Fact check: No, Joe Biden did not put a gun in a woman’s mouth in Wisconsin
The claim: Joe Biden stuck a gun in a woman's mouth in Wisconsin
A manipulated photo that dates back more than a decade is finding new life amid the effort of many Americans to stay at home and engage in social distancing during the coronavirus pandemic.
An image of Democratic presidential frontrunner and former Vice President Joe Biden shared more than 2,000 times on Facebook purports to show Biden sticking a gun in an elderly woman’s mouth. The accompanying text claims it happened at a 2019 rally in Wisconsin.
Here’s the text of the post:
JOE BIDEN WANTS THIS PICTURE OFF THE INTERNET BUT WE NEED TO KEEP SHARING IT
MAGA
KAGA
Story: In 2019, Joe Biden was confronted by 63 year old Melinda Bares at a rally in Wisconsin. Bares claimed Biden was trying to take guns from law abiding citizens, to which Biden claimed “guns are just as dangerous as poison and knives, and I will prove it!” He then held a gun to Bares, and said she is even more scared than normal.
It was posted March 23, 2020, but began circulating heavily in early April. The comments showed many Facebook users taking it seriously, calling Biden “evil” and asserting this as further reason to support Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., who remains in the Democratic nomination race along with Biden.
But the image is fabricated.
Here’s the background.
Picture dates back more than a decade
The “story” accompanying the photo is pure fiction. Biden didn’t even attend any public events in Wisconsin in 2019, according to records maintained by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.
The original picture is from a Sept. 2, 2008, rally in Deerfield Beach, Fla. It was taken by an Associated Press photographer and published in an online Washington Post story that same day.
The woman was 87, not 63, when the photo was taken and her name is Annalou Trebitz, according to the original caption. There are other clues to the age of the photo, like the “Seniors for Obama” sticker on Trebitz’s jacket.
The picture — with the gun digitally inserted into the scene — has been circulating online since at least May 2012, according to Snopes, which fact-checked the picture (rating it "False") in January 2017.
Our ruling: False
We rate this picture and accompanying text FALSE because it is not supported by our research. The picture is actually an altered photo from a 2008 event in Florida, with the gun digitally added. It’s been circulating online for at least eight years. Biden wasn’t even in Wisconsin in 2019.
Our fact-check sources:
The Washington Post, Joe Biden, Yiddishe Veep, Sept. 2, 2008
Snopes, Does a Photograph Show Joe Biden Putting a Gun in a Woman’s Mouth?, Jan. 20, 2017
Contact Eric Litke at (414) 225-5061 or elitke@jrn.com. Follow him on Twitter at @ericlitke.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Fact check: No, Biden did not put a gun in a woman’s mouth in Wisc.
