“Dateline” Star Keith Morrison Opened Up About “Second-Guessing” Interviews, The Longest Cases He’s Covered, And His Rivalry With Josh Mankiewicz

’Tis the season, which for true crime folks means watching Dateline’s Keith Morrison read Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, How the Grinch Stole Christmas, and of course “The Night Before Christmas.” I managed to pull him away from his reporting (and reading) for a short Q&A about his challenging job and rivalry with correspondent Josh Mankiewicz (who makes a surprise appearance at the end).

Five years after two young girls were killed in Delphi, Indiana, police just arrested and charged a man with their murders. Tell me about the longest case you’ve covered.

Keith Morrison: Several cases have gone on for a long, long time. We’ve followed the story behind Murder & Magnolias, my newest podcast, for going on seven years, but that is by no means the longest. Several have been in production for over a decade. In one case a character in junior elementary school when we started was a college student when we conducted our last interview.

Is there an interview you wish you could do over or revisit?

KM: Wouldn’t we all love do-overs? I could use hundreds of those.

What do you do to unwind after a particularly distressing interview?

KM: The only way an interview is distressing is when I make a poor job of it. There’s no unwinding from the second-guessing.

Selfies abound with your fellow correspondent Josh Mankiewicz, but you generally manage to fly under the radar. Where’s the strangest place you’ve been recognized?

That time I was mowing Josh’s lawn.

Speaking of Mank, what would you get him as a white elephant present for the holidays?

KM: Photo album for his selfies.

I reached out to Josh himself to ask what gift he’d give Keith in return. His answer:

Josh Mankiewicz: I mean, the guy’s always whining how he’s out of Luminol.

For more behind-the-scenes scoops from Keith Morrison and the Dateline gang, check out “Everything You Wanted to Know About 'Dateline' But Were Afraid to Ask.” I wasn’t afraid to ask the tough questions!

More true crime

• Everything You Wanted To Know About "Dateline" But Were Afraid To AskDrusilla Moorhouse · July 7, 2017

• A Man Has Been Arrested More Than Five Years After The Delphi Murders Of Two GirlsDrusilla Moorhouse · Oct. 31, 2022

• “Dateline” Headlined CrimeCon And The Fans Went Wild. Here’s Why.Drusilla Moorhouse · May 18, 2018

• How Can People Fall Asleep To True Crime Shows And Podcasts?Drusilla Moorhouse · June 4, 2022