During her appearance on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen on Thursday, a caller asked co-anchor Hoda Kotb about the process, jokingly wondering “how traumatized” she is from her and Kathie Lee Gifford‘s Snoopy and Woodstock outfits, worn when the NBC morning show went with a Peanuts cartoon theme in 2015.
“That was the worst year we’ve ever had. The worst ever,” admitted Kotb, 55. “You can’t unsee it.”
The mother of two confirmed that she does not have a say in what costume she wears.
“I feel like I’m always either a man or something hideous,” she said. “I was Yoda one year, and I’m usually a man. I don’t know why they keep picking me to do those things!”
So where does she rank this year’s John Travolta costume as Tony from Saturday Night Fever?
“The Travolta thing, I liked it!” she said. “I liked that one. I looked like Eddie Munster, it was clear.”
The get-up was part of Today‘s dance theme for the holiday last month. Al Roker and Craig Melvin went as The Fresh Prince of Bel Air‘s Carlton and Will, respectively, Dylan Dreyer as Seinfeld‘s Elaine, Savannah Guthrie as Sandy and Carson Daly as Danny from Grease, Sheinelle Jones as Janet Jackson, and Peter Alexander as Kevin Bacon‘s character in Footloose.
In 2018, the rival morning shows inadvertently both channeled the 1980s, resulting in an epic Halloween showdown.
Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen airs Sunday-Thursday (11 p.m. ET) on Bravo.