By Alwyn Scott WASHINGTON (Reuters) - In the crucial minutes before an Asiana Airlines flight crashed in San Francisco last summer, the pilots voiced concern about the plane's low speed but did nothing to correct it until just before it hit the ground. A hearing on Wednesday into the July 6 crash that killed three people and injured more than 180, highlighted the pilots' mistaken reliance on the autopilot to maintain their airspeed but also Korean cultural factors that may have played a role and the design of the flight controls. The pilot flying the plane was "stressed" about hand-flying the plane, according to interviews with National Transportation Safety Board investigators, and hesitant about aborting the landing because he felt the more senior pilot observing him should make that call. Asiana Airlines Inc Flight 214 came in too slowly and too low, causing the plane's tail to hit a seawall short of the runway. The plane spun 330 degrees as it broke apart and caught fire, strewing wreckage along the runway. It was the first fatal commercial airplane accident in the United States since February of 2009 and the first fatal accident for Boeing Co's 777 airliner since it entered service in 1995. There was no indication of mechanical problems with the plane. The crash has sharpened a debate on whether over-reliance on autopilot systems in modern aircraft has led to degraded human flying skills and increased the risk of accidents. There is "an issue in aviation" with cockpit automation, NTSB Chairman Deborah Hersman told reporters covering the board's hearing but she added that the airline industry has a robust safety record. Hersman said the agency has no immediate plans to make recommendations from the hearing, but if it finds a safety issue, it can make recommendations at any time. The NTSB typically takes 12 to 18 months to complete a major investigation. TRAINING, RESCUE RESPONSE The hearing also questioned the pilots' training and the rescue response. One of the victims died from being struck by a rescue truck after the crash. Training has been central to the investigation because although the pilots had many hours of flying experience, Lee Kang-kook, the pilot flying the plane, was making his first landing of a Boeing 777 jet in San Francisco. His supervisor, Lee Jeong-min, was making his first flight as a trainer. The Asiana pilots said in interviews with the NTSB that they left their "flight director" system, which includes the autopilot, partly on. But in that mode, the system would not "wake-up" from hold mode, testified Captain John Cashman, a retired Boeing 777 test pilot, at the hearing on Wednesday. The lack of wake-up meant the autothrottle was not going to prevent the plane's speed from slipping below the minimum needed to keep it aloft. The design is consistent with Boeing's philosophy of leaving the pilot in charge of the controls. "We try not to put in design elements that override the pilot," Cashman said at the hearing. "We try to let him be the decider." Cashman said the design principles had been consistent for 31 years, across Boeing's 747, 757, 767, 777 and 787 models. SPEED CONCERNS The pilot flying the plane, Lee Kang-kook, told investigators he was worried about his ability to perform a "visual approach" to the airport, which is known for having a challenging landing. He had only performed a manual landing at that airport once before, on a Boeing 747, according to the NTSB. On July 6, he was instructed to do a manual landing because a "glide slope" system at the airport was out of service. As the plane neared the runway, a number of warnings in the cockpit indicated that the speed was dropping dangerously, according to the NTSB documents. In interviews with the NTSB, the pilots said they thought the autothrottle would correct the speed. The training pilot, Lee Jeong-min, and a third pilot, Bong Dongwon, who was in a jump seat in the cockpit, spoke about the plane's speed and "sink rate," or descent, about a minute before the plane hit the ground, according to a transcript of the cockpit voice recorder released on Wednesday. "Sink rate, sir," Bong said, about a minute before impact. "Sink rate, sir," he repeated. "Minimums, minimums," said an electronic voice about 20 seconds later. "Speed," the instructor pilot said about six seconds before impact. "Speed." The pilot later told NTSB investigators he did not feel he had the authority to abort the landing and perform a "go around." Asked whether he could have done that maneuver, he said, "that's very hard" in Korean culture because people at "one step higher level" had to make the decision to go-around. WAKE-UP CONCERN Much of the hearing addressed the use of automated systems on aircraft, which are widely credited for the safety of modern air travel because they can minimize mistakes. But they can also confuse pilots, experts said on Wednesday, particularly when pilots don't understand what "mode" the automation is in. "Problems have been observed on a large number of cockpits and for pilots at different level of experience," said Nadine Sarter, a professor at the University of Michigan and an expert on flight control automation. Bob Myers, chief of flight deck engineering for Boeing, said that if pilots are concerned about how their plane is flying under automation, the Boeing 777 system allows them to quickly exit that system and fly the plane manually. The Asiana pilots said they thought the autothrottle would "wake up" and prevent the speed from falling dangerously low. That confusion also arose in 2011 during certification of Boeing's 787 Dreamliner, which has a similar autothrottle system, documents released on Wednesday showed. In an interview following the Asiana accident, Eugene Arnold, a test pilot for the Federal Aviation Administration, said he was surprised when the 787 autothrottle did not "wake up" while set in certain "modes" but did wake up in other settings. According to NTSB documents, he thought "it was a less-than-desirable feature and it could be improved upon." Boeing did not change the system, saying the autothrottle had been certified and had no problems in service. The European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) called the two modes with no wake up feature an "inconsistency" and suggested changing the system to avoid confusing pilots, EASA wrote in a report to the FAA before it certified the jet in 2011, cited by Arnold. "Inconsistency in automation behavior has been in the past a strong contributor to aviation accidents," EASA said. Boeing says in the 787 operating manual that in certain flight modes, the autothrottle "will not wake up even during large deviations from target speed and does not support stall protection." The matter is also noted in the 777 operation manual, but in more abbreviated form. (Reporting by Alwyn Scott; Editing by Jeffrey Benkoe, Gunna Dickson and Tim Dobbyn)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
It's "not an agenda," the Watergate journalist told MSNBC's "Morning Joe."
