5 cheap dupes for high-end skincare products—according to dermatologists

Hannah Kramer

Yahoo Life is committed to finding you the best products at the best prices. We may receive a share from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change.

This unassuming jar rivals the bigwigs when it comes to dosing skin with hydrating hyaluronic acid. (Photo: Ulta)
This unassuming jar rivals the bigwigs when it comes to dosing skin with hydrating hyaluronic acid. (Photo: Ulta)

The magic words in skincare often seem to call for magic money. Hyaluronic acid, retinol, vitamin C—getting these goods requires you to shell out serious cash and give up something else, right? Well, yes and no. Yes if you go straight to the obvious brands—Tatcha, Sunday Riley or especially next-level companies like La Mer and Dr. Sturm—which call for sacrificing an arm and a leg as payment. But no if you’re strategic and know who to ask about options (and, not to brag, but we know who to ask.)

We went straight to the experts—top dermatologists—to find out what a normal person could do to get the best results from the most cutting edge ingredients and they sent us to...the drugstore. That’s right. These pros say there’s a batch of reasonably priced products that work just well as—or better than—the high-end brands that hog the limelight. We pressed for details, and here’s what we got: Five brilliantly affordable under-the-radar picks from doctors to bring the glow, save the cash and give you the satisfaction of beating the system.

Instead of splurging on SK-II R.N.A Power Radical New Age Cream ($235) or Chanel Hydra Beauty Cream ($87), try La Roche Cicaplast Baume ($15, at Amazon)

Hand-healing for hard times.  (Amazon)
Hand-healing for hard times. (Amazon)

Frequent hand washing during the times of coronavirus strips the skin of moisture, while the constant rubbing of masks against our faces exacerbates sensitive skin and contributes to breakouts from buildup of dirt and oil. It’s important to find a moisturizer that doesn’t clog pores yet at the same time soothes irritated skin, like this La Roche-Posay balm made with shea butter and glycerin.

“La Roche Cicaplast Baume B5 is a lifesaver especially in the time of COVID-19 where hand washing and face mask-wearing is really causing a lot of skin irritation for many,” says Dr. Kavita Mariwalla, founder of Mariwalla Dermatology. “This moisturizer truly heals the hands with its anti-inflammatory ingredients and the formulation does not leave the hands feeling oily or sticky.”

Instead of splurging on SkinCeuticals Hydrating B5 Gel ($80, was $84) or Shiseido Essential Energy Moisturizing Gel Cream ($48), try Neutrogena Hydroboost Water Gel ($25, from Ulta)

Plump up the volume. (Ulta)
Plump up the volume. (Ulta)

Hyaluronic acid is produced naturally by our skin to keep our skin plump and well-hydrated, but the amount we create naturally decreases exponentially as we age. Dermatologists recommend hyaluronic-focused products, like this best-selling Neutrogena moisturizer, to hydrate and replenish skin and in doing so, minimize fine lines and wrinkles.

“The Neutrogena Boost absorbs 1,000 times its weight, is noncomedogenic and can be used day and evening, at a fraction of the cost compared to other brands,” explains Dr. Patricia Wexler of Wexler Dermatology. “The function of hyaluronic acid is to provide retention of moisture for plump, hydrated, smooth and wrinkle-free skin. It is naturally found in your body and its function is to keep your retain water and keep your tissues well lubricated. This is not only a dupe [for SkinMedica Ha5], but there are unique chains of hyaluronic acid in multiple shapes and sizes which can help stimulate your skin to produce its own hyaluronic acid. Many times, more expensive brands are delivering hyaluronic acid, but more expensive due to branding, marketing and packaging.”

Echoes Spring Street Dermatology’s Dr. Sapna Palep: “It works just as well to hydrate the skin. The main ingredient is the hyaluronic acid. It’s in a water base instead of a clogging serum. So, it works well with our skin in a time like this when we are wearing masks and need a non-clogging moisturizer.”

