I Never Thought I'd Love Organic Makeup—Until I Found These 10 Products

Erin Jahns

Confession: Even as someone who lives, works, sleeps, and writes about beauty practically 24/7, organic makeup (categorically) kind of feels like the twilight zone. A) There's a whole lot of murkiness when it comes to what's "clean," "natural," "nontoxic," "green," and yes, even truly "organic" within the beauty industry, and B) lots of said murkiness entails brands and products that fall very short in terms of their efficacy as makeup products. Blush turns into smudge city, mascara into flake city, foundation into puddle city… You get the idea. In all honesty, it's kind of a crapshoot, especially if you're ultra attached to the "organic" label.

"'Clean beauty' is a much better term for the consumer as the products are non-toxic and still effective," cosmetic chemist Ginger King told Allure. last year. "'Non-toxic' means free from undesirable ingredients listed by the Environmental Working Group. This is better than claiming 'natural' or 'organic' as they are products that perform without compromising safety."

My personal philosophy has always been as follows: If I'm choosing to wear makeup (which, honestly, I only wear 40% of the time), I'm wearing it for a reason. I apply a concealer to conceal, I apply mascara to bring more attention to my favorite features (my lashes), or I apply blush to put a little pep in my complexion. I'm not going to wear a "clean" or "organic" beauty product just because it's "clean" or "organic." It has to actually work, and again, just because of how the industry is right now (i.e., very little regulation), it's hard to ever really know what you're putting on your face. So I just want something that will do the dang job and not leave me with a rash or breakout. (FYI: Some makeup products that are too natural or harsh have done just that.) Food for thought.

However, after lots and lots of testing, I've discovered an intimate number of organic makeup products from amazing brands that not only look great, apply easily, and wear with stamina, but which I trust in terms of their ingredient transparency and dedication to quality. Now, as a quick reminder, certified organic products can be labeled "made with organic" or "contains organic" if they contain (at minimum) 70% organic ingredients, and these products must display the organic and non-organic ingredients on the label and the name of the organic certifier. (You'll usually find these certifications at the bottom of a brand's website, or in their mission statements.) That said, the FDA does not have a definition for the term "organic,” since it's not defined by either the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act or the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act, which it uses as guidelines. So you can see how this all gets a little hairy, am I right?

I recommend doing your research, deciding what your wants and needs are in terms of how clean or natural your product regimen is, and go from there. For the record, while most of the brands below are certified organic, some are not and only feature products with a handful of ingredients quoted as organic. You do you! I've done my best to get you started in the world of organic (or mostly organic) makeup brands that I've truly vetted, love, and would recommend. Keep scrolling! All of my current nontoxic favorites are below. 

1. Tata Harper Be Adored Lip Tint Treatment

Tata Harper Be Adored Tinted Anti-Aging Neuropeptide Lip Treatment ($32)

I've had this organic lip tint in my bag 24/7 ever since I discovered it on Tata Harper's website about two years ago. It's one of the few products in my arsenal that are perfect regardless of whether I'm wearing them with no makeup, a full face, or something in between. The raspberry tint is universally flattering, and it gives your lips that Popsicle-like stain that's so coveted. The consistency is lovely—not sticky or tacky—and thanks to high-quality organic ingredients, my lips feel and look healthier and plumper. Even thrown in with my non-organic makeup, this is the one ride-or-die product I can't ever live without.

I also recommend:

Tata Harper Very Flashy Neuropeptide Blush ($39)

2. Kora Organics Rose Quartz Crystal Illuminizer

Kora Organics Crystal Luminizer ($28)

Kora Organics creator Miranda Kerr and I agree: This crystal-infused luminizing cream is pretty damn amazing. Unlike so many cream or balmy highlighters, it doesn't leave my skin looking smudgy or feeling sticky. Instead, it melts into my complexion in well-behaved conjunction with any other products I've applied (it layers wonderfully) and gives me the softest, prettiest glow that never turns oily or greasy. There are three different shades. I'm just partial to the Rose Quartz hue, which is a soft and glimmery pink.

