Andy Reid cookies, shirtless Kelce cakes & more: Get your Chiefs sweets for Super Bowl

Bakeries around the Kansas City area can keep cooking their Chiefs-themed treats until the Super Bowl.

Cakes, cookies and more are dripped in red and gold and feature the faces (and bodies) of some of the Chiefs’ most prominent players and supporters.

Here are eight shops where Kansas Citians can buy Chiefs-themed treats — and maybe send a little good luck to their team all the way in Las Vegas.

If you know of any other bakeries or shops with Chiefs’ cakes, cookies or other sweet treats, let us know at kcq@kcstar.com and we will add it to our list.

Eat your hearts out

Saturday Night Live star and Kansas City native Heidi Gardner made treats from Cookie Bliss KC a part of her AFC Championship watch party, and the bakery at 3518 NE Vivion Road has added more designs for the Super Bowl.

New cookies include heart hands, Chiefs head coach Andy Reid’s frozen mustache and slot machines to honor the team heading to Las Vegas.

You can order these cookies online or try and get a batch from their limited supply inside the store when they are open from 9:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Fridays and 9:30 a.m. to 1 p.m. on Saturdays.

Wolfy treats and ‘stache cakes

From KC Wolf cupcakes to red and gold cookie cakes, McLain’s sells a smorgasbord of sweets from its five locations across the Kansas City metro.

Owner Mollie Lothman previously told The Star that holidays and the Super Bowl are the bakery’s busiest seasons.

Recently, the business went semi-viral for its Andy Reidcicle cakes, which featured the Chiefs coach’s frozen mustache after the chilly game against the Miami Dolphins. The cakes were in such high demand, McLain’s stopped offering them at its Waldo location.

Reidcicle is back. The bakery announced that the cake is available for pre-order and pickup at its Waldo location, 201 E. Gregory Blvd., and in Lawrence at 2412 Iowa St.

Karma is the guy on the Chiefs

Prairie Village’s Dolce Bakery, 3930 W. 69th Terrace, is known for its thematic goodies. Last summer, sales of its Taylor Swift-themed cookies exploded.

Now customers can order cookies bearing the likeness of Chiefs players, including Swift’s boyfriend, Travis Kelce. Plus, cakes bearing the line Swift sang at an Eras Tour stop in South America — “karma is the guy on the Chiefs — are selling for $25.

Dolce’s Super Bowl goodies can be ordered via their website, dolcebakes.com.

Conchas and cookies

Chiefs-themed conchas are taking over the Northeast at Elvira’s Cakes. The traditional Mexican treat consists of sweet bread topped with crumbly cookie dough, and you can pick up yours, along with Chiefs-colored cookies, cakes and macarons at 3838 Independence Ave.

Kansas City toasts San Francisco?

Meshuggah Bagels is offering red and gold swirled Chiefs bagels all weekend, while supplies last.

Meshuggah is offering the kosher, New York-style Chiefs bagels at its locations: 40 E. 13th St., 1208 W. 39th St. and 7096 W. 105th St. in Overland Park.

Schmear options include plain, rosemary garlic, toasted everything, jalapeno, dirty martini, cinnamon sugar, Oreo cheesecake and more.

Bagels without a schmear cost $2, with a plain schmear cost $4.25, and with a specialty schmear cost $5.25.

In their “Super Bowl era”

Sweet Petites KC bakery at 108 E. Missouri Ave. unveiled their Super Bowl-themed treats now available for pre-order.

Options include a dozen cookies based on Las Vegas, with poker chip designs and a Patrick Mahomes cake with the likeness of his hair and headband.

You can place your orders by emailing orders@sweetpetiteskc.com or calling (816)841-1048.

Chiefs win = happy Jason

A cookie cake made by Hannah Stumpner, the manager at Eileen’s Colossal Cookies in Liberty, went viral in January

Stumpner created the confection featuring Philadelphia Eagles center Jason Kelce cheering for his brother, Travis, against the Buffalo Bills.

Photos of the cake were posted online Monday, and the bakery’s phones have been ringing ever since.

Prices range from $19, $21, and $23 for the three sizes.

To snag a slice of Jason’s chocolate-y chest hair, call the 925 W. Liberty Drive store at 816-429-5150.

Free donuts?

Donutology, with locations at 1009 Westport Road and 426 Delaware St., is bringing back its special Super Bowl-themed shirt for the big game.

While it costs $58, buyers will get a free box of a dozen donuts weekly for the rest of 2024 if the Chiefs win the big game. It cost $57 last year, but fans cashed in on the deal since the Chiefs won.

Buy the shirt online. The deal applies to both children’s and adult-size shirts.

You can also order an assorted dozen of Chiefs-themed donuts with football and field goal post designs or lettered donuts that spell Chiefs Kingdom.