Bond investor Gundlach denounces MMT as 'pretzel logic on steroids'

Julia La Roche
Correspondent

Top bond investor Jeffrey Gundlach, the CEO of $150 billion DoubleLine Capital, slammed Modern Monetary Theory (MMT), a hot topic as federal deficit spending climbs with no end in sight.

The trendy economic theory is centered around the idea that the federal government can effectively print money without regard for balancing spending and taxes, and has been embraced by populist politicians like U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY).

Yet in a Yahoo Finance interview, Gundlach dismissed MMT as "ridiculous," "highly illogical," and "pretzel logic on steroids." Calling out its “false appeal,” the billionaire hit out at the idea of politicians who think the government can print money ad infinitem.

"It just says, 'Hey, if you're borrowing your own currency, you can just have infinite amounts of money,” Gundlach said in a recent wide-ranging conversation with Yahoo Finance.

"Basically, what they're doing is they're saying, 'As long as the interest rate is below the growth of the economy, then everything's fine. And, so it's OK to have basically tons of debt as long as the economic growth is there, and so on,'" the billionaire explained.

Gundlach isn’t the only one speaking out against MMT. Fellow billionaire investor Paul Tudor Jones has also criticized the theory, as have mainstream Democrats like former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers — who in a recent Washington Post Op-Ed called it “a recipe for disaster.”

‘It makes your brain hurt’

Gundlach, who has sounded the alarm on the debt bomb America is sitting on, pointed out that the idea behind MMT is flawed.

The idea that the government can borrow infinite amounts of money because gross domestic product (GDP) has been growing is "meaningless" — because no one knows what economic growth will look like in the future, he explained.

“When you issue all the bonds for 10 or 30 years, that's a fixed interest rate. So the fact that interest rate is lower than the growth of the economy — that sounds pretty good — but what happens if the growth of the economy turns negative?” he asked.

“Well, then MMT gets blown out of the water” once growth falters, he added.

Gundlach admitted to watching videos of folks who are big proponents of MMT, and he can see how people get sucked into the idea.

"[It] just makes your brain hurt to watch these videos, because they use these bizarre analogies that actually the government is not borrowing money, they're investing in the economy, is kind of the way they try to turn it,” the billionaire told Yahoo Finance.

“And when you watch it, you can actually get kind of sucked into the logic. And then you kind of suddenly get a big — a cold bucket of water drops on your head,” he added.

“And you go like, 'This is just pretzel logic taken to — pretzel logic on steroids really.' So MMT is just completely nonsensical,” Gundlach stated.


Julia La Roche is a Correspondent at 
Yahoo FinanceFollow her on Twitter.

Read the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance

Follow Yahoo Finance on TwitterFacebookInstagramFlipboardSmartNewsLinkedIn, YouTube, and reddit.

  • 'I have a PhD': The spotlight is now on Peter Navarro's role in White House coronavirus response
    Yahoo News

    'I have a PhD': The spotlight is now on Peter Navarro's role in White House coronavirus response

    One of those is a doctorate in economics (the other is a master's in public policy), but Navarro has used it to suggest that he has broad expertise related to the coronavirus crisis. On Monday, he argued on air with CNN anchor John Berman, who asked him about the use of hydroxychloroquine as a treatment. Over the weekend, there had been reports that Navarro had clashed bitterly on the matter with Dr. Anthony Fauci, a top National Institutes of Health epidemiologist who is on the coronavirus task force.

  • Synthetic antibodies might offer a quick coronavirus treatment
    Yahoo News

    Synthetic antibodies might offer a quick coronavirus treatment

    Another approach is to harvest antibodies, protective substances produced in response to an infection, from the blood plasma of people who have been infected. Dr. Jacob Glanville, one of the researchers featured in the Netflix documentary “Pandemic: How to Prevent an Outbreak,” thinks he has found a shortcut. Glanville is the president of Distributed Bio, a computational immunoengineering group that focuses on making antibody therapeutics and vaccines.

  • Coronavirus wreaks havoc in African American neighbourhoods
    BBC

    Coronavirus wreaks havoc in African American neighbourhoods

    Stark statistics from Chicago health officials have underscored the heavy toll of coronavirus on black Americans. Black Chicagoans account for half of all coronavirus cases in the city and more than 70% of deaths, despite making up 30% of the population. Other cities with large black populations, including Detroit, Milwaukee, New Orleans and New York, have become coronavirus hotspots.

