FLORIDA — The most expensive American ZIP codes during the coronavirus pandemic include two in Florida. They are Fisher Island's 33109, an exclusive community south of Miami Beach where median home prices were $3,071,250. The 33109 code is the 16th most expensive ZIP code in America.
And, the 33921 ZIP code in Boca Grande just snuck on the list, tied for 125th, with a $1,500,000 median sale price.
Property Club, a New York City-based real estate company, looked at all residential sales nationwide between March 13 and Sept. 7 to determine the 125 priciest ZIP codes of the pandemic thus far.
The top two in the nation are both in California, with Atherton (94027) coming in at No. 1 with a median home sale price of nearly $6.7 million, and Beverly Hills (90210) at No. 2 with a $4.08 million median home sale price.
“The biggest surprise was that no urban city ZIP codes were in the top 10,” Andrew Weinberger, CEO of Property Club, told Patch. “It’s particularly astounding because when looking at historical numbers, you’ll see multiple New York City ZIP codes near the top.”
Fisher Island is a private, 216-acre community on Biscayne Bay accessible only by a 24-hour passenger vehicle ferry service off the MacArthur Causeway or by private yacht, according to Miami Luxury Homes. Residents navigate the island by golf cart.
Once the private winter retreat of the Vanderbilt family in the 1920s, the Mediterranean style Vanderbilt Mansion boasts a 2,250 square foot ballroom, and a 6,800 square-foot south terrace for Fisher Island Club members to enjoy.
Atherton has been the highest-priced ZIP code “consistently” when looking at previous similar ZIP codes, Weinberger said. But he says the pandemic has had a noticeable impact on others that made the list.
“For example, here we see more Long Island ZIP codes on the list than New York City,” he said. “Normally, you’d expect places like Manhattan and San Francisco to have more.”
“We’re also seeing more ZIP codes near the sea and the mountains. It’s the first time we’ve seen a Lake Tahoe ZIP code in any top 10.”
More than two-thirds of the priciest ZIP codes identified are in California; all on the list are spread across only 15 states; and 18 continue to hold a median sale price of over $3 million, according to other “key findings” identified by the researchers.
ZIP codes with fewer than five closed sales between the study time frame were not considered, the methodology states.