By Julie Steenhuysen and Bill Berkrot CHICAGO (Reuters) - Controversial heart disease prevention guidelines that abandoned specific targets for reducing "bad" LDL cholesterol are under fresh assault after a major study highlighted the benefits of taking LDL to very low levels. Guidelines issued last year by the American Heart Association and the American College of Cardiology asked doctors to assess individual patients' risk for heart disease over 10 years based on a complex calculation of risks posed by lifestyle, family history and other health conditions. Those deemed at sufficient risk would be prescribed cholesterol-lowering statins. The recommendation overturned decades of practice in which doctors screened patients for high cholesterol, then sought to reduce LDL to a specific level. Many cardiologists criticized the guidelines, saying they were confusing, and that patients and physicians were comfortable with measurable goals to reduce the risk of heart disease, the world's No. 1 killer. Those opponents got a boost from data released on Monday showing high-risk patients fared better when their LDL was brought to very low levels by adding Merck & Co's Zetia to treatment with a statin. Several prominent heart specialists told Reuters the guidelines should be changed, with some advocating LDL targets even lower than previous ones. Many have ignored the year-old recommendations. "I never really bought the new guidelines," said Dr. Andrew Klaus of Mount Carmel Health System in Columbus, Ohio. The Zetia trial “definitely showed that lower is better," he said. "I would predict the guidelines are going to be rewritten very soon." The so-called Improve-It trial of Merck's Zetia, unveiled at the AHA’s annual meeting in Chicago, studied more than 18,000 high-risk patients. It showed they could further cut heart attacks and strokes by taking LDL cholesterol from about 70 to around 53. Dr. Steven Nissen, cardiology chief at the Cleveland Clinic, said the result "blows up" the prevention guidelines. "It matters how low you go (with LDL) ... which is why many of us were so upset about the guidelines," Nissen told Reuters. At a recent meeting of cardiologists and primary care doctors, Nissen asked how many had adopted the guidelines. "Three out of those 300 raised their hand," he said. "Nobody is using them." 'SCIENTIFIC TOMES' Millions of Americans at risk of heart disease could be affected by the outcome of the debate. Some 83.6 million live with some form or cardiovascular disease or the effects of stroke, according to the AHA. By some estimates, the new guidelines would boost the use of high-potency statins such as AstraZeneca's Crestor and Pfizer Inc's Lipitor, now available as cheaper generic atorvastatin. The debate could also affect the future of new medicines from Amgen Inc and Regeneron Pharmaceuticals Inc that reduce LDL even more aggressively. In Reuters interviews with more than a dozen cardiologists attending the AHA meeting, most said they were wrestling with the guidelines. AHA and ACC officials have heard the complaints and said the guidelines are subject to revision based on new scientific data. "We don't want guidelines that serve as scientific tomes that nobody finds useful," said Dr. Robert Harrington, an AHA board member. "We need our guidelines to really help guide practice." When a major trial like Improve-It comes out, "AHA absolutely responds to that," he said. Dr. Patrick O’Gara, president of the ACC, said the new guidelines were based on the fact that clinical trials of cholesterol-lowering statin drugs were not designed to test the effectiveness of specific cholesterol targets - only the drugs themselves. Doctors following the guidelines tend to test cholesterol levels far less frequently, and that has some in the field worried. "We're still having this back and forth, which seems to represent a gap between the manner in which trials were designed and the practical implications," O’Gara said. "I hope we will be able to strike the right balance in the process." CLARIFYING THE MESSAGE Dr. Lori Mosca of New York-Presbyterian Hospital, who helps train residents, said she is frequently asked how to interpret the guidelines. "There is sufficient confusion out there that it's worthy of clarifying what the message is," she said. Dr. Matthew Sorrentino, a preventive cardiologist at University of Chicago Medicine, uses the guidelines. But he said the older targets - an LDL of 70 for high-risk patients - were easier for doctors and patients to grasp. "Almost everybody knew what the LDL target was," he said. "I can see making the guidelines easier to follow." Writers of the guidelines, such as Dr. Donald Lloyd-Jones of Northwestern Medicine in Chicago, defended the scientific rigor behind them. He said focusing on a cholesterol goal may have led to undertreatment, perhaps failing to take into account the added risks from diabetes, obesity or smoking. A new class of drugs, known as PCSK9 inhibitors, that can lower LDL by more than 50 percent may increase the pressure for new, even lower, LDL targets, some doctors said. One from Amgen and another developed by Regeneron and Sanofi are expected to reach the market next year and initially be used in patients with extremely high cholesterol or those who cannot tolerate statins. "We can't really get away from paying attention to what the LDL is," said Dr. Daniel Rader, director of the preventive cardiology program at the University of Pennsylvania. (Reporting by Julie Steenhuysen and Bill Berkrot; Editing by Michele Gershberg and Douglas Royalty)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
Jennifer Gates, the eldest daughter of Bill Gates and Melinda French Gates, celebrated her wedding to Nayel Nassar over the weekend
- Business Insider
Fox News anchor John Roberts deleted a tweet that questioned vaccine efficacy in light of Colin Powell's death, clarifying that he is actually pro-vaccine
"The fact that Colin Powell died from a breakthrough COVID infection raises new concerns about how effective vaccines are long-term," he said initially.