I also recommend: 

Kora Organics Noni Lip Treatment ($24)

3. W3ll People Expressionist Volumizing Mascara

W3ll People Expressionist Volumizing Mascara ($20)

I had lost all hope of finding the clean mascara of my dreams until I finally test-drove this highly rated volumizing wand from W3ll People. And the reviews didn't lie! Not only does this mascara deliver the darkest, inkiest black color (which I love), but it also creates lots of volume and length without weighing down my long, thin lashes. The addition of organic, conditioning botanicals is another great perk.

I also recommend: 

W3ll People Expressionist Liquid Eyeliner ($18)

4. Ilia Super Serum Skin Tint SPF 40

Ilia Super Serum Skin Tint Broad Spectrum SPF 40 Sunscreen ($46)

Never have I ever loved tinted moisturizes or tinted sunscreens. The shades are usually all wrong or the consistency and texture are off. However, this fresh-off-the-presses launch from Ilia seems to be the exception. Not only does it offer the perfect hint of coverage for those days when I still want to be mostly bare-faced, but it keeps my quick-to-parch skin hydrated and radiant thanks to organic squalane in addition to hyaluronic acid and niacinamide. It's a makeup-meets-skincare powerhouse!

I also recommend: 

Ilia Liquid Light Serum Highlighter ($42)

5. Cocokind Highlighter Stick

Cocokind Highlighter Stick in Mai-Light ($12)

Meet the organic makeup product that actually turned me into a stick-makeup person. Infused with cool adaptogens from certified organic mushrooms, this highlight stick from Cocokind also boosts your glow with prettifying, moisturizing ingredients and oils like jojoba and castor seed oil. I love the lightt, shimmery pink shade called Mai-Light, but I also love mixing it with the slightly bronzier iteration (shown below) called Chagaglo. It's perfect on top of your cheekbones, around your temples, or right on your Cupid's bow.

I also recommend: 

Cocokind Highlighter Stick in Chagaglo ($12)

6. Henné Organics Luxury Lip Tint

Henné Organics Luxury Lip Tint in Azaela ($21)

Henné Organics is a brand-new find, and I couldn't be more thrilled to discover its chic spread of organic lip products and luxe hand creams. However, since we're talking makeup, specifically, I have to call out my obsession with the brand's gorgeous tinted lip balms. This vibrant pink shade is called Azaela, and I know it's going to carry me well into summer.

I also recommend: 

Henné Organics Lip Serum ($45)

7. Crop Natural Bio Metal Liquid Eyeshadow

Crop Natural Bio Metal Liquid Eyeshadow ($26)

One thing you should know about me: I don't do powder eye shadow. Or rather, I can and sometimes I do, but it rarely ends well. And it just so happens that one of my all-time favorite liquid eye shadow formulas comes courtesy of one of the best organic makeup brands, Crop Natural. The colors are shimmery, highly pigmented, and gorge, while application is foolproof—even if you're eye makeup challenged like me! 

I also recommend: 

Crop Natural Intense Matte Lipstick ($26)

8. Jillian Dempsey Cheek Tint

Jillian Dempsey Cheek Tint ($28)

Leave it to a celebrity makeup artist to create a luxurious makeup brand brimming with high-quality organic ingredients. Out of all the blushes I own (and typically I'm not even a cream-blush kind of gal), I find myself reaching for Jillian Dempsey's easy-to-use cheek tints over and over. The colors are designed to be universally flattering, and the consistency is easy to work into the apples of your cheeks while still playing nicely with any other makeup you're wearing. If you're after a believable, I-just-left-the-gym flush, this blush is for you.

I also recommend: 

Jillian Dempsey Khôl Eyeliner ($20)

9. Beautycounter Brilliant Brow Gel 

Beautycounter Brilliant Brow Gel ($24)

I'm going to put this super bluntly: 99% of organic brow products have left me extremely underwhelmed and borderline mortified. However, not only does this amazing gel formula with tons of organic ingredients not disappoint, but I'm giving it soaring kudos. I keep it right up there in the big leagues alongside my brow products from other (non-organic) brands like Anastasia Beverly Hills or Benefit Cosmetics. I love the invisible clear hue for days when I want to set my brows with a minimal-makeup vibe, and I reach for the Light tint when I'm wearing a full face. (It also has three darker shades beyond that.) 

