Judges in 5 states have temporarily blocked state laws that would restrict or ban abortions

Grace Panetta
Updated ·4 min read
11

  • Courts in five states have so far blocked state-level abortion bans after Roe was overturned.

  • Judges in Louisiana, Kentucky, and Utah temporarily blocked "trigger laws" banning abortion.

  • Here's where abortion access currently stands and where judges have blocked bans.

The Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade on Friday sent abortion back to each individual state to decide — and state judges are emerging as key players in the new abortion fight.

Before the Supreme Court decision, 13 states had enacted "trigger" laws designed to ban abortion as soon as Roe fell, others had passed abortion bans or restrictions in earlier years designed to challenge Roe, and still others had pre-Roe abortion bans on their books that courts are now tasked with ruling whether to uphold.

Abortion rights litigants are now turning to state courts and arguing under state laws and constitutions to block those trigger laws and other restrictions, with judges in two states temporarily blocking trigger laws that went into effect on Friday.

Here's where abortion access currently stands, and where courts have temporarily blocked abortion bans so far:

Florida:

Leon Circuit Judge Leon Cooper issued a ruling that will temporarily block Florida's 15-week abortion ban from going into effect on July 1 as planned, finding that the law violates the Florida Constitution's right to privacy.

But the ruling won't be official until the judge issues a written order on Friday, meaning the law could still take effect as scheduled, per the Orlando Sentinel. The state appealing the case would also put on a stay on Judge Cooper's injunction and allow the law to take effect.

Kentucky:

Jefferson Circuit Judge Mitch Perry temporarily blocked Kentucky's trigger law banning nearly all abortions that immediately went into effect on June 24 and the state's separate six-week abortion ban on Thursday, allowing abortion procedures in the state to resume for now.

Louisiana:

A state judge in Louisiana has temporarily blocked the state's trigger law, which went into effect on Friday and bans nearly all abortions. Judge Robin Giarrusso said the law's language is "unconstitutionally vague," and set the next hearing over the law for July 8. Patients can receive care at least until then.

Utah:

Judge Andrew Stone temporarily blocked Utah's trigger law, which bans abortion except in cases of rape, incest, or threat to the patient's life. It too went into effect on Friday.

"The immediate effects that will occur outweigh any policy issues of the state," Stone said in a Monday hearing blocking the law from being in effect for 14 days, granting a request from Planned Parenthood and the ACLU.

Texas:

A judge temporarily blocked the enforcement of Texas' pre-Roe abortion ban on Monday, allowing providers to perform abortions up until six weeks of pregnancy — for now.

The pre-Roe abortion ban is separate from Texas' six-week "heartbeat" abortion ban, which has been in effect since September 2021, and its trigger law banning nearly all abortions, which is set to go into effect later this summer.

Abortion bans allowed to go into effect:

On the other hand, federal judges have allowed previously-enjoined six-week abortion bans to take effect in four states following the Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization decision on Friday. In Dobbs, the Supreme Court upheld Mississippi's 15-week abortion ban and struck down the protections for first-trimester abortion that were established in Roe and upheld in the 1992 case Casey v. Planned Parenthood.

Over the past decade, and especially after Justice Brett Kavanaugh's confirmation to the Supreme Court in 2018, several Republican-controlled state legislatures passed six-week or total abortion bans that were quickly struck down for violating Roe's prohibitions against first-trimester abortion.

But now without any federal protections for the procedure, judges have allowed a previously-blocked total abortion ban to take effect in Alabama and previously-enjoined six-week abortion bans in Ohio, South Carolina, and Tennessee to go into effect.

Tennessee's six-week ban is separate from the state's trigger law banning nearly all abortions, which is set to take effect by July 24.

Read the original article on Business Insider