The Best Mail-Order Beef and Butcher Shops Across America

Lauren Hubbard, Natasha Wolff
·8 min read
Photo credit: Courtesy Eric Medsker
Photo credit: Courtesy Eric Medsker

From Town & Country

Red meat got a bad rap for a while, but it's made a comeback in the last decade, thanks to the rise of low-carb diets, and research that shows that, in moderation, a burger or steak is nothing to worry about. In fact, beef consumption is way up this year, thanks in part to people staying home and cooking during the COVID-19 pandemic.

With this growing demand for high-quality, responsibly sourced proteins, many butcher shops and meat processors now deliver nationwide, making it easier to get great quality meat even in smaller cities.

Here are a few of our favorite butchers and delivery services where you can stock up on top notch proteins.

The Best Beef

Chicago Steak Company

Order Now

In keeping with Chicago's tradition of excellent meat, this company specializes in hand-cut, midwest-raised, USDA prime beef. Expect finely aged meats from local heritage herds and Kobe-style Wagyu beef. Chicago Steak Company also boasts the largest dry-aging room in the country and pride themselves in their old-world techniques which have become scarce through time. They "really do provide the Ultimate Steak Experience."

Holy Grail Steak Co.

Order Now
This is the place to go to get a real taste of highly coveted A5-grade Japanese Wagyu beef, from the iconic Kobe to Kagoshima to Wagyu grazed on special diets like olives from Shodoshima Island or fermented rice from the Dassai Sake Brewery. Of course that's not all they carry—you can also get your hands on USDA prime Black Angus, burgers, Kurobuta pork, as well as American- and Australian-raised Wagyu steaks: everything you need to have a true beef taste-off.

Photo credit: VICUSCHKA - Getty Images
Photo credit: VICUSCHKA - Getty Images

Snake River Farms

Order Now

Family-owned-and-operated Idaho purveyor Snake River Farms sells its signature American Wagyu beef (tomahawk rib-eye and filet mignon are two popular cuts), dry aged steaks, and Kurobuta pork (their bone-in chops are a must) to discerning customers. "We are involved in the production from start to finish," said Dave Yasuda, the brand's director of marketing and ecommerce. "We like to call it a 'ranch-to-table' approach since we have control of key steps from genetics all the way to final processing." If you're feeding a crowd (or just planning ahead) they also offer provisioning bundles so you can stock up on a dozen NY strips or ribeye filets all in one go.

DeBragga

Order Now
This New York-based butcher is a favorite of some of the top steak restaurants in NYC, and for good reason. The butcher shop, which was founded in the early 1920s, has specialized in top-quality meats for close to a century, including everything from perfectly dry aged beef for a rich meaty flavor to silky Wagyu (available in American, Australian, and Japanese varieties) as well as pork from prized Iberico pigs and apple-raised lamb chops, plus game meat, poultry, and cured selections.

Photo credit: Lisovskaya - Getty Images
Photo credit: Lisovskaya - Getty Images

Porter Road

Order Now
If you're looking to simplify your butcher shop shopping, Porter Road offers specialty subscription boxes of their pasture raised, antibiotic free meats, with options like grill-master favorites, breakfast stand-bys, and weeknight basics, so you can get regular deliveries of your protein staples. Of course, you can also go a la carte with a wide range of cuts from their hand-cut meats sourced from Kentucky, Tennessee, and Pennsylvania.

Omaha Steaks

Order Now
Want a one-stop-shop for your meat needs? In addition to the lush, perfectly-aged steaks you'd expect from this Nebraska-based butcher, the brand also offers everything you need to put together stand out meals; from sausage, poultry, and seafood, to sides, sauces, pre-prepped skillet meals—even desserts and wine.

ButcherBox

Order Now
Like a food subscription box, but specifically geared toward meat, this monthly delivery subscription offers plenty of options for every kind of carnivorous dining, including a custom box made of your favorite cuts of grassfed beef, free range chicken, and heritage pork, as well as an all-beef box, a beef and pork box, a beef and chicken option, and a mixed box of carefully chosen tastes—all raised free of antibiotics and added hormones.

Photo credit: Diana Miller - Getty Images
Photo credit: Diana Miller - Getty Images

Belcampo

Order Now

The West Coast-centric Belcampo was founded in 2011 by Anya Fernald and Todd Robinson after they spent years trying to figure out how they could best foster the growth of the sustainable quality food movement. The company's 18,000-acre organic ranch houses organic, grass-fed cattle and thus the meat produced has a very short supply chain. Look to them for great cuts of beef, pork, lamb, and poultry was well as slab bacon, signature sausages, and bone broth. For nose-to-tail eaters, they're also one of the rare purveyors to offer offal options.