- The Daily Beast
YouTubeThe last text Gabby Petito sent before she went missing while road-tripping across the U.S. with her fiancé set off alarm bells for her mother, who became fearful for the 22-year-old’s safety after receiving the “odd” message.That’s according to a newly-unsealed search warrant giving North Port, Florida, police permission to search a hard drive investigators found in Petito’s white van, which she and Brian Laundrie, 23, had been using to tour the country’s national parks.“The text message
The Duke of Edinburgh passed away at the age of 99.
- Miami Herald
Camila Cabello looked like she was starring in a music video for the updated version of an old ’60s song the other day.
- E! News
Authorities confirmed they found the remains of YouTuber Gabrielle Petito, who was reported missing by her parents on Sept. 11. Read the FBI's statement here.
Search warrant for Brian Laundrie: Gabby Petito's mom says conversations and texts with her appeared to show 'more and more tension' between couple
The tenor of some messages, followed by a lack of communication from Petito, is what led her mother to contact authorities, according to the warrant.
Twitter users pluck the feathers out of Mike Lindell over his latest wild claim.
A police note was found on Brian Laundrie's car after he disappeared following a hike into a Florida nature preserve, his family says
Brian Laundrie's family said they picked up the Ford Mustang from the Carlton Reserve in Florida when he didn't come home.
Harvick's clash with Chase Elliott adds intriguing layer to next round of Cup Series playoffs.
Biden Had a Four-Word Reaction After He Found Trump's Giant Video Golf Setup in the White House: Book
“Trump's existence permeated the White House,” Bob Woodward and Robert Costa write in their new book, Peril
On Monday’s airing of The ReidOut, host Joy Reid addressed the massive media coverage surrounding Gabrielle “Gabby” Petito, the young […] The post Joy Reid calls out ‘Missing White Woman Syndrome’ amid Gabby Petito case appeared first on TheGrio.
- Washington Examiner
Florida authorities searching for the boyfriend of Gabby Petito said Tuesday that someone bearing his likeness was caught on a deer camera hiking through the wilderness.
Police say four people found dead in SUV in Wisconsin were killed in Minnesota, suspect reportedly told his father he ‘snapped’
UPDATE: 9.21.21 9:10 p.m. Suspect Antoine Suggs, who was reportedly casually dating Nitosha Lee Flug-Presley, one of four people found […] The post Police say four people found dead in SUV in Wisconsin were killed in Minnesota, suspect reportedly told his father he ‘snapped’ appeared first on TheGrio.
- E! News
Instead of dancing the night away at an after-party for the 2021 Emmys, Mandy Moore celebrated ending her awards night in the best way possible: by eating pizza in her pantry.
- Good Housekeeping
We did not expect this! 🙌
Now the story can be told. Two years ago, just after Bruce Bochy had managed his last game for the San Francisco Giants, Ron Fowler, then running the San Diego Padres, called Bochy to ask if he’d like to return to San Diego to manage his old club. Bochy, now 66, had a bifurcated 25-year […]
Five teams across all three NASCAR national series were penalized Tuesday for lug-nut violations from last weekend’s events at Bristol Motor Speedway. RELATED: Las Vegas weekend schedule | Cup Series standings Crew chiefs for each team were fined for the infractions, which stemmed from NASCAR officials finding one unsecured lug nut on each vehicle in […]
Jennifer Eakins reveals her latest list of players to consider dropping to make room for options with more upside on the waiver wire.
- USA TODAY Sports - Golfweek
There's plenty of bonding at the biennial event, and not just among the players.
- USA TODAY Sports - Golfweek
Watch: Ryder Cup range interaction between Brooks Koepka, Bryson DeChambeau hints at restored relations
Ryder Cup Twitter showed a brief interaction between Bryson DeChambeau and Brooks Koepka. Does that mean the feud is over?