I also recommend: 

Beautycounter Touchup Skin Concealer Pen ($33)

10. Kjaer Weiss Lip Gloss

Kjaer Weiss Lip Gloss ($38)

I'm not a huge lip gloss fan, but this slightly tinted, certified organic gloss from Kjaer Weiss is one of the few I not only can stand but actually really love. The subtle colors are so pretty and give my face a little bit of perk and glow when I'm feeling (or looking) sleep-deprived, and it never feels sticky or heavy on my lips. Plus, thanks to the rich infusion of oils like rose hip, castor, and sunflower, it's actually doing your pout some good too. I know spending nearly $40 on a lip gloss seems a tad steep, but this formula is a true diamond in the rough.

I also recommend: 

Kjaer Weiss Bronzer Compact ($56)

Up next: I Tried 37 Nontoxic Makeup Products—These Are the 16 I'll Actually Keep Using

This article originally appeared on Who What Wear

Read More from Who What Wear

  • A national lockdown to stop coronavirus? Trump is 'thinking about doing that'
    Yahoo News

    A national lockdown to stop coronavirus? Trump is 'thinking about doing that'

    President Trump shied away Wednesday from issuing domestic travel restrictions or a national lockdown to slow the spread of the coronavirus pandemic that, in a best-case scenario, is expected to kill between 100,000 and 240,000 Americans. Asked at a White House briefing if he was considering limiting domestic air travel, Trump said he was thinking about it, a phrase he frequently applies to subjects he wishes to avoid discussing. We're thinking about doing that, but at the same time we just, to start these airlines and to start this whole thing over again is very tough, John [Roberts, Fox News reporter].

  • Flattening the curve on coronavirus: What California and Washington can teach the world
    Yahoo News

    Flattening the curve on coronavirus: What California and Washington can teach the world

    Washington state, early, about two weeks before New York or New Jersey ... California, a week before New York or New Jersey, really talked to their communities and decided to mitigate before they started seeing this number of cases. And now we know that makes a big difference.

  • Two years before coronavirus, CDC warned of a coming pandemic
    Yahoo News

    Two years before coronavirus, CDC warned of a coming pandemic

    Two years ago, some of the nation's top public health officials gathered in an auditorium at Emory University in Atlanta to commemorate the 1918 influenza pandemic — also known as “the Spanish flu” — which had killed as many as 40 million people as it swept the globe. Implicit was the understanding that while the 1918 pandemic was a singular catastrophe, conditions in the 21st century were ideal for another outbreak. Long before the coronavirus emerged in Wuhan, China, and then soon spread to nearly every country on Earth, the 2018 conference offered proof that epidemiologists at the CDC and other institutions were aware that a new pandemic was poised to strike.

  • Coronavirus: 'Tiger King' star now in virus isolation, says husband
    BBC

    Coronavirus: 'Tiger King' star now in virus isolation, says husband

    Joe "Exotic" Maldonado-Passage - the star of Netflix hit Tiger King - has been placed in coronavirus isolation in a Texas prison, his husband says. Maldonado-Passage had recently been transferred from Oklahoma's Grady County Jail to the Federal Medical Center in Fort Worth, Texas, US media report. "We speak like three to five times every day, but since he's been moved to this new facility, they are putting him on a Covid-19 isolation because of the previous jail he was at, there were cases," Mr Passage, 24, told US entertainment reporter Andy Cohen.

  • China's Shenzhen bans the eating of cats and dogs after coronavirus
    Reuters

    China's Shenzhen bans the eating of cats and dogs after coronavirus

    The Chinese city of Shenzhen has banned the eating of dogs and cats as part of a wider clampdown on the wildlife trade since the emergence of the new coronavirus. Scientists suspect the coronavirus passed to humans from animals. Some of the earliest infections were found in people who had exposure to a wildlife market in the central city of Wuhan, where bats, snakes, civets and other animals were sold.