Pat LaFrieda

Order Now
The Brooklyn-born butcher shop (now located in New Jersey), which offers delivery, has been in business since 1922. Its new 36,000-square-foot facility has two dry-aging rooms that house over 80,000 steaks at any given time. LaFrieda's superstar beef can be found at such steakhouse stalwarts as Peter Luger, Porter House New York, and Minetta Tavern—and now, your dining room.

Allen Brothers

Order Now

Allen Brothers's legacy in sourcing only the finest in USDA Prime Beef from the stockyards of Chicago for more than 125 years has forged la reputation for the kind of ultra high quality product that you can't find at your local grocer. The purveyor ages its grain-fed and pasture-raised products for 60 days as part of a patented aging process in which the beef is dry- or wet-aged prior to cutting. "People are seeing that if they are going to spend good money on a steak, then it has to be the best," says John DeBenedetti, the brand's director and EVP of Protein (yes, that's his real title), who's noticed an increase in demand for gifting options for the holiday season.

Mr. Steak

Order Now

Handle all of your grilling needs with this online butcher shop, which not only offers succulent, pasture-raised steaks, but also seasonings and grills to complete the carnivorous package. The service allows you to get hands-on with your selections by building your own box of favorites like marbled ribeyes, tender filets, mega-sized cowboy steaks, and rich burgers made from ground brisket—or get a variety with one of their curated boxes. As a feel-good bonus, all of the meats are delivered to your door by carbon neutral shipping in a biodegradable cooler.

Gourmet Meats and More

Photo credit: Courtesy Belcampo
Photo credit: Courtesy Belcampo

Harry & David

Order Now

Purveyors of gourmet gifts and monthly clubs, Harry & David provides exceptional delivery service of premier fruits, vegetables, beverages, cheeses, and yes, meats. An age-old family business, Harry and David Rosenberg (son's of an acclaimed 19th-century Seattle Farmer) have defined the gold standard in luxury food delivery, since the 1930's. And because agriculture is at their roots, Harry & David focuses on responsible farming behaviors in the foods they harvest. They claim to have a reputation "for unmatched quality and customer service."

D'Artagnan

Order Now
It was poultry that made this culinary powerhouse famous, launching in 1985 as the first delivery purveyor of game and foie gras in the States, and fowl remains a top notch choice from the brand's online store, though it's no longer the only mainstay. From Thanksgiving turkey to rack of lamb, charcuterie to caviar, this gourmet selection has everything you need for a decadent (and ethically-sourced) feast.

Fossil Farms

Order Now
For those craving a taste of something truly unique, Fossil Farms offers an online menu full of esoteric options from all walks of the animal kingdom. Whether you want something traditional like Scottish game meats or something really off the beaten path—think: yak, kangaroo, alligator, and ostrich—this New Jersey supplier has you covered.

Photo credit: Courtesy Allen Brothers
Photo credit: Courtesy Allen Brothers

Creekstone Farms

Order Now

Creekstone Farms's hormone-and-antibiotic-free Duroc pork and Black Angus beef selections are processed in the brand's state-of-the-art, 450,000-square-foot facility in Arkansas City, Kansas. To give you a sense of how picky they are about their genetics, less than one percent of all cattle harvested in the United States makes it into their facility. The innovative company even collaborated with Dr. Temple Grandin, an expert in the field of animal welfare, to create a set of humane guidelines for handling its cattle.

Murray's Cheese

Order Now

A tradition founded in New York City's eclectic Greenwich Village, Murray's Cheese boasts gourmet cheeses and specialty foods from around the world. The purveyors of luxury cheese and charcuterie offers a wide selection of artisan and house-made specialties and everything you need to put together a veritable smorgasbord of noshes. Additionally, the brand also offers a slew of monthly clubs and subscriptions for delectable gifting.

Cote

Order Now

If you're looking for a meaty curated meal, this Michelin-starred Korean steakhouse has your back. In addition to their in-house dry aged beef, the NYC restaurant also offers artfully designed meal experiences for delivery, like thier Prime Galbi Feast for four people with marinated boneless short ribs, house pickled vegetables, ssamjang sauce, and lettuce for wrapping or their Butcher's Feast packed with hanger steak, ribeye, Wagyu, and short ribs plus all of the fixings.

Brodo

Order Now
Bone broth has been a hot commodity for the last few years, but for those who want to try the trend (or are already committed) but don't want to spend the time slowly simmering their own broth, James Beard Award-winning chef Marco Canora makes it even easier by selling his signature broth blends online—frozen and available to ship around the country.

You Might Also Like