Best and Worst Small Freezers
CR-tested space-saving models for smaller households
By Mary H.J. Farrell
On most days you might not need more freezer space than what’s in your refrigerator. But for those times when you’re stocking up for a family event or taking advantage of a sale on your favorite cut of meat, having a little extra freezer capacity comes in handy.
Below are five small chest and upright freezers (5 to 9 cubic feet) that perform well in CR’s tests for temperature uniformity and thermostat control, and that run efficiently. We also point out one small freezer from our tests that isn’t up to snuff.
If floor space is an issue, keep in mind that upright freezers have a smaller footprint for the equivalent storage space of a chest freezer (one reason fewer uprights fall into the small-capacity category). And remember that manufacturers recommend leaving a clearance of about 3 inches around any freezer so that it has the airflow it needs to run properly.
Another consideration is the expense of operating an extra appliance. “The cost of running a small freezer can be as much as running a large one,” says Joseph Pacella, who oversees our freezer tests. To compare the operating costs of freezers as you shop, check the yellow Energy Guide labels on each model.
For more on freezers of any size, see our freezer ratings and buying guide.
Best Small Chest Freezers
Best Small Upright Freezer
Frigidaire FFFU06M1TW
CR’s take: Manual-defrosting uprights like this one tend to score lower in our tests than self-defrosting uprights, but they cost less to buy and run. The Frigidaire FFFU06M1TW gets top marks for temperature control, meaning it hits and maintains our set temperature. But we detected a few warm and cool spots in our tests, which lowers the score a bit. Still, it maintains its internal temperature well in the power outage test and runs quietly. We estimate it costs $36 a year to run. This model’s footprint is 22 inches wide by 22 inches deep.
And a Small Freezer That Doesn't Cut It
It’s too bad the slim Insignia NS-UZ7WHO performs so poorly in our tests—earning only a 37 out of a possible 100—because it’s a real space saver. (Its usable capacity is 5 cubic feet, and the footprint is 22 inches wide by 22 inches deep.) This manual-defrost upright earns impressive scores on our thermostat control test (in which we gauge how well a model hits and holds the set temperature of 0° F), and the temperature inside stays fairly consistent.
But this model’s downfall is its performance in the blackout test, in which we unplug it for 9 hours to simulate a power outage. The temperature inside rose quickly, so you would likely have to toss the contents after a real blackout. This Insignia’s impressive performance in the temperature tests aren’t enough to offset its Poor rating in the blackout test. Plus, it costs more to run than the others on this list—$43 a year.
More from Consumer Reports:
Top pick tires for 2016
Best used cars for $25,000 and less
7 best mattresses for couples
Consumer Reports is an independent, nonprofit organization that works side by side with consumers to create a fairer, safer, and healthier world. CR does not endorse products or services, and does not accept advertising. Copyright © 2022, Consumer Reports, Inc.
