'Embarrassing': How Indiana residents reacted to Mike Braun's interracial marriage comments
In a press call Tuesday, Sen. Mike Braun said the U.S. Supreme Court was incorrect in legalizing interracial marriage in a landmark case in 1967, and that the decision should have been left to the states.
Braun's comments came during an open-ended conference call with media, during which he discussed confirmation hearings for President Joe Biden's Supreme Court nominee, Ketanji Brown Jackson. That's when he began discussing what he called "judicial activism."
After Braun said he believed abortion rights should've been left up to the states in the 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling, Dan Carden, a reporter with the Times of Northwest Indiana, asked if he felt the same way about Loving v. Virginia, which struck down all state laws banning interracial marriage.
Read more: Mike Braun walks back comments that interracial marriage ruling should have been left to states
"When it comes to issues, you can't have it both ways," Braun said. "When you want that diversity to shine within our federal system, there are going to be rules and proceedings, they're going to be out of sync with maybe what other states would do. It's the beauty of the system, and that's where the differences among points of view in our 50 states ought to express themselves."
Just a few hours later, Braun attempted to walk back his comments, saying he "misunderstood the line of questioning."
"Let me be clear on that issue — there is no question the Constitution prohibits discrimination of any kind based on race, that is not something that is even up for debate, and I condemn racism in any form, at all levels and by any states, entities, or individuals,” he said in a written statement.
Here's how some Hoosiers — and non-Hoosiers — are responding:
Mike Schmuhl, chairman of the Indiana Democratic Party
Schmuhl, who is the chairman of the Indiana Democratic Party, released a written statement denouncing Braun's comments as "un-American" and "beneath any respectable person wishing to hold public office.
"The United States Supreme Court has affirmed many times that marriage equality in our country extends to any committed couple regardless of sex, race, orientation, or religious affiliation, and to question that legitimacy questions the very fabric of America and its people," Schmuhl said.
There’s no typo in that headline. @SenatorBraun believes #SCOTUS was wrong to legalize interracial marriage nationwide.
This rhetoric is un-American and once again demonstrates how dangerous the @indgop’s culture wars are for Indiana. #INSen https://t.co/MaHVao37ni— Indiana Democrats (@INDems) March 23, 2022
Schmuhl went on to say that the "culture wars" within the Indiana Republican party are "diminishing" the future of the U.S.
"Democrats implore all Hoosiers to ask themselves if they want to be associated with someone as embarrassing as Mike Braun and a form of partisanship that endorses white nationalist views — because these are the same views that led to the insurrection against our nation on January 6, 2021," he said. "If Mike Braun wants to question the legitimacy of anything, it should be his own standing as a United States Senator. He cheated his way into office and consistently shows that he does not represent us.”
Kyle Hupfer, chairman of Indiana Republican Party
In an emailed statement, Hupfer referred IndyStar to Braun's follow-up statement . However, he also said he believed some rights are so "intrinsic" that they cannot be left up to states, and one of those is ensuring "racial equality."
"As for my thoughts on the issue at hand, I believe there are some rights that are so intrinsic to us as humans and Americans that the states cannot be left to decide those issues on their own," Hupfer said. "That includes ensuring racial equality in all aspects of life."
The Indiana Republican Party during my tenure has created a first in the nation Republican Diversity Leadership Series. We will continue to be a party that seeks to grow and unite and not divide.”
Hammond Mayor Thomas McDermott
McDermott is a Democrat running for U.S. Senate against Sen. Todd Young.
In a tweet, McDermott called the senator's comments "appalling" and urged Young to join him in denouncing "views that should be left in our nation's past."
It is appalling that a US Senator from IN claims that the US Supreme Ct shouldn’t decide the right of people to marry inter-racially. I condemn @SenatorBraun ‘s comments and I urge @SenToddYoung to join me in condemning views that should be left behind in our nation's past.
— McDermott for Indiana (@gomcdermott) March 22, 2022
The modern day GOP has become a disgrace.
Comments like these, from a sitting US Senator, were wrong in the 1950’s, and are appalling in the year 2022.
It’s up to us #Hoosiers to take care of business and drive backwards thinking politicians out of Washington DC. https://t.co/JlPO08jFAU— Thomas McDermott (@tommcdermottjr) March 22, 2022
Victoria Garcia Wilburn, candidate for Indiana House
Garcia Wilburn is a Democrat running for Indiana House District 32 and an assistant professor at IUPUI.
