Construction at Brooklyn subway station causes flooding, damage and frustration for Williamsburg businesses, residents

Construction at a Brooklyn subway stop aimed at making the station ADA compliant has caused flooding, shattered windows and damaged nearby property, say area residents and business owners.

The work at the Metropolitan Ave./Lorimer St. station in Williamsburg is meant to bring the station up to snuff with new elevators, raised boarding areas, sidewalk curbs and Braille signs, among other improvements. Construction is expected to wrap up later this year.

But as the work proceeds, the complaints roll in.

ā€œThis has been an absolute nightmare for myself, neighbors and other fellow small businesses across the Metropolitan, Lorimer and Union vicinity,ā€ said Joseph Franquinha, owner of Crest Hardware, a 61-year-old business upstairs from the station.

ā€œWhile weā€™re all understanding and compassionate to the ADA needs of our city, there are right ways and wrong ways of going about it,ā€ Franquinha said. ā€œAnd this is most certainly the wrong way.ā€

City Council member Jennifer GutiĆ©rrez (D-Brooklyn) and Assemblywoman Emily Gallagher (D-Brooklyn) called for ā€œimmediate interventionā€ to address neighborsā€™ concerns in a letter to Jamie Torres-Springer, the president of construction and development for the MTA.

Conditions on the project ā€œare not just a nuisance, but dangerous, and we know that the MTA typically holds their contractors to a higher standard,ā€ said the letter, shared with the Daily News.

ā€œOf course, some nuisance is to be expected around construction, but the MTAā€™s total disregard of this area has even led to city agencies complaining about the MTAā€™s lack of communication and coordination,ā€ GutiĆ©rrez said in a statement.

She added that sheā€™s been complaining for months, but that conditions have worsened. ā€œI donā€™t think we would see this level of neglect in places like Manhattan,ā€ GutiĆ©rrez said.

Franquinha said the construction caused flooding in his building that left tenants without heat or hot water for days.

One day in December, construction crews dumped the water from two big dumpsters that held concrete water into the street, he said.

ā€œIt created backflow and came back up the pipes and up Metropolitan Avenue,ā€ he said.

The dark, murky, pungent water, mixed with sewage and with an oily film across the top, leached under the sidewalk and into Franquinhaā€™s basement, the building owner said.

Franquinha pulled on galoshes and grabbed some garbage bags, and got to work cleaning the ā€œdisgusting, unsanitaryā€ mess.

ā€œI wouldnā€™t wish that on my worst enemy, to sift through that ā€¦ Weā€™re talking a 1500-square-foot basement filled with water 2Ā½ feet high. I mean, thatā€™s a lot of water,ā€ he said.

Lisa Summa, 58, a retired public school teacher who lives next to the construction, said sheā€™s felt unsafe coming home at night because the construction creates a dark tunnel to her door. Late-night work on the project has interrupted her sleep, she added.

ā€œYour home is not your home,ā€ said Summa, a lifelong resident of Williamsburg. ā€œTheyā€™re literally in my living room with noise. Itā€™s an unbelievable feeling. We donā€™t even open our windows because of dirt [in the air].ā€

Summa and more than a dozen other nearby residents organized the Friends of Lorimer group to challenge the project. ā€œIt did feel like the MTA was paying lip service about wanting to be a good neighbor,ā€ she said.

ā€œYou can put this elevator, do it well, and also try to cause minimal impact to the community.ā€

Ivan Garcia, a co-owner of Zona Rosa, a Mexican restaurant on the corner of Metropolitan and Lorimer, said that his business is down 60% since construction began last year, and that heā€™s had to lay off servers and bartenders.

He blames the construction ā€” it hides the restaurant from view and blocks foot traffic.

ā€œI think itā€™s the worst year, ever, for us,ā€ he said. ā€œToday is Taco Tuesday. Usually, everyone is here, looking for happy hour. But now, we have nobody.ā€

Vibrations have caused two-inch-wide cracks in the concrete floor and several broken windows in the restaurantā€™s building, Garcia said.

Additionally, he said, water has pooled in places it didnā€™t before on the restaurantā€™s open roof. Garcia fears that may be a sign that the buildingā€™s foundation is damaged.

ā€œThey have big machines and then the whole building vibrates ā€” it shakes,ā€ Garcia said.

An MTA spokesperson told the Daily News that crews have been performing limited night work inside the Lorimer St. station, which is allowed since the station is indoors and open 24/7.

The agency has also been made aware of damage to a nearby building, the spokesperson said, and is investigating whether the ongoing construction is to blame.

The work at the Metropolitan Ave./Lorimer St. station is part of a larger effort by the MTA to improve accessibility in its stations, following the settlement of a lawsuit against the agency brought by disability advocates.

The MTA committed last year to making 95% of the subway system accessible. Fewer than a third of the cityā€™s subway stations are now accessible in line with ADA standards.

Advertisement