  • Supreme Court won't hear Catholic Church challenge to ban on religious advertising
    USA TODAY

    Supreme Court won't hear Catholic Church challenge to ban on religious advertising

    WASHINGTON – The Supreme Court refused Monday to hear the Catholic Church's challenge to a local ban on religious advertising. The case, brought by the Archdiocese of Washington against the District of Columbia region's mass transit system, would have been the latest example of religious freedom appeals heard by the conservative-leaning court. The justices already are considering four major religion cases, all brought to them by religious organizations after lower court losses: • School choice: Three Montana women challenged a Montana ban on state funds being used to pay for religious education.

  • Chinese Official Tries to Walk Back Claim U.S. Military Brought Virus to Wuhan
    National Review

    Chinese Official Tries to Walk Back Claim U.S. Military Brought Virus to Wuhan

    China Foreign Ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian held his first press conference in several weeks on Tuesday, attempting to walk back his earlier claim that the U.S. military had brought the novel coronavirus to the city of Wuhan. The virus [is] a scientific question that requires scientific opinions,” Zhao told reporters. He was then asked if he stood behind a March 12 tweet in which he wrote that, “It might be the U.S. Army who brought the epidemic to Wuhan.

  • Brazil minister offends China with 'racist' virus tweet
    AFP

    Brazil minister offends China with 'racist' virus tweet

    China demanded an explanation from Brazil Monday after the far-right government's education minister linked the coronavirus pandemic to the Asian country's "plan for world domination," in a tweet imitating a Chinese accent. In the latest incident to strain ties between Brasilia and Beijing, Education Minister Abraham Weintraub insinuated China was behind the global health crisis. "Geopolitically, who will come out stronger from this global crisis?" he wrote on Twitter Saturday.

  • 'He kind of called us p---ies': Hear the US Navy's top official call a carrier captain 'stupid' to boos from sailors facing a coronavirus outbreak
    Business Insider

    'He kind of called us p---ies': Hear the US Navy's top official call a carrier captain 'stupid' to boos from sailors facing a coronavirus outbreak

    Acting Navy Secretary Thomas Modly's impassioned 15-minute speech to the sailors aboard the USS Theodore Roosevelt on Sunday was met with dismay and anger. In a recording of Modly's speech obtained by Task & Purpose, one person could be heard saying "What the f---?" when Modly said Crozier was "too naive or too stupid to be commanding officer of a ship like this." The acting Navy secretary's impassioned 15-minute speech to the sailors aboard the USS Theodore Roosevelt on Sunday was met with anger from some people who supported its former commander, Capt. Brett Crozier, who was removed from command last week amid a coronavirus outbreak on the ship.

  • Iran says US oil production must be known before OPEC+ call
    Associated Press

    Iran says US oil production must be known before OPEC+ call

    Iran demanded on Wednesday that U.S. oil production levels must be known before an upcoming OPEC meeting with Russia and others seeking to boost global energy prices. The meeting of the so-called OPEC+ is scheduled to be held Thursday after officials delayed it following Saudi Arabia criticizing Russia over its comments about the price collapse. A meeting in March saw OPEC and other nations led by Russia fail to agree to a production cut as the ongoing coronavirus pandemic has drastically cut demand for oil.

  • Spanish Deaths Rise, Suggesting Virus Not Yet Under Control
    Bloomberg

    Spanish Deaths Rise, Suggesting Virus Not Yet Under Control

    Spain reported an increase in daily coronavirus deaths and new cases, suggesting the government has yet to bring the disease under control. There were 5,478 new infections in the 24 hours through Tuesday, the highest since Sunday and taking the total to 140,510, according to Health Ministry data. Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez's government has struggled to address one of Europe's worst outbreaks despite weeks of severe restrictions on public life.

  • Her granddaughter was sick, so Dr. Birx stayed home: 'You can’t take that kind of risk' around the president
    Yahoo News

    Her granddaughter was sick, so Dr. Birx stayed home: 'You can’t take that kind of risk' around the president

    Dr. Deborah Birx, one of the two leading medical experts on the White House coronavirus task force, said that out of deference to social distancing rules she had stayed away from her daughter's house — despite her 10-month-old granddaughter having registered a fever of 105 degrees over the weekend. Birx said the child, who is recovering, probably had roseola, a common childhood infection, not COVID-19. Birx, who meets daily with President Trump and Vice President Pence, said she has been vigilant about avoiding social contact “because of you two.”

