By Will Dunham WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A federal judge on Friday dismissed a lawsuit filed against the U.S. government by the families of three American citizens killed by U.S. drones in Yemen, saying senior officials cannot be held personally responsible for money damages for the act of conducting war. The families of the three - including Anwar al-Awlaki, a New Mexico-born militant Muslim cleric who had joined al Qaeda's Yemen affiliate, and his teenage son - sued over their 2011 deaths in U.S. drone strikes, arguing that the killings were illegal. Judge Rosemary Collyer of the U.S. District Court in Washington threw out the case, which had named as defendants former defense secretary and CIA chief Leon Panetta, former senior military commander and CIA chief David Petraeus and two other top military commanders. "The question presented is whether federal officials can be held personally liable for their roles in drone strikes abroad that target and kill U.S. citizens," Collyer said in her opinion. "The question raises fundamental issues regarding constitutional principles, and it is not easy to answer." But the judge said she would grant the government's motion to dismiss the case. Collyer said that the officials named as defendants "must be trusted and expected to act in accordance with the U.S. Constitution when they intentionally target a U.S. citizen abroad at the direction of the president and with the concurrence of Congress. They cannot be held personally responsible in monetary damages for conducting war." Awlaki's U.S.-born son, Abdulrahman al-Awlaki, was 16 years old when he was killed. Also killed was Samir Khan, a naturalized U.S. citizen who had moved to Yemen in 2009 and worked on Inspire, an English-language al Qaeda magazine. The American Civil Liberties Union and the Center for Constitutional Rights, both based in New York, represented the families. They had argued that in killing American citizens, the government had violated fundamental rights under the U.S. Constitution to due process and to be free from unreasonable seizure. 'TRAVESTY OF JUSTICE' "This is a deeply troubling decision that treats the government's allegations as proof while refusing to allow those allegations to be tested in court," ACLU lawyer Hina Shamsi said. "The court's view that it cannot provide a remedy for extrajudicial killings when the government claims to be at war, even far from any battlefield, is profoundly at odds with the Constitution." Center for Constitutional Rights lawyer Maria LaHood said the judge "effectively convicted" Anwar al-Awlaki "posthumously based solely on the government's say-so." LaHood said the judge also found that the constitutional rights of the son and of Khan "weren't violated because the government didn't target them." "It seems there's no remedy if the government intended to kill you, and no remedy if it didn't. This decision is a true travesty of justice for our constitutional democracy, and for all victims of the U.S. government's unlawful killings," LaHood added. Collyer ruled that the families did not have a claim under the Constitution's Fourth Amendment guarantee against unreasonable seizures because the government did not seize or restrain the three who were killed. "Unmanned drones are functionally incapable of 'seizing' a person; they are designed to kill, not capture," she wrote. Collyer also wrote that the families had presented a plausible claim that the government violated Awlaki's due process rights. "Nonetheless, the court finds no available remedy under U.S. law for this claim," the judge wrote. "In this delicate area of war making, national security, and foreign relations, the judiciary has an exceedingly limited role," Collyer said. Allowing claims against individual federal officials in this case "would impermissibly draw the court into the heart of executive and military planning and deliberation," she wrote. It would "require the court to examine national security policy and the military chain of command as well as operational combat decisions," she said. Nasser al-Awlaki, father of Anwar al-Awlaki, said in a statement he was disappointed in the American justice system and "like any parent or grandparent would, I want answers from the government when it decides to take life, but all I have got so far is secrecy and a refusal even to explain." Drone attacks have killed several suspected figures in al Qaeda's Yemen-based affiliate including Awlaki, who is accused of orchestrating plots to bomb a Detroit-bound airliner in 2009 and U.S. cargo planes in 2010. The United States has faced international criticism for its use of drones to attack militants in places such as Pakistan and Yemen. A U.N. human rights watchdog last month called on the Obama administration to limit its use of drones targeting suspected al Qaeda and Taliban militants. President Barack Obama's administration increased the number of drone strikes after he took office in 2009 but attacks have dropped off in the past year. The United States has come under pressure from critics to rein in the missile strikes and do more to protect civilians. (Additional reporting by Dena Aubin in New York; Editing by Bernard Orr and Mohammad Zargham)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
"My experiences in the ICU these past weeks have left me surprised, disheartened, but most of all, angry."
