The body matters. That's why, as university president, I am concerned for my female athletes.

The sun was a long way from rising yet Alison was already running on quiet campus roads as I left for the airport.

She didn’t have to be up so early. But she was. That’s how she is wired.

Alison is a bit over 5 feet tall, so she says, and maybe a little north of 100 pounds. Intimidating to look at she is not. Alison is also one of the finest, toughest, fiercest athletes I have ever met. In one track and field event, she ranks as one of the top 20 NCAA D-III women athletes in the country.

Waving as I drove past Alison on that extremely cold morning, my heart broke for her. You see, despite her early mornings, rigorous workouts and athletic gifts, in her D-III women’s category, Alison may have to compete against athletes who I believe have an unfair advantage: transgender women.

Opinions in your inbox: Get a digest of our takes on current events every day

Biology 101 tells us men’s bodies and women’s bodies are different. Because they are, Title IX legislation has elevated women’s sports in schools over the past 50 years, making it possible for more female athletes to compete against other female athletes. Because their bodies are different, we have the NBA and WNBA, the PGA and LPGA, ATP and WTA. These divisions give women the opportunity to measure their hard work and success against other women on an even playing field.

Lia Thomas wins, sets records

Recently, Lia Thomas made news as a transgender female swimmer who competed on the University of Pennsylvania men’s team for three years until joining the women’s team. Despite NCAA-required testosterone suppression treatment, Lia easily won many of her races, setting several pool records along the way.

Columnist Suzette Hackney: Simone Biles is an inspiration, whether competing or ‘pushing mental health to the forefront’

University of Pennsylvania swimmer Lia Thomas made history in March 2022 by becoming the first transgender woman to win an NCAA swimming competition in Division I.
University of Pennsylvania swimmer Lia Thomas made history in March 2022 by becoming the first transgender woman to win an NCAA swimming competition in Division I.

Over the years, I have walked with men and women who struggle with their body, their identity. It’s often a painful journey. They feel isolated, trapped and despairing. We need to do all we can to help these individuals.

But we can’t tell them drugs or surgery will bring their body in line with what they experience and feel. We can’t say the human body doesn’t matter when it matters greatly.

Appreciating both male and female

The male body and female body are beautifully and wonderfully made. They have inestimable value and dignity. To experience the full beauty, we must appreciate both male and female, see their complementarity and difference, and celebrate both. We should be awed by this rather than trying to deny it, even when the body and mind conflict.

USA TODAY's Women of the Year: Meet the inspiring, remarkable leaders

Father Dave Pivonka in Steubenville, Ohio, in 2020.
Father Dave Pivonka in Steubenville, Ohio, in 2020.

The body matters. That’s why, as a university president, I am concerned for my female athletes. They will work hard, be diligent in their training, and on race day lose to transgender athletes. Tragically, it becomes another example of how the system is rigged against women because they were born women. Our female athletes deserve better. Alison deserves better.

Columnist Connie Schultz: Madeleine Albright made history, then insisted on helping other women make theirs.

Alison and I talked a couple of times about saying something on the impact of transgender athletes on women’s athletics. I was nervous she might experience negative consequences for speaking out publicly. I was worried something would happen to her while she was racing. She wasn’t.

You see, she’s built that way, tough, scrappy. I’ll never forget her face, looking up at me as she bravely said, “Father Dave, it’s just a race. We have to say something. There are things more important than running.”

Alison wins again. She will always be a champion in my eyes.

Author and speaker Father Dave Pivonka became president of Franciscan University of Steubenville (Ohio) in 2019.

You can read diverse opinions from our Board of Contributors and other writers on the Opinion front page, on Twitter @usatodayopinion and in our daily Opinion newsletter. To respond to a column, submit a comment to letters@usatoday.com.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Transgender athletes conversations I'm having on my campus