By Janice Neumann (Reuters Health) – What’s better for limiting the spread of bacteria in washrooms: paper towels, or air dryers? New research funded by a trade organization of paper towel manufacturers suggests that towels spread less bacteria. Previous studies have shown mixed results, some finding air dryers spread more bacteria and others showing they’re as safe as towels. A review of past studies published in 2012 in the Mayo Clinic Proceedings suggested that in healthcare settings, at least, “paper towels should be recommended.” In the new study, jet air dryers spread 27 times the microbes as paper towels, and four times more microbes than warm-air machines, researchers said in a presentation last week in France at a meeting of the European Tissue Symposium, which sponsored the work. Lead author Mark Wilcox and his colleagues had volunteers dip gloved hands into yogurt containing lactobacilli, a type of “friendly” bacteria. Then, the volunteers dried their hands using jet air dryers, warm air dryers, and paper towels. The test was repeated 60 times over six weeks for 20 collections of each method. From one meter away, the average airborne bacterial counts, measured in so-called colony-forming units, were 89.5 when the gloved hands were dried with jet air dryers, 18.7 using warm air dryers, and 2.2 from paper towels. To assess the potential spread of bacteria visually, individuals dipped their gloved hands in black paint and wore white disposable suits backwards with the hoods covering their faces. When they dried their hands, there were 230 visible spots from the jet air driers and 130 from the warm air dryers. None were found on people who used paper towels. Wilcox, who is a consultant/head of microbiology at Leeds Teaching Hospitals in the UK, pointed out in email to Reuters Health that drying hands thoroughly is an important way to avoid spreading bacteria to other people or surfaces. “I had made the disconcerting observation that when using some jet air driers I could feel droplets hitting my face,” said Wilcox of his interest in doing the study. “For an infection control doctor, a key principle is to reduce the risk of spread of microbes.” He and his coauthors say that more research is needed before anyone can assume the air dryers spread more germs than towels. In email to Reuters Health, William Gagnon, vice president of marketing for Excel Dryer, Inc. in East Longmeadow, Massachusetts, pointed to studies that showed no difference in bacteria with the different drying methods and others that showed microbes on unused, recycled paper towels. Benjamin Tanner, a microbiologist who is president and CEO of Antimicrobial Test Laboratories in Round Rock, Texas, criticized the new study for using gloved hands (which he said is unrealistic), paint spots and a high number of bacteria - and for failing to show any real health risk. “A well done study would have measured levels of disease-causing organisms on the hands (which may have been done), then measured the number of those bacteria that are blown off as a result of drying,” said Tanner in an email to Reuters Health. Wilcox replies that the study “purposely contaminated hands with a high number of bacteria to represent poorly washed hands, and (we) have justified this decision in our publication.” Dr. John Segreti told Reuters Health by phone that the study is interesting and well done. “What they were trying to do was mimic someone who doesn’t wash their hands carefully,” said Segreti. “It wasn’t intended as a real-life analysis.” But Segreti, who was not involved in the study, doesn’t think bacteria from dryers are much of a health risk. “In their conclusion, they have a lot of maybes . . . and I think you have to keep that in mind with this,” said Segreti, an infectious disease specialist and hospital epidemiologist at Rush University Medical Center in Chicago. Importantly, he said, “most of the pathogens people have on their skin are not spread by the airborne route but by direct (contact).” “It’s what’s left on your hands after drying that is more important than what’s aerosolized into the air,” he said. Segreti also said hospitals tend to use alcohol gel or foam on patient floors, not air dryers. “Certainly (they’re) in public restrooms all over the place and how that translates to transmission in the community is a different issue. I don’t know of any outbreak yet that’s been traced back to any of these,” said Segreti. Before last week's presentation in France, the study was online in August in the Journal of Hospital Infection. SOURCE: http://bit.ly/1xwccpO Journal of Hospital Infection, online August 26, 2014.
