By Bill Cotterell TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (Reuters) - An appeal before the Florida Supreme Court on Tuesday could shift the burden of proof for the state’s "stand your ground" law, relieving gun owners of a legal duty to prove self-defense when they brandish weapons in violent confrontations. If the high court sides with Jared Bretherick, charged with aggravated assault for pointing a pistol at a man in a road-rage incident, the burden of proof would be shifted to prosecutors to show that a defendant claiming the law's protection did not act in self-defense. The 2005 law allows citizens to use deadly force when they reasonably perceive that their lives or the lives of others are in danger. Bretherick was riding with his family on Dec. 29, 2011, when a passing vehicle driven by Derek Dunning nearly sideswiped their SUV near Orlando, court records show. The Indiana family said Dunning cut them off and stopped his own SUV in front of them, jumping out, and that driver Ronald Bretherick, Jared's father, called 911 and showed his holstered gun to warn the man away. The Brethericks said Dunning returned to his vehicle and backed it up toward them. Jared Bretherick then took his father’s gun and stood beside their vehicle, where deputies found him pointing the gun at Dunning’s SUV. No shots were fired. Jared Bretherick said he heard Dunning say he had a gun, although none was found. A judge denied Bretherick “stand your ground” immunity at a hearing in June 2012.Faced with a mandatory three-year sentence if convicted, Bretherick appealed and a district appellate court asked the state Supreme Court to decide the proof issue. “If Derek Dunning had put his hands on that car door and attempted entry, this case wouldn’t be here,” Bretherick's attorney, Eric Friday, told the court in opening statements. State assistant attorney general Kristen Davenport said defendants should no be shielded from trial by “stand your ground” immunity when the circumstances are disputed. “The defendant is certainly entitled to make this argument to the jury,” she said. “Maybe they’ll believe his version of events. The trial judge didn’t.” The National Rifle Association has filed a brief supporting Bretherick. It also backed the state's “stand your ground” law, which has drawn nationwide attention. A new Florida law permits gun owners to display their weapons, or even fire warning shots, if they fear death or injury. (Editing by Letitia Stein, Mohammad Zargham and Bill Trott)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
Lawyer for Brian Laundrie's family addresses speculation about how easily his dad found his belongings, saying the public 'doesn't understand simplicity'
Brian Laundrie's parents could not have planted his remains or had special knowledge about where they were, the family lawyer said.
- CBS News
The discovery came after a weeks-long manhunt following the death of Gabby Petito.
- The Daily Beast
YouTube/ABCA family of three found dead on a Northern California hiking trail in August died of heat exposure and possible dehydration, the local sheriff’s office revealed Thursday.“Heat-related deaths are extremely difficult to investigate,” Mariposa County Sheriff Jeremy Briese said at a press conference, citing an official cause of death of “hyperthermia and probably dehydration.”The bodies of John Gerrish, Ellen Chung, and their 1-year-old daughter Muji were found mid-August on the Savage Lu
- The Daily Beast
Vanderburgh County Sheriff's OfficeA 36-year-old Indiana woman is behind bars after police discovered two people tied up and shackled in her home—one of them “deceased and beyond help.”The woman, identified by Evansville authorities as Heidi Carter, faces a string of charges in connection with the Tuesday night incident, which police say took even them by surprise.It all began after a woman flagged down an Indiana state trooper late Tuesday night, saying she’d stopped by Carter’s home only to fi
- The Wrap
Long story short, guns are very, very dangerous, regardless of the ammo
The actor fired a prop weapon that killed a crew member and injured the director on the set of his film "Rust."
- Business Insider
'I've lost my joy': Anti-vax Republican, who worked for the Trump campaign and embraced QAnon, says she has COVID-19
Lauren Witzke, the 2020 GOP candidate for US Senate in Delaware, told followers she had "lost all of my senses."
- Atlanta Black Star
A 4-foot-8 Black Woman Was Accosted By Group of Boys, Minutes Later a Louisiana Deputy Was Flinging Her By Her Hair In Shocking Video; Investigation Launched
An investigation has been launched in a New Orleans suburb after a video captured a Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office deputy flinging a 4-foot-8 Black woman […]
Photo shows Alec Baldwin in tears outside sheriff's office after the prop-firearm shooting that left 'Rust' cinematographer dead
One person died after Baldwin fired a prop gun on the set of "Rust" in New Mexico, the Santa Fe County Sheriff's Office said Thursday.
At least 4 other bodies were found during the almost 2-month search for Gabby Petito and Brian Laundrie
Authorities looking for the couple in Alabama, Wyoming, North Carolina, and Colorado have inadvertently discovered other remains.
"Things started to go south for me was when I hit, I think it was 25."View Entire Post ›
- Women's Health
Emma Watson wore a crop top that revealed her bra and her toned abs to meet Al Gore. The actress works out with celeb trainer Emily Drew for 30-minute sessions.
- NBC Sports Boston
Newly signed Celtics guard Brodric Thomas is going to wear a number no NBA player has ever used before.
- Atlanta Black Star
‘Sunny Is Just As Smart’: Condoleezza Rice’s ‘Brazenly Condescending’ Back and Forth with ‘The View’ Co-Host Sunny Hostin Called Out by Viewers
Sunny Hostin and former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice have different views regarding the Capitol riots that took place on Jan. 6. Those disagreements came […]
- USA TODAY
A video of a man who served in the U.S. Marine Corps shutting down a would-be armed robbery went viral this week.
Prince William & Kate Middleton's Rare PDA Photos Give Us An Intimate Look At The Future of the Monarchy
With every new glimpse we get, it seems like the future of the royal family is looking pretty bright, especially with Prince William and Kate Middleton at the helm. When it comes to their duties as senior members of the House of Windsor, the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge have been stepping it up — […]
- USA TODAY
A series of potent storms is poised to deliver torrents of rain and feet of snow across California and the West over the next few days.
- In The Know by Yahoo
Mom 'terrified' after spotting suspicious figure in baby monitor footage: 'Search every inch of your house'
She said she had a strange feeling that prompted her to go get her baby.
- ProFootball Talk on NBC Sports
The Browns are favorites against the Broncos in tonight’s Thursday Night Football game, but the line has moved toward Denver, particularly after Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield was ruled out with a shoulder injury. Which makes one big bet particularly eye-opening. Caesars Sportsbook reported a $500,000 bet on the Broncos +4, according to David Purdum of [more]
- The Wrap
The actress died May 7 in Newport Beach, CA