Chariho school bond narrowly fails. What comes next?

Residents across the Chariho Regional School District voted Tuesday not to borrow $150 million to build three new elementary schools and upgrade the district's main campus in Richmond.

It was a narrow defeat for proponents of the school bond, which polarized residents of the three towns. The unofficial result according to the Rhode Island Board of Elections was 2,442 against the bond and 2,367 in favor – a 75-vote difference. A majority of residents of Charlestown voted for the bond, but most voters in Hopkinton and a slight majority in Richmond voted against it.

Catherine Giusti, chair of the Chariho School Committee and a proponent of the bond, said she was disappointed with the outcome.

“This bond vote became more about the anger of some rather than focusing on the opportunity to improve our schools. I hope is that, going forward, the larger Chariho community can return its focus to making our schools better for our kids,” Giusti said.

Hope Valley Elementary School in Hopkinton.
Hope Valley Elementary School in Hopkinton.

Opponents of the school bond argued it would raise taxes and that renovating the current elementary schools would be cheaper, but the school district emphasized that the cost of renovating would be the same as building new schools. Gina Picard, superintendent of Chariho School District, previously told The Journal it was a once-in-a-generation opportunity for the district because of special reimbursement bonuses offered for a limited time by the state Department of Education.

Misinformation about the fate of the school buildings and the terms of reimbursement from the state, among other issues, may also have swayed some to vote against the bond.

On the ballot: Voters in Chariho to decide fate of 3 new schools. Is misinformation fueling opposition?

What happens now in Chariho

The district now faces a difficult choice. Options presented by the school district include voting on a new bond in November, which would address HVAC, plumbing and electrical needs but not include any new construction or renovations, or prioritizing emergency needs only. Renovations would require submitting new paperwork to the state for approval.

Picard said the district “will craft a new plan that reflects our shared values and aspirations for our children's future.” However, she clarified that the district will need to consult the School Committee first to determine next steps.

She also thanked voters who participated in the referendum.

“While the bond may have been rejected, we view this as an opportunity to regroup, reassess and emerge stronger. Our resolve remains unshaken as we embark on a new journey, forging a fresh path toward securing the resources our schools need to thrive,” Picard said.

South Kingstown bond passes

While Chariho voters rejected its school-construction bond, voters in South Kingstown passed a similar bond to build a new high school and other facilities in their district.

Voters there approved the measure by 54.59% to 45.41%, based on unofficial results released by the Board of Elections on Tuesday night.

This article originally appeared on The Providence Journal: Chariho school bond fails despite strong support from Charlestown voters