Experts: ‘Special interest alien’ designation is based largely on person's country of origin

Illegal immigration is a frequent focus on Laura Ingraham’s Fox News show "The Ingraham Angle," and one of the show’s contributors recently offered data that he claimed showed the safety risks behind it.

"People underestimate the danger of this, Laura," Raymond Arroyo said Sept. 6. He claimed that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement "just arrested" more than 300 migrants with criminal records "and 75,000 illegals have now been named national security threats by Border Patrol."

We wondered about Arroyo’s source for the number of people deemed national security threats, so PolitiFact reached out to Fox News. A spokesperson there said Arroyo’s claim was based on an article published in the Daily Caller, a right-wing online publication.

"Customs and Border Protection (CBP) flagged 74,904 illegal migrants nationwide for potentially posing risks to national security between October 2022 and August, according to CBP data obtained exclusively by the Daily Caller News Foundation," according to a quote the spokesperson pulled from the report.

The bulk of the article then focused on "special interest aliens." It cited a 2019 Department of Homeland Security fact sheet that defined a special interest alien as "a non-U.S. person who, based on an analysis of travel patterns, potentially poses a national security risk to the United States or its interests."

The Daily Caller article also said Border Patrol agents "encountered 25,627 'special interest' illegal migrants" in fiscal year 2022 and 3,675 in fiscal year 2021; its source is "internal agency data previously obtained by the DCNF."

We asked CBP about the Daily Caller’s numbers but did not hear back. We also did not find publicly available data on the number of "special interest aliens." Experts told us government agencies have used that term differently, too, muddying the issue.

Here’s what we found:

What have federal officials said about the 'special interest alien' designation?

Across federal agencies, there is no universally accepted definition for "special interest alien," and immigration experts say the definition has changed over time.

The 2019 DHS fact sheet cited in the article published by the Daily Caller said that not all special interest aliens are terrorists, but that their travel and behavior "indicates a possible nexus to nefarious activity (including terrorism) and, at a minimum, provides indicators that necessitate heightened screening and further investigation."

DHS also said a special interest alien designation "does not indicate any specific derogatory information about the individual" and that it’s different from the "known and suspected terrorist" designation.

DHS says a "known terrorist" is a person who has been arrested, charged or convicted for crimes related to terrorism or someone who has been identified as a terrorist or member of a terrorist organization.

Meanwhile, a "suspected terrorist," according to DHS, is a person "reasonably suspected" of having engaged in, being engaged in or intending to engage in terrorist activity.

During a 2016 House hearing about potential terrorist threats, then-Rep. Albio Sires, D-N.J., asked government officials: "Can you define for me or discuss how the U.S. government defines special interest aliens? How do you do that?"

Alan D. Bersin, DHS’ assistant secretary for international affairs and chief diplomatic officer, said the definition varies by agency. "They tend to be either a listing of countries. I have seen listings up to 35 countries. Other agencies take up a more restricted terrorist-related or a terrorist-centric view of the definition."

Lev Kubiak, assistant director for international operations at Immigration and Customs Enforcement, said his agency was "trying to get away" from using the special interest alien classification because it lacks a standard definition.

What do immigration experts say about the designation?

Experts said the classification is primarily about a person’s country of origin, and is not based on an individualized assessment of a person’s history or network of friends and family, for example.

"The definition of which countries make a person a special interest alien changes constantly," said David Bier, the libertarian Cato Institute’s associate director of immigration studies.

In 2016, the list of "special interest countries" was about 35 long, including countries deemed state sponsors of terrorism — at the time, Iran, Syria and Sudan — and countries such as Afghanistan, Somalia, Bangladesh, Egypt, Iraq and Pakistan, The Texas Tribune reported.

In October 2018, the Trump White House referred to a list of 22 countries as "‘special interest aliens’ countries."

The recent increase in the number of migrants arriving "from outside the Western Hemisphere" might be boosting the number of people deemed special interest aliens, said Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, policy director at the American Immigration Council, an immigrants' rights advocacy group.

"We’ve even seen hundreds of Afghan nationals fleeing the Taliban come to the United States to seek asylum," Reichlin-Melnick said. Based on what is known about the United States’ lists of special interest countries, it is likely that those immigrants from Afghanistan and thousands of immigrants from Bangladesh who have recently come to the United States "would be considered special interest aliens," he said.

Reichlin-Melnick said it’s important for people to understand that the designation doesn’t mean a person is a national security threat.

"It just generally means that they come from a country that the U.S. is concerned with, not that they themselves represent a threat," he said.

There's no evidence a person apprehended by Border Patrol who was designated a "special interest alien" has ever committed an attack on U.S. soil, according to Sept. 14 testimony from the Cato Institute’s vice president for economic and social policy studies, Alex Nowrasteh.

This article originally appeared on Austin American-Statesman: ‘Special interest alien’ label is based largely on country of origin