A Canadian diver who scored a 0 with a feet-first flop with the finals on the line said she wasn't going to give up
Pamela Ware scored a zero at the Olympics with a failed dive, but she chalked it up to a bad mistake at the worst time.
Improper fuel level detected in postrace inspection for Vettel's Aston Martin.
- The Guardian
US viewers have been able to see everything at any given moment while understanding fundamentally nothing about what’s going on The women’s 100m final was a brilliant spectacle but you might have had to wait to watch it. Photograph: Dylan Martinez/Reuters If there’s one message the Olympics unfailingly conveys, it’s that elite competition is all about making the right choices. At a certain point every athlete needs to make the decision not to do certain things: the fencer lunging for the head ra
- Chicago Tribune
After decades of invisibility, asexuals are speaking up and gaining ground: ‘I don’t need to be fixed because I’m not broken.’
CHICAGO — Looking back, Allison McCorkle can laugh at all the signs she missed: There was that time in sixth grade when the cool boy her friends were swooning over called to ask her out. Not only was McCorkle uninterested, but she was also puzzled as to why anyone would feel otherwise. “We’re too young to be doing that,” she told her flustered suitor. A few years later, when McCorkle’s best ...
- Business Insider
A Waffle House waitress who worked a double shift while looking after her baby says she received a $1,000 tip from a country-music star who was impressed by her work ethic
The music star told her that some people were unwilling to work hard, the waitress said in an interview with Fox 8 News.
- KCRA - Sacramento Videos
Meteorologist Linh Truong says goodbye to KCRA 3 viewers after six years with the station. “It was a dream come true to get this job six years ago and I’ve loved every minute,” Truong said. She’s headed to a new job in St. Louis.
- Good Housekeeping
J.Lo posted the ultimate thirst trap for Ben and co. 💛💛
Jay Pickett, known for his work in soap operas General Hospital and Port Charles, died of unknown causes on Friday at the age of 60. Pickett was on location in Idaho shooting the film Treasure Valley when he died while on a horse, according to actor and friend Jim Heffel. “Yesterday I lost a good […]
- NBC Sports
World Cup qualifying starts Sept. 2, who from the Gold Cup squad will be there? A few, at least.
- The Guardian
The Ohio Republican admits he spoke to Trump the day the Confederate flag flew in Congress. Aptly, the investigation of John Brown’s raid sets precedent for what must happen nextWhat did Jim Jordan know about the insurrection and when? Jim Jordan listens as Kevin McCarthy speaks to reporters at the US Capitol. Photograph: Shawn Thew/EPA The House select committee on the 6 January insurrection at the Capitol, according to chairman Bennie Thompson, should “not be reluctant” to include on its witne
- Business Insider
The Army rejected the M50 Ontos outright, but the Marines embraced it, putting it on the frontlines of the Vietnam War's heaviest fighting.
An Olympic medalist admitted on live TV that she was 'sh------ herself' while swimming her relay leg
Sydney Pickrem was very candid during her TV interview after winning bronze for Team Canada in Sunday's 4×100 meter medley relay.
- WCVB - Boston
Police say there is an active death investigation-- with potentially hazardous materials-- near the Marriott Copley hotel. Emergency crews responded to a parking garage located at 110 Huntington Ave. just after 3:30 a.m. Officials say it is too early to tell if the death is considered suspicious.
Warning: graphic carnage ahead.
Forget Google Search and Fuchsia. Researchers from Google, Stanford, Princeton, and other universities might have made a computer discovery so big we can’t fully comprehend it yet. Even Google researchers aren’t entirely sure that their time crystal discovery is valid. But if it turns out to be accurate, then Google might be one of the … The post Google’s time crystal discovery is so big, we can’t fully comprehend it appeared first on BGR.
- Business Insider
Trump lashed out after documents were released showing him pressuring Justice Department officials to overturn the 2020 election
In a statement, Donald Trump denied documents showed he was trying to subvert the election - though he continued to push bogus election-fraud claims.
- MMA Junkie
Gadzhi Rabadanov scores nasty KO at Bellator 263; coach Khabib Nurmagomedov loads fallen fighter on stretcher
Khabib Nurmagomedov coached his fighter Gadzhi Rabadanov to a violent KO win – and then loaded the fallen opposition onto a backboard.
- USA TODAY Sports
Baseball's trade deadline is behind us and with two months left to go, a look at which teams have the best shot at a title.
- Country Living
You'll want to read this before you book your flight. ✈️