  • How the Coronavirus Death Toll Compares to Other Deadly Events From American History
    Time

    How the Coronavirus Death Toll Compares to Other Deadly Events From American History

    When the White House projected on March 31 that, even with social distancing measures, 100,000 to 240,000 Americans could die of COVID-19, the numbers were not necessarily shocking to those who had been paying attention. Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, had already said he projected between 100,000 to 200,000 U.S. deaths, and estimates by the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) at the University of Washington are not much different, projecting 81,766 American deaths by Aug. 4, as of Monday afternoon. White House is now setting the goal posts at 100-200K dead as a good job.

  • Coronavirus: Why China's claims of success raise eyebrows
    BBC

    Coronavirus: Why China's claims of success raise eyebrows

    China has reported no new deaths from coronavirus anywhere in the country, for the first time since the beginning of the outbreak. For months now, every morning at 03:00, officials in China have put together the latest figures on the spread of the virus to share with the world. World Health Organization Director General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus hailed China for the "speed with which [it] detected the outbreak" and its "commitment to transparency".

  • Iran supreme leader approves withdrawal of 1 billion euros from sovereign wealth fund to fight coronavirus
    Yahoo News Video

    Iran supreme leader approves withdrawal of 1 billion euros from sovereign wealth fund to fight coronavirus

    Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has approved the withdrawal of 1 billion euros from the country's sovereign wealth fund to help fight the coronavirus epidemic, President Hassan Rouhani's official website said on Monday.

  • The Vatican Welcomes Back Cardinal Pell After Stunning Sex Abuse Reversal in Australia
    The Daily Beast

    The Vatican Welcomes Back Cardinal Pell After Stunning Sex Abuse Reversal in Australia

    Many Vatican insiders who felt Pell was a scapegoat convicted for the sins of many others will now feel vindicated, while survivors of clerical sexual abuse feel as if they have been victimized all over again. Pope Francis earlier said he would refrain from commenting until all the Australian court processes played out. But at his televised mass Tuesday morning, he seemed to send a subtle message of support for Pell.

  • Fact check: No, Joe Biden did not put a gun in a woman’s mouth in Wisconsin
    USA TODAY

    Fact check: No, Joe Biden did not put a gun in a woman’s mouth in Wisconsin

    The claim: Joe Biden stuck a gun in a woman's mouth in Wisconsin A manipulated photo that dates back more than a decade is finding new life amid the effort of many Americans to stay at home and engage in social distancing during the coronavirus pandemic. An image of Democratic presidential frontrunner and former Vice President Joe Biden shared more than 2,000 times on Facebook purports to show Biden sticking a gun in an elderly woman's mouth. The accompanying text claims it happened at a 2019 rally in Wisconsin.

  • Tour More of the Toronto Home of Superstar Recording Artist Drake
    Architectural Digest

    Tour More of the Toronto Home of Superstar Recording Artist Drake

    Superstar Drake goes home to Toronto to build his eye-popping pleasure dome Originally Appeared on Architectural Digest

  • New York coronavirus deaths 'effectively flat' as U.S. braces for peak cases in hot spots
    NBC News

    New York coronavirus deaths 'effectively flat' as U.S. braces for peak cases in hot spots

    The mounting number of New York's coronavirus deaths has stayed "effectively flat" over the past two days, Gov. Andrew Cuomo said Monday, offering a glimmer of hope that the state may be at a peak even as the country braces for what the Trump administration is calling the "toughest week" yet in the fight against the pandemic. While the state has recorded 4,758 total deaths, with an additional 599 from the day before, it's only a slight uptick from the 594 added two days ago, Cuomo said, and shows a "possible flattening of the curve" that is "better than the increases we have seen."

