Julia Roberts reportedly was suggested to play Harriet Tubman, and Twitter isn't having it
The revelation that Julia Roberts was suggested to play Harriet Tubman has shocked and downright outraged many social media users.
"Harriet," a historical film about the life of the slave-turned-abolitionist, starred actress Cynthia Erivo. But if one studio executive had their way, Roberts would've led the way.
Producer Gregory Allen Howard, who started writing the film's screenplay over two decades ago with director Kasi Lemmons, revealed the outrageous casting request during an interview this month with Focus Features, the distributor for "Harriet."
"Harriet, which was set up at Disney 26 years ago, was my first assignment. … Hollywood, however, was very different back then," Howard recalled. "I was told how one studio head said in a meeting, 'This script is fantastic. Let's get Julia Roberts to play Harriet Tubman.' "
'Harriet' fact-check: How accurate is the new movie about Harriet Tubman?
He continued: "When someone pointed out that Roberts couldn’t be Harriet, the executive responded, 'It was so long ago. No one is going to know the difference.' " (Howard did not identify the exec who allegedly made the proposal.)
But Twitter certainly does know the difference, and had some thoughts about the tone-deaf suggestion of a white actress portraying a black heroine.
'Harriet' is in theaters: Here's where you can learn about Harriet Tubman in real life
"Yet another example of a system of erasure & marginalization in action," tweeted @PRanganathan. "I wonder if the original version of that Notting Hill line had #JuliaRoberts saying this: 'I’m just a girl standing in front a studio exec asking him to go to hell for suggesting I play Harriet Tubman.'"
Others mocked the casting suggestion entirely. "In light of news that Julia Roberts was being considered for the role of Harriet Tubman, I would like to put forth the idea for Leslie Jones to play Queen Elizabeth II in the upcoming biopic," @mrparks212 tweeted.
In light of news that Julia Roberts was being considered for the role of Harriett Tubman,
I would like to put forth the idea for Leslie Jones to play Queen Elizabeth II in the upcoming biopic#paletteswaps— Darth Hater (@mrparks212) November 20, 2019
Jordan Crucchiola took the opportunity to encourage people to go after their dreams regardless of how wild they may seem.
"If you’re chasing a Hollywood dream and feel doubtful you’ll ever make it, remember there are executives getting paid (expletive) loads of money to suggest JULIA ROBERTS should play Harriet Tubman," she wrote in a NSFW tweet. "A jar of cockroaches is more qualified than some of these people so DON’T GIVE UP."
Some social media users addressed the fact that as absurd as Roberts playing Tubman would be, it wasn't surprising that it was suggested by Hollywood.
"If Julia Roberts can play Harriet Tubman then damn it Scarlett Johansson can play...oh wait. Hollywood is wild, man," tweeted @WajahatAli. "People of color, friends in the industry, stay sane and grounded as you deal with this madness. Laugh at the absurdity if possible."
If Julia Roberts can play Harriet Tubman then damn it Scarlett Johansson can play...oh wait. Hollywood is wild, man. People of color, friends in the industry, stay sane and grounded as you deal with this madness. Laugh at the absurdity if possible.
— Wajahat "Abu Khadija" Ali (@WajahatAli) November 20, 2019
Jay Caruso said it was "entirely believable that a Hollywood exec, 25 years ago, would suggest Julia Roberts to play Harriet Tubman."
"These are the same people who were greenlighting Pauly Shore movies at the time," he wrote.
Yes, it is entirely believable that a Hollywood exec, 25 years ago, would suggest Julia Roberts to play Harriet Tubman.
These are the same people who were greenlighting Pauly Shore movies at the time.— Jay Caruso (@JayCaruso) November 20, 2019
A few people noted that Roberts would probably be uncomfortable playing the role as well.
"Ummmm... i’m guessing julia roberts would very much like to be excluded from this narrative," tweeted @banikarim, referencing Taylor Swift's quotable line.
ummmm... i’m guessing julia roberts would very much like to be excluded from this narrative. https://t.co/MnyF1N5bcW
— susie (@banikarim) November 20, 2019
Another person tweeted out a gif of how they envisioned Roberts' reaction to being offered the part of Tubman.
Hollywood execs: hey Julia, gotta role for you... Harriet Tubman.
Julia Roberts: pic.twitter.com/Sj8tQbkbBW— The name's Rollo, turkey! (@sonofdusable) November 20, 2019
User @LoriAnnGazella tweeted, "#JuliaRoberts is good but she not that good to play a woman of color."
#JuliaRoberts is good but she not that good to play a woman of color
— LoLo (@LoriAnnGazella) November 20, 2019
"I love Julia Roberts, but there are plenty of actresses of color who could play Harriet Tubman....Viola Davis comes to mind," added @LynneGarrison.
I love Julia Roberts, but there are plenty of actresses of color who could play Harriet Tubman....Viola Davis comes to mind.
— AlphaChick♿️ (@LynneGarrison) November 20, 2019
USA TODAY reached out to Roberts' rep for comment.
"Harriet," starring Erivo, Leslie Odom Jr., Joe Alwyn and Janelle Monáe, debuted in theaters Nov. 1.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Julia Roberts was suggested to play Harriet Tubman; Twitter reacts