On withholding aid to Central America, Mulvaney was correct: 'We do that all the time'
October 25, 2019
Read full article
Sign in to post a message.
"Contrary to President Trump’s apparent understanding of how foreign aid is distributed, most economic aid provided by the U.S. is not transmitted directly to governments but is channeled through third parties (non-profits, non-governmental organizations, public-private partnerships and multilateral organizations like the World Bank and the United Nations) for specific projects intended to advance the interests of the U.S. as well as the country in which its delivered. In the case of Central America, American assistance was part of a comprehensive effort to address the causes of increased migration, from Northern Triangle countries in particular. The policy was begun by the Obama administration in 2015, with bipartisan support in Congress." There you have it, folks. The real reason aid was cut off. Besides enriching himself, his primary goal is to undo EVERYTHING accomplished by or started by Obama.
"More important, in McFarland’s view, is that the concessions sought from Ukraine weren’t to advance U.S. foreign policy goals, but Trump’s personal interest in disputing Russian help with his election and discrediting former Vice President Joe Biden."
That is it in a nutshell. Policy or personal, if it is personal it is not permittable if it is to enforce policy as decided by law it is.
THIS IS IT EXACTLY!
"More important, in McFarland’s view, is that the concessions sought from Ukraine weren’t to advance U.S. foreign policy goals, but Trump’s personal interest in disputing Russian help with his election and discrediting former Vice President Joe Biden." --- “First of all, Mulvaney was conflating regular diplomacy, where you engage in combination of persuasion, cajoling, sometimes pressure to advance United States security objectives, with doing the same stuff to advance the president’s reelection,” said McFarland. “That’s the difference, and it’s a big difference.”
"More important, in McFarland’s view, is that the concessions sought from Ukraine weren’t to advance U.S. foreign policy goals, but Trump’s personal interest in disputing Russian help with his election and discrediting former Vice President Joe Biden. "
That is the key point. And many on the right miss that when they point out that Biden withheld aid. Biden did it the right way, using the correct channels and for the right reasons.
We have always withheld funds to get what is needed, but not to get favors for personal, political gain for an individual.
Quite correct. It is done all the time.
But when it is done for the personal gain of an individual, or to try to influence an election said individual will be running in, it is flat ILLEGAL.
It's very naive to think that foreign aid are given without any string attached. As a matter of fact, foreign aid are used to gain concessions and access for political, diplomatic, military, or economic reasons. For example, US military aid to countries like Pakistan and Turkey allowed the US to build listening installations into Russia, Iran and other non-friendly government. Threatening to withhold aid to Central America helped push Mexico, Guatemala and El Salvador into tightening their borders to slow down the influx of illegal immigration into the US. Billions of US aid were poured into South Vietnam in order to stop the spread of communism (the Domino doctrine), an effort that ultimately failed.
Foreign aid works the same way as welfare and other social benefits in this country, the government doles out money in exchange for votes. Just look at the promises of trillion of dollars of spending that the Democratic candidates are offering, they do that because they want the votes.
People who think that foreign aid are given simply because of altruism reasons need to rethink that notion. Just like money is the number one tool to use to manipulate people, foreign aid works the very same way.
If we have lots of extra money, it should be going towards helping American citizens and American veterans.
Where's the criticism of the leadership of Guatemala, Honduras, El Salvador, etc? Apparently if they refuse to do anything to fix the problems in their country, it's okay for the USA to give them money, same as someone who refuses to work, so it's ok to just keep sending them Welfare checks.
There is a humongous difference between using aid to influence, even coerce allies to advanced our country’s interest and withholding Congressionally approved aid to a country that has already been invaded by our enemy for personal political purposes.
There's a big difference in withholding aid to coerce a country to align with US Policy and to do it to attack a political rival.
What to Read Next
Despite trade wars, Trump says US 'open for business'
11 big and not-so-big names granted clemency by Trump
Who got pardoned, who got shorter prison sentences under Trump's clemency spree?
The Atlantic Politics Daily: MAGA vs. the Coronavirus
2 big reasons behind Trump’s pardon of former San Francisco 49ers owner Eddie DeBartolo Jr.
The 10 richest Americans are just beginning to take sides in the 2020 presidential race
Kathy Ireland opens up about experiences with 'predators' in fashion: 'I know what a lot of these young girls go through'
Mike Bloomberg qualifies for next two debates, trails only Sanders in recent poll
Toddler's reaction to Target ad of boy in wheelchair goes viral: 'He couldn't stop looking'
'Education deserts' are a 'staggering' problem, and for-profit colleges are taking advantage
Trump declares himself 'chief law enforcement officer' as he issues numerous pardons
Report: Obama reportedly expects he'll have to play a 'prominent role' in uniting Democrats this summer
Yahoo News Video
Trump Raises Doubts Over India Trade Deal Ahead of Visit
PHOTOS: Ukraine International Airlines plane crashes in Iran killing all on board
Yahoo News Photo Staff
Stock market news live: Dow falls again after Apple warns of coronavirus, Nasdaq closes barely in the green
Coronavirus update: Apple, other businesses feel virus' chill: 'I think we're starting to worry'
Yahoo U: Breaking down ESG investing
Yahoo Finance Video
Blagojevich's sentence commuted
Yahoo News Video
McConnell slams 2020 Democratic presidential candidates
Yahoo News Video