By Kate Kelland Nutrition and health specialists criticized a study on Monday which argued that dietary fat advice given in the United States and Britain was based on flimsy evidence and should not have been introduced. The study, published in the Open Heart journal, said national advice on fat consumption issued to millions of Britons and Americans in 1977 and 1983 with the aim of reducing heart disease "lacked any solid trial evidence to back it up". But in the latest chapter of a long-running row about whether fat is the true culprit in the global obesity epidemic, independent experts said the research was flawed and failed "to take into account the totality of the evidence". Both the British and U.S. dietary guidelines recommended reducing overall dietary fat consumption to 30 percent of total intake and limiting saturated fat to around 10 percent -- advice that has remained broadly the same since the 1970s and 1980s. Zoe Harcombe of the University of the West of Scotland and James DiNicolantonio of the Saint Luke's Mid America Heart Institute, who co-led Monday's study in the Open Heart journal, said their research -- a meta-analysis of the randomized controlled trials available at the time -- suggested the guidelines were inconsistent with the evidence. "The available [trials] did not support the introduction of dietary fat recommendations in order to reduce [coronary heart disease] risk or related mortality," they wrote, adding that it seemed "incomprehensible" that dietary advice was given to millions of Americans and Britons given the "contrary results". Health experts looking for clues to persistently rising obesity rates around the world have recently begun to question whether fat is the main, or only, villain, and many are turning a spotlight on sugars and other carbohydrates instead. Yet several independent experts asked to review Harcombe's and DiNicolantonio's work criticized the study's approach and advised extreme caution in concluding the guidelines were wrong. "The claim that guidelines on dietary fat introduced in the 1970s and 80s were not based on good scientific evidence is misguided and potentially dangerous," said Christine Williams, a professor of human nutrition at Britain's Reading University. Nita Forouhi, a nutritional epidemiology specialist and public health consultant at Britain's Cambridge University said the Open Heart study's attempt to apply a "retroscope" to the trial-based evidence of the time was "unhelpful for several reasons, including methodological limitations and interpretation". "As such, the current dietary guidelines on fat intake should not be influenced by this study," she said. (Editing by Robin Pomeroy)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
- NBC Sports BayArea
Steph Curry was having a fine game against the Clippers heading into the fourth quarter. Then a technical foul was called, and his spark was lit.
- The Oklahoman
Taking a look at five candidates to replace Oklahoma head coach Lincoln Riley.
- Men's Health
Pulmonary medicine and critical care specialist Dr. Mike Hansen explains what you need to know about the new Covid-19 strain known as the Omicron variant.
- Madame Noire
Venus And Serena’s Half-Sister Slams ‘King Richard’ Biopic: ‘Those Girls Rose To The Top While His Children Had To Suffer’
Sabrina Williams's late mother, Betty Johnson, was married to the former tennis coach in the early sixties. The couple had four children together shortly before Williams allegedly walked out on his family according to the Wimbledon champs estranged sister.
- NBC Sports BayArea
After a bad start, Jimmy Garoppolo responds to a fiery conversation with Kyle Shanahan
- USA TODAY
Two-year-old Emma Sweet was found three miles downstream from where her father had been found by duck hunters on Friday.
- The Columbus Dispatch
Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh added some trash talk of his own following the Wolverines' upset of Ohio State.
FYI: You're probably doing a few things wrong when getting a shampoo.View Entire Post ›
- The Daily Advertiser
LSU offensive line coach Brad Davis will coach the Tigers in the bowl game.
"Congrats guys!" Charli XCX wrote on Instagram, sharing an outtake of her wardrobe malfunction at the ARIA Music Awards, in which she suffered a nip slip while presenting an award to Justin Bieber
- Ducks Wire
How should Duck fans feel about USC hiring Lincoln Riley? It's great for the Pac-12 as a whole, but bad for the talent gap Oregon has enjoyed recently.
- College Football News
Bowl Projections and College Football Playoff Picks: Week 13. They're the last big bowl projections before it all comes out next Sunday.
Who doesn’t love baby bump photos? Some are silly, some are majestic ala Beyonce and Halsey — and some give us a rare glimpse into how some private celebrities are handling their pregnancies. This time, famously private A-lister Christina Ricci gave us a glimpse into her life with a rare bare baby bump selfie. Motherhood […]
- Lebron Wire
A new trade proposal has the Los Angeles Lakers acquiring this forward from the Oklahoma City Thunder.
- Belleville News-Democrat
How does your southwestern Illinois community compare to others?
- Niners Wire
The #49ers won a shootout over the Minnesota Vikings. Our observations from each quarter of San Francisco's third-consecutive victory.
- Patriots Wire
This quote is absolutely perfect, Bill.
- Footwear News
Trump wore a lacy blouse to celebrate Thanksgiving with mom Marla Maples.
- Vols Wire
How Lincoln Riley at USC impacts Josh Heupel and Oklahoma's head coaching search.
- NBC Sports
Lionel Messi assisted two from Marquinhos sandwiched around his set-up of Angel Di Maria as PSG overcame a 1-0 deficit but lost Neymar to an ugly injury.