Instead of shopping SkinCeuticals C E Ferulic serum ($250) or La Mer Brilliance Brightening Essence ($345), try Vichy Liftactiv Vitamin C ($21, was $28.50, from Amazon)

Vitamin C is having a serious moment. (Photo: Amazon)
Vitamin C is having a serious moment. (Photo: Amazon)

The powerhouse ingredient vitamin C can reduce inflammation, even out pigmentation and add a healthy glow, but most serums with an effective percentage cost a bundle.

That’s why Dr. Jennifer MacGregor of Union Square Laser Dermatology is a fan of Vichy Laboratories brightening serum; it’s a spectacular find for the price.

“It has the same potent 15 percent vitamin C as the more expensive and popular C E Ferulic by SkinCeuticals (which I also love), without the vitamin E and Ferulic acid,” she explains. “It’s rare, but some people develop an allergy to topical vitamin E. It’s still an ultra-potent, effective antioxidant, packaged correctly to maintain efficacy and comes in a smaller stock size that is convenient for travel or gym bags. This version of vitamin C is also combined with hydrating and plumping hyaluronic acid to smooth the skin surface and comes at less than half the price when adjusted for size.”

Instead of opting for Estée Lauder Perfectionist Pro Rapid Renewal Retinol Treatment ($72, was $85), try AcneFree's Adapalene Gel ($8, was $12, from Amazon)

Acne begone. (Amazon)
Acne begone. (Amazon)

Effective retinoids are often tricky to find, dermatologists explain, because brands frequently don’t make retinol strength clear to customers. While retinol is now available over-the-counter (it used to require a prescription), there are still plenty of brands that work just as well to help stimulate collagen production, reduce lines, pigmentation, dark spots and combat acne.

“People are sometimes scared of using retinoids because they think their skin will get too irritated or that they will be too sun sensitive. But there are many different formulations available, and some are much more tolerable than others,” Dr. Hadley King of Skinney MedSpa explains.

“Adapalene is a third-generation retinoid with proven efficacy and tolerability, for the treatment of acne, and is also effective for anti-aging,” continues Dr. King.“It has been studied in numerous clinical trials that have demonstrated high efficacy and lower risk of skin irritation. Adapalene also has an anti-inflammatory effect due to inhibition of lipoxygenase activity and also to the oxidative metabolism of arachidonic acid. These mechanisms may be the reason for decreased risk of irritation with adapalene. It's marketed for acne but works well for anti-aging too.”

Instead of Sunday Riley Good Genes All-in-One Lactic Acid Treatment ($85) get The Ordinary Lactic Acid 5% + HA 2% ($13, was $16, from Amazon)

Anything but ordinary.
Anything but ordinary.

Lactic acid has long been hailed as a gentle, dermatologist go-to for anti-aging and exfoliation. Because it’s less irritating than salicylic acid, it’s often recommended for patients with sensitive and dry skin, but it can also help those suffering from rosacea, superficial acne and hyperpigmentation.

“This is a great dupe,” says Dr. Howard Sobel, of Sobel Skin. “It will remove the layer of dead skin cells and reveal a radiant and youthful complexion. The ingredients are very straightforward, with the percentage of active ingredients right in the product name.” Dr. Sobel told us that the info is unclear with the pricier Sunday Riley treatment: “With Sunday Riley, the exact amount of active ingredients isn't as clear.” This is a fairly mild exfoliant, and it is also fragrance-free, making it a perfect option for all skin types. I would recommend using the product once a day to remove dirt and residue from the skin, followed by a moisturizer and sunscreen, like the Sobel Skin Rx Plant Stem Cell Day Cream + SPF 30, to protect freshly exfoliated skin from damaging UV rays and sunburn."

Read More from Yahoo Lifestyle:

Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest for nonstop inspiration delivered fresh to your feed, every day

Want daily pop culture news delivered to your inbox? Sign up here for Yahoo Entertainment & Lifestyle's newsletter.