She shared a photo of her and her husband, saying that "this picture should not be offensive to any elected official in or from Indiana." Garcia Wilburn is Latina, and her husband is Black.
This picture should not be offensive to any elected official in or from Indiana.
WE are Indiana, WE belong in Indiana. https://t.co/87ei3hYfc8 pic.twitter.com/Agjqoo240h— Victoria Garcia Wilburn for Indiana House (@wilburn4IN) March 22, 2022
Andrea Hunley, candidate for Indiana Senate
Hunley is a Democrat running for the Senate in Indiana's 46th district. She quote-tweeted Wilburn Garcia's tweet with a photo of her own family.
Hunley also shared a photo of her with her parents and siblings in the 1980s, calling the photo "a portrait of interracial marriage and adoption."
We are Indiana, We belong in Indiana.
Agreed, @wilburn4IN #loving https://t.co/NYcbIVOpdY pic.twitter.com/ocjyw5PjaI— Andrea Hunley for SD46 (@AndreaHunley_IN) March 23, 2022
Bonus pic of young Andrea with my mom and dad and siblings. Fort Wayne, IN 1980s. A portrait of interracial marriage and adoption. pic.twitter.com/gFk6uMH35P
— Andrea Hunley for SD46 (@AndreaHunley_IN) March 23, 2022
Ashley C. Ford, bestselling author and Indianapolis resident
Ford is the author of "Somebody's Daughter," a bestselling memoir. She's a Fort Wayne native and Ball State University alumna.
Her tweet asked how someone could "'accidentally' say legalizing interracial marriage was a mistake?"
How do you “accidentally” say legalizing interracial marriage was a mistake? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
— Ashley C. Ford (@iSmashFizzle) March 23, 2022
Ford tweeted in support of Hunley, saying Braun needed to be voted out of office.
I can’t run for office because I can’t mentally endure being constantly questioned by dummies, but Mike Braun gotta go. Really they all gotta go. In the meantime, vote for @AndreaHunley_IN.
— Ashley C. Ford (@iSmashFizzle) March 23, 2022
John Green, bestselling author and Indianapolis resident
Green, who lives in and writes about Indianapolis, is the author of multiple bestselling books, including "The Fault in our Stars" and, most recently, "The Anthropocene Reviewed."
Green's tweet called Braun a "disaster" for Indiana and the United States as a whole. He encouraged Hoosiers to vote Braun out of office.
Mike Braun is a disaster for Indiana and for the U.S. I would say this is "unbelievable," but it's actually totally in keeping with his entire political career. Vote him out, Hoosiers! https://t.co/VUFlENBWKC
— John Green (@johngreen) March 23, 2022
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY)
Ocasio-Cortez, a Democratic congresswoman, quote tweeted a video from Heartland Signal of Braun's comments and encouraged reporters to "not pretend it's normal" for Braun to say that the Supreme Court should not have legalized interracial marriage.
She then said Braun's subsequent attempt to go back on his remarks was not sufficient, saying he needed to go on the record in favor of the Loving case.
Can journalists please not pretend it’s normal for a US Senator to declare that the Supreme Court was wrong to legalize interracial marriage, he’s OK w/it being illegal again, his “new” statement not walking anything back during a SCOTUS nomination that he’d be voting on? Thanks. https://t.co/HOoaEEyuWK
— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) March 22, 2022
Senator Braun’s statement does not walk back what he said.
He needs to go on the record to clarify whether he believes states should be allowed to reinstate anti-miscegenation laws, and whether it’s his belief SCOTUS should overturn Loving v. Virginia as he does w/ Roe v. Wade— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) March 22, 2022
Rep. Gerry Connolly (D-VA)
Connolly, a Democratic congressman, also quote tweeted a video of Braun's comment, referencing other landmark cases which have encountered Republican opposition: Roe v. Wade and Obergefell v. Hodges.
"If they gain power, there's no telling which constitutional right will be on the chopping block next," he wrote.
They fought Obergefell v. Hodges with all their might.
They’re still coming after Roe v. Wade
And now, apparently, Republicans have a new target in Loving v. Virginia.
If they gain power, there’s no telling which constitutional right will be on the chopping block next. https://t.co/uhX75evvMq— Rep. Gerry Connolly (@GerryConnolly) March 23, 2022
IndyStar reporter Kaitlin Lange contributed to this report.
Contact IndyStar trending reporter Claire Rafford at crafford@gannett.com or on Twitter @clairerafford.
This article originally appeared on Indianapolis Star: How Indiana reacted to Mike Braun's comments on interracial marriage