  • ‘We Didn’t Know That Until the Last 24 Hours’: Georgia Gov. Says He Just Found Out People without Symptoms Can Spread Coronavirus
    National Review

    ‘We Didn’t Know That Until the Last 24 Hours’: Georgia Gov. Says He Just Found Out People without Symptoms Can Spread Coronavirus

    While announcing a statewide shelter-in-place order on Wednesday, Georgia governor Brian Kemp, a Republican, said that he had just been informed that asymptomatic individuals could spread the coronavirus. The illness “is now transmitting before people see signs….Those individuals could have been infecting people before they ever felt [symptoms],” Kemp said at a press conference. It has been widely known for months that the coronavirus can spread through asymptomatic transmission.

  • Coronavirus map of the US: latest cases state by state
    The Guardian

    Coronavirus map of the US: latest cases state by state

    The number of confirmed cases of Covid-19 continues to grow in the US. Mike Pence, the vice-president, is overseeing the US response to the coronavirus. So far, 80% of patients experience a mild form of the illness, which can include a fever and pneumonia, and many of these cases require little to no medical intervention.

  • Chinese government rejects allegations that its face masks were defective, tells countries to 'double check' instructions
    Business Insider

    Chinese government rejects allegations that its face masks were defective, tells countries to 'double check' instructions

    REUTERS/Marko Djurica The Chinese government is rebuffing the notion that its face masks exported to other countries were "defective" and suggested that the nations did not "double-check" the instructions. China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Thursday claimed in a tweet that the "true story" behind the alleged faulty face masks imported by the Netherlands was that the Chinese manufacturer explicitly "stated clearly that they are non-surgical." Representatives from the Chinese government in recent weeks shifted the narrative surrounding the coronavirus's origins by questioning its validity.

  • 10 Great Deals on Apparel From REI’s 25% off Sale
    Popular Mechanics

    10 Great Deals on Apparel From REI’s 25% off Sale

    Act fast to score discounts on Patagonia, Nike, Smartwool, and more. From Popular Mechanics

  • Bloomberg

    Biden Offers to Call Trump with Coronavirus Advice

    Democratic presidential front-runner Joe Biden's campaign said Wednesday it will be in touch with the White House to set up a call for the former vice president to offer his ideas on combating coronavirus to President Donald Trump after a top White House official complained the administration hadn't heard any suggestions from Biden. A day of back and forth between the president and his likely general election opponent culminated in Trump saying during a press briefing that he would “absolutely” take Biden's call. Oh absolutely, I'd love to speak with him,” Trump said.

  • Coronavirus poses special risk to millions of Americans with diabetes
    Yahoo News

    Coronavirus poses special risk to millions of Americans with diabetes

    As the worsening coronavirus pandemic continues to spread across the country, millions of Americans living with diabetes face heightened risks from COVID-19. Around 30 million Americans have diabetes, mostly of the type II (previously called “adult-onset”) variety. A quarter of U.S. adults with diabetes are over 65, an age that has been shown to delineate increased COVID-19 mortality rates.

  • 'Act as though it's going to be a lot longer': American in Wuhan warns U.S. over lockdowns
    NBC News

    'Act as though it's going to be a lot longer': American in Wuhan warns U.S. over lockdowns

    An American who spent more than two months locked down in the Chinese city of Wuhan, where the coronavirus epidemic first emerged, is urging people back home to prepare for a lengthy interruption to their lives. “Don't go into this thinking it's going to be over in a few weeks,” Benjamin Wilson told NBC News from his apartment in Wuhan where he and his family spent eight weeks in confinement. After initially experiencing problems getting evacuated back to the U.S., Wilson, 38, chose to stay in the city where he has lived for more than 16 years, with his Chinese wife, Li Qin, and seven-year-old daughter Jasmin as it went into lockdown in late January.

