Former Marathon County town officials charged with using town funds to pay fine for past conviction

WAUSAU − A Marathon County couple, both of whom are former town officials, are facing felony charges connected to paying a court fine.

Mary Beth Gebert, 67, and Michael J. Gebert, 63, both of the town of Bergen, each are charged with misconduct in office. Mary Gebert's charge is as a party to the crime and contains a repeat offender charging enhancer.

Mary Gebert previously pleaded guilty to being an election official who destroyed a poll list. According to the complaint, Mary Gebert and two other poll workers couldn't make the numbers balance correctly on election night on Nov. 3, 2020, and chose a random name and signed the person's name in a poll book. Marathon County Circuit Judge Suzanne O'Neill withheld a sentence during Mary Gebert's plea hearing Dec. 6 and placed her on two years of probation. O'Neill also ordered her to pay $1,788.

According to the criminal complaint filed Monday, a check was written on a town of Bergen account on Feb. 13 to the Department of Corrections for $1,788.

On May 12, Bergen Chairman Edwin Rucinski talked to a Marathon County deputy about finding the Feb. 13 check during the course of his duties, according to the complaint. The check was signed by Michael Gebert, who was the previous town chairman, a town supervisor and the town treasurer.

The deputy talked to the supervisor whose signature was on the check. He said he did not typically sign checks for the town, but was given the responsibility of signing them the last few months of his term after Mary Gebert was convicted. The supervisor said he did not remember signing the $1,788 check. He said the town chairman and treasurer would have the checks ready for him at the town hall and he'd sign them, asking any questions he had about a particular check, but he couldn't remember the check written to the Department of Corrections.

More: Wausau police arrest three after shots fired near Marathon Park

More: Check out Tork Mason's favorite photos of September 2023 in central Wisconsin and some Packers too

Michael Gebert told the deputy the town's insurance company paid for his wife's legal expenses related to the first case filed against her. When the deputy asked about the check, Michael Gebert said he should talk to Mary Gebert, according to the complaint.

Mary Gebert said state statutes indicate the town pays for her responsibilities while she was clerk. She said the town attorney said the town would pay her fines and court costs, according to the complaint. Mary Gebert at first said she prepared the check, but she later said it was the treasurer who did it.

Michael Gebert said he had to get approval of the checks from the Town Board, according to the complaint.

The deputy spoke with the town's attorney, and he said it was the first time he had heard of a town using funds to pay post-conviction fees. He said he did not believe the town should have paid the court fees because Mary Gebert had been found guilty of a crime. The attorney said he would not have advised the town to use town money to pay Mary Gebert's court costs.

Michael Gebert told the deputy he had told the board the check was for the Department of Corrections, and they were OK with it, according to the complaint. He said he used the town money to pay the court fees because Mary Gebert was an elected town official. The deputy showed Michael Gebert an invoice listing checks the Town Board approved in February and the check was not listed, according to the complaint.

The deputy talked with a member of the town's insurance company, and he said the company did not make any payments to the Department of Corrections between March 18, 2022, and April 14, 2023, in the amount of $1,788, according to the complaint. He said it is not common for an insurance company to pay for post-conviction fees.

Michael and Mary Gebert are scheduled to make their initial appearances on the charges Oct. 12. If convicted, they each face a maximum sentence of 3 ⅟₂ years.

Contact Karen Madden at 715-345-2245 or kmadden@gannett.com. Follow her on Twitter @KMadden715, Instagram @kmadden715 or Facebook at www.facebook.com/karen.madden.33.

SUPPORT LOCAL JOURNALISM: Our subscribers make this coverage possible. Click to see the Wausau Daily Herald's special offers at wausaudailyherald.com/subscribe and download our app on the App Store or Google Play.

This article originally appeared on Wisconsin Rapids Daily Tribune: Former Marathon County town of Bergen officials facing felony charges