  • Coronavirus news – live: UK death toll rises by 786 as Boris Johnson spends third night in hospital and China reports no new fatalities
    The Independent

    Coronavirus news – live: UK death toll rises by 786 as Boris Johnson spends third night in hospital and China reports no new fatalities

    China has reported no new coronavirus deaths in the last 24 hours, the first time since January, as the death toll from the disease reached 75,000 people worldwide. Meanwhile, more than 160 current and former global leaders are urging the world's 20 major industrialised nations to approve $8bn (£6.5bn) in emergency global health funding to hasten the search for a vaccine, cure and treatment for Covid-19 and prevent a second wave of the pandemic. It comes after Boris Johnson was moved to intensive care as his Covid-19 symptoms worsened and Dominic Raab, the foreign secretary, took over the government's response to the crisis.

  • Trump berates reporters during coronavirus briefing: 'You will never make it'
    Yahoo News

    Trump berates reporters during coronavirus briefing: 'You will never make it'

    Trump used Monday's briefing of the coronavirus task force to lash out at several members of the press, despite having recently praised media coverage of his response to the crisis as “very fair.” After kicking off the briefing by praising his own administration for its response to the ongoing coronavirus outbreak, Trump opened the briefing up to questions, during which he refused to acknowledge any criticism of his handling of the pandemic that has brought the United States to a virtual standstill. One point of contention was a report released today by the inspector general of the federal Department of Health and Human Services.

  • Jakarta coffin maker faces gruelling days as coronavirus death toll climbs
    Reuters

    Jakarta coffin maker faces gruelling days as coronavirus death toll climbs

    As debate rages about the true death toll caused by the coronavirus outbreak in Indonesia, Jakarta coffin maker Sahroni has been too busy to pay the issue much attention. "Usually we sell between five to seven coffins a day, but now it is up to 20 to 30 coffins a day," said Sahroni, 38, as he applied base coat onto a wooden coffin. The warehouse where Sahroni works normally specialises in coffins for Indonesia's Christian minority, but now they are providing coffins for all denominations, including Muslims who would usually be buried in a shroud.

  • Philippines backs Vietnam after China sinks fishing boat
    Associated Press

    Philippines backs Vietnam after China sinks fishing boat

    The Philippines on Wednesday expressed solidarity with Vietnam after Hanoi protested what it said was the ramming and sinking of a Vietnamese fishing boat by a Chinese coast guard ship in the disputed South China Sea. The Department of Foreign Affairs in Manila expressed deep concern over the reported April 3 sinking of the boat carrying eight fishermen off the Paracel Islands. China claims virtually the entire South China Sea and has built several islands equipped with military installations in the area, one of world's busiest shipping lanes.

  • 86-year-old and three sons die after contracting COVID-19
    CBS News

    86-year-old and three sons die after contracting COVID-19

    The coronavirus pandemic is affecting nearly everyone in the world in different ways, but for one Louisiana family, the deadly virus inflicted a particularly devastating blow. Four members of the same family died after contracting the virus, including the 86-year-old matriarch. Antoinette Franklin and three of her sons all died within days of each other.

  • Congo mine gun attack kills three Chinese nationals: Xinhua
    Yahoo News Video

    Congo mine gun attack kills three Chinese nationals: Xinhua

    A gun attack in a mining area in the Democratic Republic of Congo has killed three Chinese nationals, China's official Xinhua news agency reported, citing the Chinese embassy in the mineral-rich central African country.

  • In El Salvador, gangs are enforcing the coronavirus lockdown with baseball bats
    LA Times

    In El Salvador, gangs are enforcing the coronavirus lockdown with baseball bats

    The street gangs that have long terrorized El Salvador have now turned their attention from extortion and killing to a more pressing matter: enforcing social distancing restrictions, often with threats and baseball bats. The gangs assumed their role as public health thugs after President Nayib Bukele ordered a 30-day lockdown that started March 22. In many parts of the country, the gangs are more effective than government authorities, with tactics that include circulating recordings on messaging applications threatening people who break the rules.

  • Bloomberg

    EU Nations Upgrade Trade Arsenal to Offset U.S. Attack on WTO

    Diplomats from the 27-nation EU approved an upgrade to European legislation on enforcing international commercial rules. The envoys decided to let the EU impose penalties against countries that illegally restrict commerce and simultaneously block the World Trade Organization's dispute-settlement process. The deal on Wednesday in Brussels advances a proposal made by EU Trade Commissioner Phil Hogan in December -- before Europe became the epicenter of the deadly Covid-19 pandemic and governments across the region unleashed unprecedented economic stimulus.