains on my shorts at BJ time in PE..
    • Cas  •  8 mths ago
      Maybe they should ban teachers who are terrible at managing classroom time instead. You know, to "teach them a lesson."
      • Vet 8 mths ago
        Go ahead. They'll just leave. You need them a lot more than they need you.
    • Kimber  •  8 mths ago
      I always found it ironic that cosmetic companies would tout their products as making you look "natural" ....like your own skin isn't natural.
    Loading...