Chamber-linked group paid $470K to ‘ghost’ candidate operatives in 2020, tax record reveal

A Florida Chamber of Commerce affiliate in 2020 paid nearly half a million dollars to a political consulting firm whose operatives played a key role in Florida’s “ghost” candidate scandal, surveilled a Jacksonville journalist and secretly gained control of a Tallahassee-based news site, tax records show.

IRS forms show Secure Florida’s Future, which is chaired by Chamber President and CEO Mark Wilson, paid $470,000 in 2020 to Alabama-based Matrix LLC. And the next year, Secure Florida’s Future transferred $2 million to a dark money nonprofit organization linked to the Montgomery firm.

The Center for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, a watchdog group, obtained the tax records and shared them with the Orlando Sentinel.

Ivette Faulkner, the chamber’s executive vice president of strategic communication and marketing, said the payment to Matrix was “non-political” and intended “to educate Floridians on issues that impact Florida’s economic and job growth,” but declined to elaborate.

Secure Florida’s Future spent more than $8.5 million in 2020 and 2021, according to tax documents. Nonprofit dark money organizations like Secure Florida’s Future are required to disclose their contributions publicly, but not their contributors.

Joe Perkins, Matrix’s owner, did not respond to an email this week asking about what services the firm performed for Secure Florida’s Future.

The Orlando Sentinel and other media outlets have reported extensively over the past 18 months about how Matrix employees used a variety of tactics to sway elections across Florida, resist citizen efforts to reshape the state Constitution and advance the interests of powerful corporations.

The efforts were revealed in a series of leaked documents, including emails, bank records and internal reports from the firm. The records showed Matrix employees worked closely with executives at Florida Power & Light over a period of several years.

Matrix operatives secretly acquired control of a Tallahassee-based political news site, The Capitolist, and gave executives influence over the site’s coverage. Employees also had a Jacksonville journalist covertly monitored after he wrote critically about FPL.

When FPL was seeking to acquire Jacksonville’s public utility, JEA, Matrix operatives arranged a job offer in 2019 meant to lure a critic of the deal to leave the City Council.

And Matrix operatives also funded a dark-money ad campaign promoting “ghost” candidates in three key 2020 Florida Senate races as progressives, in an apparent scheme to siphon votes away from the Democrats in each race and help Republicans win.

The defeated candidates included former Democratic Sen. José Javier Rodríguez, one of FPL’s most prominent critics in the legislature who had drawn the personal ire of the utility’s CEO, Eric Silagy. “I want you to make his life a living hell….seriously,” Silagy wrote in a leaked 2019 email to two of his vice presidents, one of whom forwarded it to former Matrix CEO Jeff Pitts.

Secure Florida’s Future seeks to educate “the citizens of Florida about economic job growth,” according to the organization’s documents.

But the public needs only to look at Matrix’s track record to infer why the Chamber-backed group wanted to hire them, said Michael Barfield, director of public access initiatives for the Florida Center for Government Accountability, a Sarasota-based watchdog group. The Chamber’s nonprofit aims to “empower corporations,” he said, and Matrix was well-suited to help them accomplish that goal.

“I think that really gets to the heart of the issue,” Barfield said. “The amount of dark money spending by corporate interests has exploded.”

The 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision in the Citizens United v. Federal Elections Commission case, which enabled corporations and other outside groups to spend unlimited money on elections, was a “tragedy” Barfield said, because it allows businesses to exert enormous influence over the political process.

“Dark money takes power away from the people and until there’s meaningful change, corporations will have all the muscle,” Barfield said.

In addition to the direct payment to Matrix in 2020, Secure Florida’s Future reported a $2 million contribution to the Coalition Against Electricity Deregulation, a nonprofit chaired by a relative of a former Matrix employee, in 2021.

The Sentinel reported earlier this year that Secure Florida’s Future contributed $630,000 late in the 2020 election cycle to a network of dark-money groups tied to the “ghost” candidate scandal. The bank records disclosing the payment were included in a Florida Department of Law Enforcement probe that emerged from reporting by the Sentinel and other news outlets about the candidates.

The payment from Secure Florida’s Future was recorded on Sept. 2, 2020, to another nonprofit organization run by Republican consultant Stafford Jones.

On Sept. 30, Jones’ nonprofit transferred the same sum to Let’s Preserve the American Dream, a nonprofit run by Ryan Tyson, a consultant with close ties to the state’s big business lobby, Associated Industries of Florida.

One day earlier, Let’s Preserve reported a $600,000 contribution to a third nonprofit, Grow United, which spent the money on the ad blitz promoting the “ghost” candidates to voters in Central and South Florida.

Jones said the contribution from Secure Florida’s Future was not related to the transfer to Tyson’s group and the chamber declined to say what the payment was intended for.

Jones, Tyson, FPL and the Chamber have not been accused of wrongdoing by authorities.

But five people have been charged criminally in connection with the “ghost” candidate scandal, including 2020 Florida Senate candidates Alex Rodriguez and Jestine Iannotti; Frank Artiles, a former lawmaker accused of bribing Rodriguez to seek office; former Seminole County GOP Chair Ben Paris and Central Florida political consultant Eric Foglesong.

Rodriguez pleaded guilty and a jury convicted Paris on a misdemeanor charge. Artiles, Iannotti and Foglesong are still awaiting trial.