  • New Yorkers Are Right to Be Skeptical of Evangelical-Run Coronavirus Ward in Central Park
    The Daily Beast

    New Yorkers Are Right to Be Skeptical of Evangelical-Run Coronavirus Ward in Central Park

    If New York City wasn't under a strict stay-at-home order right now, protesters might be marching along Central Park. The 60-bed emergency field hospital is composed largely of tarp-wrapped tents and will function as a respiratory unit servicing overflow patients from Mount Sinai Hospital. City Mayor Bill de Blasio admitted he was “very concerned” about the operation and was sending people from his office to monitor Samaritan's Purse.

  • Pakistan worshippers clash with police trying to enforce coronavirus lockdown
    Reuters

    Pakistan worshippers clash with police trying to enforce coronavirus lockdown

    Pakistani Muslims at a Karachi mosque clashed with baton-wielding police trying to enforce new curbs on gatherings to prevent Friday prayers and contain coronavirus infections, officials said. TV footage showed dozens of people chasing two police vehicles and pelting them with stones as an officer fired in the air to disperse the crowd. After failing to persuade worshippers to pray at home last week, the government in Pakistan's southern province of Sindh, home to the financial hub of Karachi, enforced a lockdown for three hours beginning at noon on Friday, officials said.

  • Birx: 5 states could be among next coronavirus 'hot spots'
    Yahoo News Video

    Birx: 5 states could be among next coronavirus 'hot spots'

    Deborah Birx, the White House coronavirus response coordinator, listed several states that could be the next “hot spots” for large numbers of COVID-19 cases, based on how many positive cases they have now.

  • "Shoot them dead": Duterte orders police to kill Filipinos who defy coronavirus lockdown
    CBS News

    "Shoot them dead": Duterte orders police to kill Filipinos who defy coronavirus lockdown

    Despite that, many in a Manila slum took to the streets Wednesday to protest a lack of supplies, arguing they had not received any food packs since the lockdown started two weeks ago. "I will not hesitate my soldiers to shoot you," Duterte said in forceful tones Wednesday. On Thursday, as often happens after Duterte makes these sorts of inflammatory public remarks, Filipino officials rushed to insist that the president was simply using hyperbole to communicate the gravity of the situation.

  • Shenzhen becomes first Chinese city to ban eating cats and dogs
    BBC

    Shenzhen becomes first Chinese city to ban eating cats and dogs

    Shenzhen has become the first Chinese city to ban the sale and consumption of dog and cat meat. It comes after the coronavirus outbreak was linked to wildlife meat, prompting Chinese authorities to ban the trade and consumption of wild animals. Shenzhen went a step further, extending the ban to dogs and cats.

  • Elon Musk says the hospitals he sent medical machines to all confirmed they were 'critical' and traditional ventilators are arriving shortly
    Business Insider

    Elon Musk says the hospitals he sent medical machines to all confirmed they were 'critical' and traditional ventilators are arriving shortly

    REUTERS/Mike Blake/File Picture Elon Musk was criticized on Thursday for apparently sending BiPAP machines, not the life-support ventilators most-needed to save coronavirus patients, to a New York hospital. New York City Hospitals thanked Musk and Tesla in a tweet for sending "40 ventilators" to a hospital in Queens, but the photo appears to show a BiPAP machine, which is more commonly used for sleep apnea. Some medical experts have warned that CPAP and BiPAP machines could be harmful in treating coronavirus patients by potentially spreading the disease.

  • America is battling a pandemic. Why is Trump talking about war with Iran?
    The Week

    America is battling a pandemic. Why is Trump talking about war with Iran?

    Because an economy-wrecking pandemic isn't enough to deal with, the Trump administration is making aggressive noises at Iran. "Upon information and belief, Iran or its proxies are planning a sneak attack on U.S. troops and/or assets in Iraq," President Trump tweeted on Wednesday. The White House didn't provide any additional information about Trump's tweet or his claim of a "sneak attack" being planned.

