By Jonathan Stempel NEW YORK (Reuters) - General Motors Co and its law firm need not turn over privileged documents to drivers hoping to show that the automaker intended to commit a crime or fraud by concealing defective ignition switches in their vehicles, a Manhattan federal judge ruled on Wednesday. Despite finding "probable cause" to believe GM committed a crime or fraud by hiding the defect from regulators and the public, U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman found no showing that the automaker and King & Spalding produced the documents with an intent to further such misconduct. Most of the documents related to the law firm's advice from 2010 to 2013 on three crashes involving Chevrolet Cobalts. Vehicle owners said the deception justified a waiver of attorney-client privilege. "Put simply, plaintiffs do not provide a factual basis for a good faith belief that the communications and work product they seek - let alone any particular communications or work product they seek - were made with the intent to further a crime or fraud," Furman wrote. The judge added that the vehicle owners already had many of the documents in hand, and that King & Spalding's work had "all the hallmarks of dispassionate, sober evaluations (perhaps, in hindsight, too dispassionate and sober for their own good)." Wednesday's decision is a victory for GM as it prepares for a Jan. 11, 2016, bellwether trial over an ignition switch defect that could cause engines to stall and prevent airbags from deploying in crashes. The defect on Cobalts, Saturn Ions and other vehicles has been linked to at least 124 deaths. GM in February 2014 began recalling 2.6 million vehicles to fix the defect, despite having awareness of a possible problem a decade earlier. Two months ago, GM agreed to pay $900 million and enter a deferred prosecution agreement to end a related U.S. criminal probe. Furman cited that accord when discussing probable cause. "We're pleased with the court's ruling," GM spokesman James Cain said. "The company did not conspire with King & Spalding to further any crime or fraud." Bob Hilliard, a lawyer for vehicle owners, said attorney-client privilege is "difficult to overcome," and that jurors in the upcoming trial "will determine what level of financial punishment should be assessed against this company." King & Spalding spokeswoman Micheline Tang said Furman's decision shows that the firm's lawyers "did exactly what one would expect ethical and diligent litigators to do." Furman oversees more than 200 lawsuits over the ignition switches. The case is In re: General Motors LLC Ignition Switch Litigation, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 14-md-02543. (Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Additional reporting by Joseph White in Detroit and Jessica Dye in New York; Editing by David Gregorio and Steve Orlofsky)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
- Business Insider
America isn't running out of everything just because of a supply-chain crisis. America is running out of everything because Americans are buying so much stuff.
Claims that the US is running short on everything miss a key point. Record imports are part of the reason for the epic supply-chain congestion.
The White House press secretary asked the Fox News reporter a question he couldn't answer.
The Sarasota County Medical Examiner's Office was called on Wednesday morning to the Myakkahatchee Creek Environmental Park where the search for Laundrie was under way, a spokesperson for the office said. The spokesperson declined to comment on the reported human remains found in the park.
The articles were discovered during a search of Myakkahatchee Creek Environmental Park in North Port, Florida. Laundrie is the only person of interest in Gabby Petito's death.
'Too Hot to Handle' star Harry Jowsey says he knew he got busted receiving oral sex as it was happening because he saw 'like 65 cameras' swerve on him to film it
Jowsey said there were "like 65 cameras" in his room on the show, including some right above his bed, in order to catch contestants in the act.
- NBC Sports Boston
Umpires are going to get calls wrong, but 21 of them? In an ALCS game? The Red Sox' issues with balls and strikes last night were legitimate, and this graphic proves it.
- Washington Examiner
A news station in Washington state has exposed itself to possible fines after broadcasting a short clip of pornography during its evening news broadcast.
Being the middle child, even in the royal family, might seem like a drag from time to time. But it seems like Princess Charlotte is doing pretty well for herself. The 6-year-old daughter of Prince William and Kate Middleton has already reached quite a few milestones this year, and she’s reportedly poised to be named […]
- Women's Health
Fiona Apple Quit Cocaine After An 'Excruciating' Night With Quentin Tarantino And Paul Thomas Anderson
Fiona Apple says she quit doing cocaine after an excruciating night with Quentin Tarantino and Paul Thomas Anderson.
Angelina Jolie plays Thena — a warrior with immense strength, speed and stamina — in Eternals
- USA TODAY
A British wildlife hospital received a call from a local stonemasonry firm about a long, spotted snake they found in a shipping container from India.
- E! News
After the birth of her son Rennie, Katharine McPhee feels appreciation for her body. In an exclusive interview with E! News, the new mom got candid about shifting away from her old habits.
- Good Housekeeping
'Live! With Kelly and Ryan' fans could not get over Kelly Ripa's amazing on-air dress, which the show posted about on Instagram.
The NBA legend praised the Brooklyn Nets for benching Irving and slammed comparisons with boxing legend Muhammad Ali.
- Rolling Stone
The former president is jealous of how the media is covering the late Republican's death
- Entertainment Weekly
Nia DaCosta has some strong opinions on who's responsible for Thanos' snap in Infinity War.
Items belonging to Brian Laundrie found off a trail at a Florida park after his parents join the search
Laundrie's possessions were found near a trail that he often visited during a search on Wednesday, according to the family's lawyer.
- In The Know by Yahoo
No one was on this mother's side on the matter.
- Women's Health
TikTok star Addison Rae, 21, turned heads in a cutout dress that shows off her sculpted core. She swears by Pilates and her favorite booty workout to stay fit.
- Footwear News
Serena Williams Enjoys Date Night in Striped Mini Dress & Versatile Suede Thigh-High Boots With Alexis Ohanian
The tennis pro and her husband dressed up for a night out.