- Atlanta Black Star
A California Construction Worker Asked a Speeding Motorist to Slow Down. He Was Shot Seven Times In Response.
The family of a California Black construction worker wants answers after their loved one was shot several times in what is now being looked at […]
He's taking the news "really bad."
- Yahoo Sports
It doesn't get much uglier than what happened in Knoxville on Saturday night. The question is what's going to be done about it.
Powell, the first Black U.S. secretary of state, was receiving treatment at Walter Reed National Medical Center, his family said. He was 84.
In CNN's docuseries Diana, royal experts discuss a 'Mean Girls' moment when Camilla Parker Bowles left a note for Princess Diana before her wedding to Charles.
- Business Insider
Hooters adjusts policy to make controversial new uniform optional for employees after outcry over skimpy new shorts that are 'like underwear'
"We are clarifying that they have the option to choose from traditional uniforms or the new ones," a spokesperson wrote in an email to Insider.
- CBS News
Madeline Baharlou-Quivey's message said she had strayed from the standard route to Kit Carson Peak.
- Access Hollywood
Kourtney Kardashian and Travis Barker are feeling lots of love from their family and friends after getting engaged. Kourtney confirmed the news on her Instagram page, writing simply “Forever” in her caption alongside two romantic snaps of her and her new fiancé embracing amid a massive display of red roses. Kourtney’s sister Kim Kardashian shared a video on Twitter showing off the Poosh founder’s sparkly engagement ring, writing, “KRAVIS FOREVER” along with an engagement ring emoji.
- Business Insider
Billionaire ex-Walmart exec says the first 'settlers' of his planned $400 billion city 'Telosa' will likely be selected through applications - and they could move in by 2030
Telosa, a futuristic city created by Marc Lore, plans to offer its citizens equal access to education, healthcare, and transportation.
Christopher Steele says he thinks the infamous golden showers tape is real -- and shared why he believes Russia hasn't released it.
- Titans Wire
Players fantasy managers should be targeting on the waiver wire in Week 7.
- Seahawks Wire
Metcalf responded this morning, telling Sharpe to stop questioning him.
- NBC Sports Chicago
Candace Parker and the Sky celebrated their historic WNBA title with one of Chicago's favorite take-out spots
- Country Living
Fans Are Throwing Fire Emojis at Jessie James Decker After She Posted a Flirty Bikini Pic with Her Husband
Fans can't get enough of Jessie James Decker and husband Eric. Their latest flirty bikini pic on the beach is enough to dub them as "the cutest couple ever."
Everyone on Twitter is making the same joke about Scott Disick reacting to Kourtney Kardashian and Travis Barker's engagement—check out the funniest tweets.
- Women's Health
The 35-year-old songstress is back in Vegas, flaunting her killer legs and booty while performing. Pilates and bicycle crunches keep her looking fit and fly.
But it all worked out in the end when he was cast in another major movie from the same director.
- USA TODAY
Dying from COVID-19 is extremely uncommon for the fully vaccinated, but at 84 years old, Colin Powell fell into high-risk group.