More than luck? Venice diver who found large megalodon tooth shares tips on teeth hunting

Diver Michael Nastasio found a 6.25-inch long megalodon tooth, the largest tooth he’s found out of his 22 years of diving.

Nastasio started Black Gold Fossil Charters in Aug. 2020, but he’s been hunting since 2011 and has since become an expert on shark tooth hunting in the area. More than luck, it’s taken him years of preparation with his love of shark teeth hunting only growing stronger.

“It’s one of those things that never gets old,” Nastasio said. “No matter how many times I find them, the excitement doesn’t go away.”

What is a megalodon?

The megalodon is the largest shark to have ever lived in the world's ocean, according to the Smithsonian. The prehistoric shark lived between 23 to 3.6 million years ago and was about three times larger than the modern day great white shark. The largest megalodons were roughly 60-feet in length and weighed up to 50 tons.

More on Florida's prehistoric animals: Bone-crushing dogs and 3-ton sloths among prehistoric animals that roamed Florida

How to find shark teeth? This Florida beach is the 'Shark Tooth Capital' of the world. Here are quick tips to find them

How rare are Megalodon teeth to find?

Nastasio finds megalodon teeth every time he gets in the water, but it's not every day you find a 6-inch tooth. Last year there were only five or six 6-inch teeth that were caught between divers in the Venice-area.

The massive prehistoric sharks would come to Venice to mate, not to eat, making a large tooth a rare find, Nastasio said. Florida was recognized by the Smithsonian Institution as a prominent nursey habitat for the megalodons looking to nurse their pups.

What’s also so rare about the tooth he found was not only its size but also its color. The golden orange hue of the tooth signifies it as a rarity, dubbing it a Golden Beach tooth.  Usually shark teeth that are found have a dark silver or black color because of their exposure to the elements, but the golden color of his find tells Nastasio that it’s a tooth that hasn’t been out long enough to mineralize.

Four-year-old Jazlynn Torres of Bradenton looks at the mouth of a prehistoric megalodon while touring The Bishop Museum of Science and Nature in Bradenton with her family on Saturday. The museum and The Parker Manatee Rehabilitation Habitat have re-opened to the public.
Four-year-old Jazlynn Torres of Bradenton looks at the mouth of a prehistoric megalodon while touring The Bishop Museum of Science and Nature in Bradenton with her family on Saturday. The museum and The Parker Manatee Rehabilitation Habitat have re-opened to the public.

How can I find megalodon teeth?

The best way to find big megalodon teeth is through a guided charter boat, Nastasio said. They’re professional, certified divers who have been doing it for decades, but beach diving on your own could also lead to finding teeth.

Although the Venice Boneyard is considered a staple for megalodon teeth hunting, Nastasio recommends that people avoid overpopulated diving spots because chances are that most of the exposed megalodon teeth were caught for that day. Nastasio generally never goes to the same spot twice. He has about 1,600 spots he rotates between.

For those preferring to be a little closer to the shore, Nastasio recommends going to Peace River to dig and sift for some teeth.

When’s the best time to find teeth?

The best time to find teeth is after storms when the waves expose a new layer of sand.

This article originally appeared on Naples Daily News: Florida diver finds 'massive' megalodon tooth. Here's how he did it