Merkel’s Party Just Broke Ultimate Taboo in German Politics

Patrick Donahue and Arne Delfs

(Bloomberg) -- When Chancellor Angela Merkel’s embattled heir left Berlin on Wednesday, she looked like she might catch a break from her domestic woes at a routine conference in the European Parliament. By the time Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer landed in Strasbourg, she was facing a scarcely believable crisis: an eastern branch of her party had thrown its lot in with the far right.

Across Europe, the center-right allies of Kramp-Karrenbauer’s Christian Democratic Union are wrestling with how to deal with the rising support for extremists. But in Germany, of course, that dilemma carries special weight, so a state CDU chapter’s decision to line up alongside the Alternative for Germany party for the first time ever sent shockwaves through the country -- and threw its federal government into disarray.

Merkel’s coalition partners hastily scheduled a crisis meeting for Saturday to talk about the consequences of the debacle, according to a CDU spokesman. The move comes after the government’s junior coalition partner, the Social Democrats, attacked the CDU for having crossed a red line in electing a regional state premier with the help of the far right.

The CDU’s party leaders quickly distanced themselves from the move. “CDU lawmakers in Thuringia willingly accepted that their votes could elect a state premier supported by Nazis,” Kramp-Karrenbauer’s right hand man Paul Ziemiak said in a televised statement.

Ziemiak and Kramp-Karrenbauer urged Thuringia to hold a new election, a call that might fall on deaf ears in the regional state. Saxony’s state premier Michael Kretschmer (CDU) voiced skepticism that new elections in his neighboring state will happen anytime soon as long as the CDU members of the state parliament are against that. “These are freely elected members of parliament who make their own decision,“ Kretschmer said Thursday morning on national broadcaster ARD.

The ballot lays bare the rifts in Europe’s central nation as Kramp-Karrenbauer struggles to keep the CDU in check and her officials in the former communist east battle to stop angry voters abandoning them for the AfD.

At a moment when traditional U.S. support is in doubt, its economic model is in question and Merkel herself is preparing to step down next year, the last thing Germany needs is a breakthrough for the kind of right-wing populism that capitalized on anti-immigration sentiment. It was the refugee crisis of 2015 that fatally tested Merkel’s grip on power and gave the AfD an opening.

“Today’s decision divides our whole country,” Zemiak said as street protests erupted in several cities, including outside the CDU’s Berlin headquarters.

For Kramp-Karrenbauer, known as AKK, it’s another blow to her authority at the head of a party she hopes to lead into the next election. She had categorically ruled out working with the AfD in Thuringia. But her local party leader Mike Mohring went ahead and did it anyway.

Fourteen months after taking the reins of the CDU, AKK has failed to get traction in opinion polls after a series of gaffes and misjudged jokes. Last year she faced a leadership struggle. The events in Thuringia, one of Germany’s lesser known states, reinforce the sense of a party that is out of control.

Indeed, even after landing in Strasbourg, AKK was unable to even get Mohring on the phone, according to a person with knowledge of the episode who asked not to be identified.

Finally, after a tense conversation, the chairwoman dispatched Zemiak, her general secretary, to make his statement in Berlin, in which he called for the government in Thuringia to be dissolved and a new election to held. AKK later echoed part of the message but indicated no disciplinary action.

AfD Ambush

The drama began in the state capital of Erfurt, with Bodo Ramelow of the anti-capitalist Left party set to claim a second term at the head of a minority government. On the third vote, the Free Democrats unexpectedly put forward Thomas Kemmerich as their candidate for the premiership.

CDU members backed him.

That’s when the AfD, which has surged on opposition to Merkel’s migration policy, dropped its own nominee -- an unknown village mayor-- to back Kemmerich, handing the premiership to the Free Democrat and shocking Ramelow’s alliance.

Mohring said in Erfurt that there would be a “clear separation” from the AfD, but few were convinced by his arguments.

“What happened today in Thuringia is unique in the history of the Federal Republic of Germany,” said Kevin Kuehnert, deputy chair of Merkel’s coalition partner the SPD, who joined the demonstrators outside CDU HQ. “What happened today, must be undone.”

Green party co-leader Robert Habeck, who the CDU may need to govern again in 2021, said the party had been warned but decided for a “deliberate pact with right-wing extremists.”

“If an election of a state premier isn’t a cooperation with the AfD, then what is?” Habeck said.

And Merkel? She’s been staying out of domestic politics since she handed the party leadership over to AKK in 2018. On Wednesday, as the storm broke over the CDU, she was far away, on her own government plane, beginning a three-day trip to South Africa and Angola.

To contact the reporters on this story: Patrick Donahue in Berlin at pdonahue1@bloomberg.net;Arne Delfs in Berlin at adelfs@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Ben Sills at bsills@bloomberg.net, Raymond Colitt, Daniel Schaefer

For more articles like this, please visit us at bloomberg.com

Subscribe now to stay ahead with the most trusted business news source.

©2020 Bloomberg L.P.