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
- The Daily Beast
Photo Illustration by The Daily BeastOXFORD, Michigan—Detailed descriptions of a wish to massacre classmates on his cellphone and in a journal. At least one social media post pointing to elation at access to a handgun bought by his dad. A mom who thanked Trump for “my right to bear arms.” And a meeting between his parents and school administrators about his conduct just hours before the attack.Authorities on Wednesday identified the teenage suspect in the mass shooting a day earlier at Michigan’
- The Daily Beast
Courtesy Mykayla BolieuThe family of Sativa Transue, a 26-year-old American woman from Spokane, Washington who was found dead in her Cancun hotel room while on vacation with her boyfriend, said she looked like she had been “beaten to a bloody pulp” when Mexican authorities discovered her body on Saturday.“I received a call from the Mexican consulate letting me know my daughter has passed away and that she’s been found dead,” Jayme Bolieu, Sativa’s mother, told The Daily Beast in an interview. “H
- Atlanta Black Star
Candace Owens Dubbed the Mouthpiece for Right Wing Agenda After Making Claims About the ‘Most Murderous’ Group In America: ‘That’s Why They Bring Out Candace’
Candace Owens’ data regarding which racial group is the most violent in America has landed her in hot water following an appearance on “Tucker Carlson […]
According to a royal insider, the Cambridge family has one habit in particular that the Queen "can't stand." But, you'll never guess what it is.
- Cowboys Wire
The return of DeMarcus Lawrence and several other Cowboys could be just what the team needs to turn things around heading down the stretch. | From @ToddBrock24f7
- NBC Sports Boston
The Boston Red Sox are bringing back Jackie Bradley Jr. and sending Hunter Renfroe to the Milwaukee Brewers in return.
- NBC Sports Boston
Taylor Hall shares how Jake DeBrusk addressed his recent trade request with his Bruins teammates before Tuesday's game against the Red Wings.
Accuser who testified Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein sexually abused her for years says she was on a flight with Prince Andrew and met Trump
Jane (not her real name) testified at Ghislaine Maxwell's trial that Jeffrey Epstein introduced her to Trump at Mar-a-Lago when she was 14 years old.
- Yahoo Sports
Richard Petty Motorsports has operated in various iterations since Petty Enterprises merged with Gillett Evernham Motorsports in 2009.
- USA TODAY Sports - Golfweek
Zhu is a former college golfer at Pepperdine with a champion tennis player for a father.
- Cincinnati.com | The Enquirer
Northwest High School volleyball alum Fatimah Shabazz died at North Carolina A&T where she was about to lead her team into a big tournament.
"'Don’t tell anyone,' he said next. 'Why not?' I asked. 'We have to protect the kids. They can’t know. The town can’t know.'''
Leah Newman, a former Harpo Entertainment executive and daughter of WME partner Robert Newman, died Nov. 24 in Los Angeles at the age of 33, two days after giving birth to a daughter. In an unbelievably tragic turn of events, Leah Newman died at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, just two days after the birth of her […]
- Fighting Irish Wire
Brady ain't happy
- USA TODAY Sports - Golfweek
The new video certainly spikes speculation that the former world No. 1 could play.
Paulina Porizkova's New Lingerie Photos Will Make You Want to Admire Your Own Stunning Body in the Mirror
Paulina Porizkova isn’t going to stop talking about ageism, so she’s hoping people are starting to listen. Her latest Instagram post honors her aging body in a way that turns around the negative self-talk many of us hear in our heads and gives it a positive spin that we should all adopt immediately. Using a […]
The person who called Oxford High School students 'bro' while trying to enter a classroom was likely an officer trying to put them at ease, sheriff says
Four students were killed at a shooting in Michigan's Oxford High School. The suspect is a 15-year-old student.
- NBC Sports
Tampa Bay Lightning defenseman Erik Cernak scored one of the craziest goals you will ever see in an NHL game on Tuesday night against the St. Louis Blues.
A Washington school board meeting was cut short after 2 attendees interrupted the Black superintendent by playing recordings of a racial slur
Local law enforcement is investigating the incident as an intentional hate crime, authorities said in a press release following the meeting.
The former White House press secretary promoted “Florida’s greatest Christmas party," where a ticket costs $10,000 for one photo with Donald Trump.