  • More than 1,000 in US die in a single day from coronavirus, doubling the worst daily death toll of the flu
    USA TODAY

    More than 1,000 in US die in a single day from coronavirus, doubling the worst daily death toll of the flu

    The U.S. topped 1,000 coronavirus deaths in a single day for the first time Wednesday, a daily death toll more than double that of two of America's most deadly illnesses – lung cancer and the flu. Death counts from the virus are difficult to keep up to date, but the Johns Hopkins coronavirus database – whose sources include the World Health Organization, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the European CDC and the National Health Commission of China – shows that the U.S. hit 1,040 cases Wednesday at 10:25 p.m. EDT. Since the virus' first appearance in the U.S. in late January, 5,116 people have died and more than 215,000 have been infected.

  • The Trail Leading Back to the Wuhan Labs
    National Review

    The Trail Leading Back to the Wuhan Labs

    It is understandable that many would be wary of the notion that the origin of the coronavirus could be discovered by some documentary filmmaker who used to live in China. Matthew Tye, who creates YouTube videos, contends he has identified the source of the coronavirus — and a great deal of the information that he presents, obtained from public records posted on the Internet, checks out. The Wuhan Institute of Virology in China indeed posted a job opening on November 18, 2019, “asking for scientists to come research the relationship between the coronavirus and bats.”

  • NRA Sues New York State Governor Over Closure of Gun Stores
    Bloomberg

    NRA Sues New York State Governor Over Closure of Gun Stores

    Cuomo's March 20 executive order that included firearms retailers as non-essential businesses which must close is a “pointless and arbitrary attack on the constitutional rights of New York citizens and residents,” the NRA said in a complaint filed late Thursday in Syracuse, New York. New York ordered most businesses to close to prevent the spread of the virus, but deemed grocery stores, liquor stores, pharmacies and restaurants that do take-out as essential and allowed them to remain open. New York City is the center of the outbreak in the U.S., accounting for more than 1,300 of the 5,700 deaths in the country.

  • Catalan leader highlights equipment crunch at stressed hospitals
    Reuters

    Catalan leader highlights equipment crunch at stressed hospitals

    Hospitals in Catalonia are at "maximum stress", with this week and next likely to be the worst experienced by the Spanish region during the coronavirus crisis, its leader told Reuters. The main challenge was a shortage of equipment, with a "supply problem" in obtaining masks and ventilators, rather than of space after makeshift hospitals were built across the region, Catalan regional government chief Quim Torra said on Friday. "At the hospital level we are able to respond to all the cases that are arriving but we are at the limit," said Torra, who has recovered after testing positive for the coronavirus.

  • Students who canceled ill-fated spring break trip say they aren't getting refunds
    NBC News

    Students who canceled ill-fated spring break trip say they aren't getting refunds

    Parents of students who canceled a spring break trip to Mexico say the sponsoring company is not refunding their money and had reassured them beforehand that their children would be safe from the coronavirus. Yet 44 of the 70 young adults who took the trip returned to the U.S. with COVID-19, the disease associated with the virus, according to the University of Texas at Austin. The group traveled on a chartered plane to Cabo San Lucas about two weeks ago with JusCollege, a company based in Nevada that plans all-inclusive spring break trips.

  • Robert F. Kennedy’s Granddaughter and Her 8-Year-Old Son Feared Drowned After Canoe Accident
    The Daily Beast

    Robert F. Kennedy’s Granddaughter and Her 8-Year-Old Son Feared Drowned After Canoe Accident

    The granddaughter of Robert F. Kennedy and her 8-year-old son were missing on Friday after they took a canoe out into rough waters on Chesapeake Bay, near Annapolis, on Thursday evening. Maeve Kennedy Townsend McKean, 40, and her son, Gideon, rowed the canoe out around 4 p.m. to fetch a ball that had been kicked into the water by children playing in their yard, Maeve's husband, David McKean, told The Washington Post. An overturned canoe matching the description of the one that went missing was recovered, the Maryland Department of Natural Resources police said.