Advertisement

Hernández: Is Brandon Staley the right coach to lead Justin Herbert and the Chargers?

dylan hernández
·5 min read
23
Chargers coach Brandon Staley speaks on the sidelines during a loss to the Jaguars
The Chargers' leadership must decide whether it can afford to wait for coach Brandon Staley to learn from the mistakes he made during a playoff collapse Saturday night in Jacksonville, Fla. (Chris O'Meara / Associated Press)

As the Chargers’ 27-point advantage gradually vanished, the look on Brandon Staley’s face told the story of the game.

Staley looked confused.

He looked shocked.

He looked the same way Sean McVay did when Bill Belichick embarrassed him in the Super Bowl.

Doug Pederson has won a championship, Staley hasn’t, and that difference was exhibited during the soul-crushing second half of the Chargers' 31-30 loss to the Jacksonville Jaguars on Saturday night in an NFL wild-card playoff game.

That’s the ground Staley has to make up if the Chargers are to have any chance of reaching a Super Bowl. That’s the distance he has to cover to justify the team retaining him.

Staley is smart. He’s a good communicator. He’s fearless. He’s just 40. He was in his second year as a head coach this season. Before the Chargers hired him, he was a coordinator for only one season.

He just needs time.

The problem: The Chargers don’t have any.

Next season will be Justin Herbert’s final year on a rookie contract.

In other words, the Chargers only have one more year during which their quarterback will be one of the NFL's most underpaid players. They only have one more year before they are expected to start paying him as much as anyone has been paid to play football. They only have one more year during which they will be able to surround him with the caliber of talent they did this season.

Dean or John Spanos or general manager Tom Telesco will have to determine whether Staley can lead the Chargers to a Super Bowl next season.

That’s the question. That’s the only question.

Staley has one of the game’s brightest defensive minds, but is he that coach?

He wasn’t Saturday night. He wasn’t even close.

With the Jaguars erasing a 27-point lead, the Chargers were the victims of the third-largest comeback in postseason history. Here’s what was especially stunning: The Chargers blew their bigadvantage without committing a turnover.

Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence scores a two-point conversion.
Jacksonville quarterback Trevor Lawrence scores a two-point conversion to bring the Jaguars to within two points after a penalty by Joey Bosa gave them better field position Saturday night. (Robert Gauthier / Los Angeles Times)

This wasn’t a case of a quarterback throwing an errant pass or a running back failing to hold on to the football. This was a case of a young coach being outclassed by a more seasoned opponent, the result a tidal wave the Chargers had no chance of turning back.

Pederson adjusted, Staley couldn’t adjust in response, and that was the game.

Staley came out with a defensive game plan that contributed to the Chargers intercepting four of Trevor Lawrence’s passes in the first half. However, when Pederson increased the tempo of his offense, the Chargers had no answers for the Jaguars’ no-huddle plays. The shift in momentum was magnified by some backbreaking penalties. Suddenly, the Chargers couldn’t get a stop.

Offensively, the Chargers continued to be failed by their suspect ground game, the inability to run the ball preventing them from controlling the clock. The Jaguars increased their pressure on Herbert and kept wide receiver Keenan Allen under wraps, a task made easier because of the absence of receiver Mike Williams, who was injured in Week 18 when Staley played his starters during a meaningless game against the Denver Broncos.

This experience should make Staley a better coach.

He has already demonstrated a willingness to change, his tempered aggression on fourth down a notable example. The guess here is he won’t play his starters into the fourth quarter of a regular-season finale the next time he already has a playoff seed secured.

Jaguars defenders smother Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert late in the AFC wild-card game.
Jaguars defenders smother Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert late in the AFC wild-card game at TIAA Bank Field on Saturday night in Jacksonville, Fla. (Robert Gauthier / Los Angeles Times)

The Chargers have paid for his mistakes in each of the last two seasons. They should at least consider whether they could benefit from what he has learned from those errors.

And if retaining Staley carries an element of risk, so does replacing him, as a new coach next season would be Herbert’s third in four years.

The franchise’s decision makers could very well determine that what Staley needs is veteran help, like what Wade Phillips provided as defensive coordinator for McVay during his first three seasons with the Rams. Perhaps the Chargers replace Joe Lombardi with a more experienced offensive coordinator.

Then again, what happened in Jacksonville can’t be overlooked. Staley was dominated in a way that had to shake his players’ confidence in him. The Chargers Curse that Staley strove to eradicate resurfaced stronger than ever, his new-age approach producing the same old results. Ultimately, taking on the history of a franchise might have been too great a task for a coach who didn’t have much a history of his own.

Now, the organization has to decide whether to place another wager on Staley. The time element increases the difficulty of the evaluation. Figuring out whether Staley can become a championship coach is only part of the equation. Calculating how quickly he can make that transformation is the other.

This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.