Madison Baby Doe autopsy released as officials seek identity of dead infant in Plain City

Plain City Police Chief Dale McKee carries out the tiny casket of "Madison Baby Doe" or as the community refers to her, "Baby Madison", during a procession and burial on June 24. The unidentified infant was found in the trash, on June 15th. The baby still hasn't been identified but police say the case remains a priority.
Plain City Police Chief Dale McKee carries out the tiny casket of "Madison Baby Doe" or as the community refers to her, "Baby Madison", during a procession and burial on June 24. The unidentified infant was found in the trash, on June 15th. The baby still hasn't been identified but police say the case remains a priority.

An autopsy released late Tuesday provided no clear answers to the death of an infant found in Plain City this summer, and while police officials stressed the case is a high priority, they could provide no answers to what progress has been made.

Madison County Coroner Dr. James Kaehr released the autopsy results for the infant, known as Madison Jane Doe, from which, he said, he was unable to determine cause or manner of death.

"Madison's body demonstrated many injuries and abnormalities. Several of these could be lethal in isolation (they could cause death even if they were the only abnormality present). Without having more information regarding when and how each abnormality developed, we are unable to determine with reasonable certainty which one (or combination) ultimately resulted in Madison's death."

The Montgomery County Coroner's office performed the autopsy with results returned to Dr. Kaehr. When contacted, coroner's investigator Bob Gibbs said the state of the remains creates a challenge in identifying the baby's parents.

"We would first send the DNA (sample) to BCI (Ohio Bureau of Criminal Identification) to see if we would get a hit on a possible relative."

If not, the remains and DNA sample would be held "until a standard could be found for comparison from family members, such as someone coming forward with new information. A lot of times, that's how we get bodies identified if we don't have dental records," Gibbs said.

Gibbs said he was not sure why officials weren't more forthcoming. Investigators insist that identifying the human remains of the body found this summer in a trash can in suburban Plain City is a top priority.

But police and prosecutors are providing little insight into what they're doing to track down those responsible for disposing of the infant.

"Madison Baby Doe" was given a funeral and miles-long procession before being laid to rest in Forest Grove Cemetery six months ago.

During the June 15 trash collection, a worker with Local Waste Services saw an arm or leg that didn't look like a doll's as a trash can was dumped into a truck on Bluestem Lane in the five-year-old Darby Fields subdivision.

The grim discovery set the neighborhood on edge. Speculation and theories spread. Neighbors looked at each other and wondered.

"The case is still being actively investigated, and all the information is sensitive to the case," said Plain City Police Chief Dale McKee in a recent email to The Dispatch. "The Madison County Prosecutor has requested that no sensitive information be released due to it possibly jeopardizing the case. I'm hoping that we are able to share some new information in the near future."

Plain City Police Chief Dale McKee salutes the tiny casket of "Madison Baby Doe," during her burial on June 24. The body of the unidentified infant was found in the trash on June 15.
Plain City Police Chief Dale McKee salutes the tiny casket of "Madison Baby Doe," during her burial on June 24. The body of the unidentified infant was found in the trash on June 15.

When asked by The Dispatch for an update, Nicholas A. Adkins, Madison County prosecutor emailed:

"First, because of the nature of the investigation, I need to ensure that the case is not compromised through the release of confidential investigatory records," Adkins said, adding that rules of professional conduct prohibit disclosure of information.

Adkins said that the investigations "has progressed through the development of investigative leads. Matters of this nature require boots on the ground for headway to occur. I have confidence that law enforcement will continue to put forth their best investigative efforts on behalf of Madison Baby Doe.”

Stuffed animals and flowers still decorate the headstone of Madison Baby Doe," an unidentified infant whose body was found in the trash in Plain City on June 15th. This file photo shows her casket bedecked by stuffed animals and flowers during burial services on June 24.
Stuffed animals and flowers still decorate the headstone of Madison Baby Doe," an unidentified infant whose body was found in the trash in Plain City on June 15th. This file photo shows her casket bedecked by stuffed animals and flowers during burial services on June 24.

Meanwhile, stuffed animals and flowers decorate the headstone at Forest Grove. Leaves whip past and collect near a chain link fence. The chill in the air takes a new meaning for the child, that by now should be learning to crawl.

And investigators hope that the granite's marking: "2023" and "Received in Heaven" will be accompanied by answers to "Why?'

dnarciso@dispatch.com

This article originally appeared on The Columbus Dispatch: Autopsy released Plain City Madison Baby Doe infant death case